Using the alternative model of personality disorders for DSM-5 traits to identify personality types, and the relationship with disordered eating, depression, anxiety and stress

Tanya Gilmartin, Caroline Gurvich, Joanna F. Dipnall, Gemma SharpJournal of Eating Disorders 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study leverages the DSM-5's alternative model of personality disorders to identify distinct personality types in young adults. It reveals that "overcontrolled," "undercontrolled," and a newly identified "antisocial/psychoticism" personality profile are significantly associated with increased disordered eating, depression, anxiety, and stress, while a "resilient" type appears protective.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding personality types has long been linked to disordered eating and treatment outcomes. However, traditional categorical approaches to personality disorders are being supplemented by dimensional models, like the DSM-5's Alternative Model of Personality Disorders (AMPD). This paper addresses the gap in understanding how these dimensional personality traits can be used to identify distinct personality types and how these types relate to significant mental health challenges, specifically disordered eating, depression, anxiety, and stress, in a young adult population. Existing research has primarily focused on normative personality traits, leaving a need to explore the clinical utility of dimensional pathology measures for personality typing.

Methods

The researchers employed a systematic, multi-stage clustering approach to identify personality types within their dataset. This involved:

  • Hierarchical, k-means, and Random Forest Cluster Analyses: These algorithms were used to group participants based on their scores across 25 pathological personality traits from the PID-5-SF (Personality Inventory for DSM-5 Short Form).
  • Model Selection: The Akaike Information Criterion (AIC), Bayesian Information Criterion (BIC), and silhouette values were used to determine the optimal number of clusters. A four-cluster solution was identified as the best fit.
  • Cluster Naming: Clusters were named based on the patterns of personality traits observed within each group, further informed by one-way ANOVAs.
  • Association Analysis: One-way ANOVAs were used to examine differences in eating pathology, depression, anxiety, and stress scores across the identified clusters.
  • Predictive Modeling: Multivariable linear regression was conducted to assess how cluster membership predicted these clinical outcomes, controlling for age and gender.

Datasets

The study utilized data from a sample of 568 individuals (aged 16-31 years) recruited in Australia. The sample comprised 391 women (68.8%), 167 men (29.4%), and 10 gender-diverse individuals (1.8%). The data was collected between December 2020 and May 2021. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; the study utilized existing validated measures.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dimensional Traits Define Types: The study demonstrates that the dimensional traits of the DSM-5 AMPD can indeed be used to delineate distinct personality types, moving beyond traditional categorical diagnoses.
  • The "Antisocial/Psychoticism" Cluster: A novel finding is the identification of a fourth cluster characterized by antisocial and psychoticism traits, which was not consistently found in previous research focusing on fewer clusters or different methodologies.
  • Resilience as a Protective Factor: The "resilient" cluster stands out as a protective factor, showing significantly lower scores across all clinical measures compared to the other identified personality types.
  • Undercontrol as a High-Risk Profile: The "undercontrolled" cluster emerged as the highest risk group, scoring significantly higher than all other clusters on measures of eating pathology, depression, anxiety, and stress.
  • Gender Differences in Presentation: While the study controlled for gender, the observation that women were significant predictors of eating pathology and stress suggests that gender plays a role in how these personality types manifest clinically.

Key Results

  • A four-cluster solution was identified as the best fit for the data:
  • Cluster 1: Maladaptive Overcontrol (OC) (27.29% of sample)
    • Cluster 2: Maladaptive Undercontrol (UC) (24.47% of sample)
    • Cluster 3: Resilient (27.46% of sample)
    • Cluster 4: Antisocial/Psychoticism (20.77% of sample)
  • The maladaptive OC, UC, and antisocial/psychoticism clusters all showed significantly higher scores on measures of disordered eating, eating pathology, depression, anxiety, and stress compared to the resilient cluster.
  • The maladaptive UC cluster scored significantly higher than the other three clusters on all measures of clinical pathology.
  • A significant association was found between cluster group and clinical EDE-QS scores (X²(N=565) = 87.84, p<0.001), with individuals in the high psychopathology clusters being more likely to achieve clinical scores.
  • Linear regression analyses indicated that being in the Maladaptive OC, Maladaptive UC, or Antisocial/Psychoticism clusters significantly predicted higher scores on EDE-QS, DASS-21 Depression, and DASS-21 Anxiety. The UC cluster contributed substantially to explaining variability in these outcomes.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Sample Demographics: The majority of the sample was Caucasian, which may limit the generalizability of findings to other ethnic groups. The sample also had a higher proportion of women than men or gender-diverse individuals, potentially limiting generalizability to these groups.
  • COVID-19 Context: Data was collected during the COVID-19 pandemic, which may have influenced psychological distress and eating behaviors. Future research should investigate if these findings hold in a post-pandemic context.
  • Self-Report Measures: Reliance on self-report measures introduces potential biases, such as individuals inaccurately describing their traits or distorting their presentation.
  • Exploratory Nature: The study is exploratory, and further research is needed to validate the findings and the utility of the PID-5-SF for personality typing.

Future work suggested includes:

  • Replicating these findings in more diverse samples.
  • Investigating the appropriateness of the PID-5-SF as a measure for identifying personality types in clinical settings.
  • Examining whether personality types identified using the PID-5-SF can predict treatment outcomes, building on existing research.
  • Further exploring the characteristics and implications of the newly identified "antisocial/psychoticism" cluster.

Summary updated

Abstract

Pathological personality traits, as conceptualised within the DSM-5 alternative model of personality disorders may have merit for identifying overcontrol and undercontrol personality types. Our findings provide additional evidence that both overcontrol and undercontrol personality types are associated with increased eating pathology, depression, anxiety and stress.
BibTeX
@article{gilmartin2025using,
  author = {Tanya Gilmartin and Caroline Gurvich and Joanna F. Dipnall and Gemma Sharp},
  title = {{Using the alternative model of personality disorders for DSM-5 traits to identify personality types, and the relationship with disordered eating, depression, anxiety and stress}},
  journal = {Journal of Eating Disorders},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1186/s40337-025-01204-2},
}
Figure