Using the Carnot cycle to determine changes of the phase transition temperature

Oskar Grocholski, K. Howil, Stanisław Rakowski, Piotr MaksymiukAmerican 2021 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract: The Clausius–Clapeyron relation and its analogs in other first-order phase transitions, such as type-I superconductors, are derived using elementary methods without appealing to advanced concepts like entropy or Gibbs free energy. Based on Kelvin's formulation of the second law of thermodynamics, this approach is accessible to a broad audience. By constructing hypothetical heat engines that exploit phase transitions (e.g., ice/water or normal/superconductor), we show that if the transition temperature were independent of external parameters like pressure or magnetic field, it would be possible to construct a perpetuum mobile of the second kind. Equating the efficiency of these reversible cycles to the Carnot efficiency yields the governing equations for phase boundaries.

Introduction: The "Black Box" of Phase Transitions

In introductory thermodynamics, the Clausius-Clapeyron equation is often presented as a finished product or derived using the abstract machinery of Gibbs free energy and chemical potential. While mathematically rigorous, this "top-down" approach can obscure the physical intuition behind why a transition temperature must shift when an external parameter, such as pressure, changes. This paper bridges that gap by relying solely on Kelvin’s formulation of the Second Law: it is impossible to build an engine that does nothing but convert heat from a single reservoir into work.

The Ice Engine Thought Experiment

The core methodology employs a "reductio ad absurdum" thought experiment. Consider a working substance that undergoes a first-order phase transition, such as water freezing into ice. Lord Kelvin realized in 1844 that if the melting point of ice did not decrease under pressure, one could create a cycle that produces net work from a single heat reservoir.

A four-step cycle of a piston-based "ice engine" where adding and removing a weight $p_2$ during phase changes produces mechanical work.

As shown in the figure above, the cycle involves:

  1. Starting with water at temperature $T_1$ and pressure $p_1$.
  2. Increasing the pressure to $p_2$ by adding a weight.
  3. Freezing the water into ice at temperature $T_2$. Because ice has a larger volume than water, it lifts the weight, performing work.
  4. Removing the weight (reducing pressure back to $p_1$) and melting the ice back to water at $T_1$.

If $T_1 = T_2$, the system returns to its original state having performed net work (lifting the weight) while exchanging heat with only one reservoir—a direct violation of the Second Law. Therefore, the transition temperature must change with pressure.

Geometric Intuition and the Carnot Limit

By representing this process on a pressure-temperature ($p-T$) phase diagram, the derivation becomes a matter of geometric intuition. The "area" of the cycle on the diagram represents the net work produced, while the heat absorbed is the latent heat of the transition.

The "ice engine" cycle represented on a $p-T$ phase diagram. The area of the rectangle 1-2-3-4 corresponds to the work produced during the cycle.

Since these cycles can be made reversible in the limit of infinitesimal changes, their efficiency must exactly match the Carnot efficiency: $$\eta = \frac{\Delta W}{Q} = \frac{\Delta T}{T}$$ By setting the mechanical work produced by the phase change equal to this Carnot limit, the standard Clausius-Clapeyron relation emerges naturally: $$\frac{\Delta p}{\Delta T} = \frac{l}{T \Delta v}$$ where $l$ is the latent heat and $\Delta v$ is the change in molar volume.

Universal Application: Superconductors and Beyond

This method is not limited to the ice-water transition. The authors apply the same logic to Type-I superconductors, where the external parameter is a magnetic field ($B$). Because superconductors expel magnetic fields (the Meissner effect), they can exert mechanical force. The derivation shows that the critical magnetic field $B_c$ must depend on temperature to prevent a Second Law violation, leading to the superconducting analog: $$\frac{\Delta B}{\Delta T} = -\frac{L \mu_0}{V B T}$$

In conclusion, this "back-to-basics" approach provides a robust toolkit for explaining complex thermodynamic relations through simple machines. While limited to first-order transitions with discontinuous changes, it offers a powerful pedagogical alternative to traditional derivations.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Clausius–Clapeyron relation and its analogs in other first-order phase transitions, such as type-I superconductors, are derived using very elementary methods without appealing to the more advanced concepts of entropy or Gibbs free energy. The reasoning is based on Kelvin's formulation of the second law of thermodynamics and should be accessible to high school students. After recalling some basic facts about the Carnot cycle, we present two very different systems that undergo discontinuous phase transitions (ice/water and normal/superconductor) and construct engines that exploit the properties of these systems to produce work. In each case, we show that if the transition temperature Ttr was independent of other parameters, such as pressure or magnetic field, it would be possible to violate Kelvin's principle, i.e., to construct a perpetuum mobile of the second kind. Since the proposed cyclic processes can be realized reversibly in the limit of infinitesimal changes in temperature, their efficiencies must be equal to that of an ordinary Carnot cycle. We immediately obtain an equation of the form dT/dX=f(T,X), which governs how the transition temperature changes with the parameter X.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{grocholski2021using,
  author = {Oskar Grocholski and K. Howil and Stanisław Rakowski and Piotr Maksymiuk},
  title = {{Using the Carnot cycle to determine changes of the phase transition temperature}},
  booktitle = {American},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1119/10.0006455},
}

Loading related content...

Figure