Using Thermostats for Indoor Climate Control in Office Buildings: The Effect on Thermal Comfort

Γεώργιος Κόντες, Georgios B. Giannakis, Philipp Horn, Simone Steiger, Dimitrios RovasEnergies 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates whether standard thermostat control, which typically relies on dry-bulb air temperature, adequately ensures occupant thermal comfort in office buildings. Through detailed simulations of two distinct office buildings, the study reveals that simple air temperature setpoints are insufficient and can lead to discomfort. The findings emphasize the need for more sophisticated control strategies that consider building characteristics and environmental factors like humidity for truly human-centric building design and operation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Building energy management systems (BEMS) and control strategies often aim to balance energy consumption with occupant comfort. A common practice is to use thermostats that regulate dry-bulb air temperature within a predefined range, assuming this guarantees thermal comfort. However, existing guidelines and standards (like ISO 7730 and ASHRAE 55) often provide comfort limits based on operative temperature, which is a combination of air and radiant temperature. This creates a disconnect: thermostats measure air temperature, but comfort is influenced by operative temperature, humidity, solar radiation, and building characteristics. The paper addresses the critical gap in understanding whether current thermostat control practices, based solely on air temperature, actually achieve the intended thermal comfort for occupants, especially in buildings with diverse thermal properties and HVAC systems.

Methods

The researchers employed a simulation-based approach using two well-instrumented office buildings with contrasting characteristics:

  • TUC Building (Crete, Greece): A lightweight construction, low insulation, and poor airtightness building, representative of many South European structures.
  • ZUB Building (Kassel, Germany): A high-performance, low-energy building with high thermal mass, excellent airtightness, and exceptional insulation, built to passive house standards.

Detailed simulation models of these buildings were created using EnergyPlus (for TUC) and TRNSYS (for ZUB). The core of the methodology involved performing numerous simulation experiments under various conditions (summer/winter, different thermostat control strategies – air temperature vs. operative temperature). Thermal comfort was evaluated using the Fanger Predicted Mean Vote (PMV) and Predicted Percentage of Dissatisfied (PPD) indices, as defined by ISO 7730. Parametric studies were conducted by varying setpoints and control parameters to analyze their impact on comfort levels.

Datasets

The study did not use pre-existing datasets for training. Instead, it relied on:

  • Building simulation models: Detailed models of the TUC and ZUB buildings were developed based on their as-built conditions, construction data, and available floor plans.
  • Weather data: Meteonorm weather files were used to simulate realistic external conditions for the chosen periods.
  • Occupant behavior data: Information on occupant density, metabolic rates, and clothing insulation (clo values) were incorporated into the models, often based on standard assumptions from ISO 7730.

The study's findings were validated against sensor data from the actual buildings where available, ensuring the simulation models accurately captured building behavior.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Air temperature is a poor proxy for operative temperature: The study strongly demonstrates that dry-bulb air temperature alone is insufficient to guarantee thermal comfort. Significant discrepancies between air and operative temperatures were observed, particularly in the lightweight TUC building, due to factors like radiant temperature from surfaces and HVAC system dynamics.
  • Building characteristics matter significantly: The difference in thermal mass and insulation between the TUC and ZUB buildings led to vastly different thermal responses and required distinct control strategies. High thermal mass buildings (like ZUB) showed less divergence between air and operative temperatures.
  • Humidity plays a crucial role: The simulations revealed that standard comfort calculations often assume a constant relative humidity. However, actual dynamic humidity levels (which were lower in the simulations than assumed in ISO 7730) significantly impacted thermal sensation, leading to potential discomfort even when temperature setpoints seemed appropriate.
  • Standard comfort bounds need adaptation: The study highlights that the comfort temperature bands provided in standards like ISO 7730, derived under specific assumptions, are not universally applicable. They need to be adapted based on the building's specific thermal properties, HVAC system, and prevailing environmental conditions (especially humidity).
  • Simple thermostats can lead to over-cooling/heating: In some scenarios, controlling to meet operative temperature setpoints resulted in over-cooling, leading to higher PPD values and discomfort, indicating that even a more direct control target can be problematic without considering other factors.

Key Results

  • Summer experiments (TUC Building):
    • Air temperature control at 24.5°C in Office 08 (north-facing) maintained comfort within acceptable limits, but operative temperature was higher than air temperature.
  • In Office 04 (south-facing), air temperature control also maintained comfort, but operative temperature showed higher variability due to solar gains.
  • Switching to operative temperature control at 24.5°C in summer led to over-cooling and higher discomfort in both offices.
  • Increasing the operative temperature setpoint to 25.5°C significantly improved comfort levels, demonstrating the impact of humidity and the need for adjusted setpoints.
  • Winter experiments (TUC Building):
    • Air temperature control at 22°C in Office 08 resulted in operative temperatures lower than air temperature, with comfort generally within acceptable limits, though humidity spikes caused temporary discomfort.
  • Office 04 showed similar trends but with more pronounced temperature fluctuations due to solar gains.
  • Controlling operative temperature at 22°C led to improved comfort in both offices compared to air temperature control.
  • ZUB Building (Winter):
    • Experiments with air temperature control at 21°C showed that air and operative temperatures coincided due to the building's heavy construction and insulation.
  • However, the study noted a potential overheating problem with TABS systems, suggesting the need for advanced control strategies that incorporate weather and occupancy forecasts.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simulation-based study: While validated against real building data, the study is primarily simulation-based. Real-world occupant interactions and adaptive behaviors could introduce further complexities.
  • Deterministic occupant behavior: The simulations assumed deterministic occupant behavior and internal gains. Future work could explore stochastic occupant models to better represent real-world variability.
  • Limited scope of ZUB building: Only winter experiments were conducted for the ZUB building, and specific control strategies were employed. Further investigation into summer operation and different control scenarios for this building type would be beneficial.
  • Future Work Suggestions:
    • Develop and implement more sophisticated, human-centric control strategies that integrate detailed thermal comfort indices (like Fanger) and personalized comfort models.
  • Adapt thermal comfort constraints based on actual environmental (humidity) and personal (e.g., clo value) influencing factors, rather than relying solely on fixed temperature bounds.
  • Explore the integration of weather and occupancy forecasts into control strategies, especially for buildings with systems like TABS, to proactively manage comfort and energy use.
  • Further investigate the impact of humidity and other less-considered environmental factors on thermal comfort across a wider range of building types and climates.

Summary updated

Abstract

Thermostats are widely used in temperature regulation of indoor spaces and have a direct impact on energy use and occupant thermal comfort. Existing guidelines make recommendations for properly selecting set points to reduce energy use, but there is little or no information regarding the actual achieved thermal comfort of the occupants. While dry-bulb air temperature measured at the thermostat location is sometimes a good proxy, there is less understanding of whether thermal comfort targets are actually met. In this direction, we have defined an experimental simulation protocol involving two office buildings; the buildings have contrasting geometrical and construction characteristics, as well as different building services systems for meeting heating and cooling demands. A parametric analysis is performed for combinations of controlled variables and boundary conditions. In all cases, occupant thermal comfort is estimated using the Fanger index, as defined in ISO 7730. The results of the parametric study suggest that simple bounds on the dry-bulb air temperature are not sufficient to ensure comfort, and in many cases, more detailed considerations taking into account building characteristics, as well as the types of building heating and cooling services are required. The implication is that the calculation or estimation of detailed comfort indices, or even the use of personalised comfort models, is key towards a more human-centric approach to building design and operation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{2017using,
  author = {Γεώργιος Κόντες and Georgios B. Giannakis and Philipp Horn and Simone Steiger and Dimitrios Rovas},
  title = {{Using Thermostats for Indoor Climate Control in Office Buildings: The Effect on Thermal Comfort}},
  booktitle = {Energies},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3390/en10091368},
}
Figure