Using RDF Summary Graph For Keyword-based Semantic Searches

Serkan Ayvaz, Mehmet AydararXiv 2017 · arXiv · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces a semantic search framework for RDF data that uses a "summary graph" to efficiently find relevant entities based on keyword queries. By leveraging entity type semantics and near-neighbor exploration within this summary graph, the system aims to provide more accurate and semantically rich search results than traditional keyword matching.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Semantic Web, with its RDF data model, promises a more interconnected and machine-understandable web. However, efficiently searching this vast and complex data landscape remains a challenge. Traditional keyword searches on the web are often too simplistic for structured RDF data, while formal query languages like SPARQL are too complex for the average user. This paper tackles the problem of bridging this gap by enabling intuitive, keyword-based semantic searches on RDF data, going beyond simple string matching to understand the underlying meaning and relationships between entities.

Methods

The core of the proposed framework is the construction and utilization of an RDF Summary Graph. This summary graph is automatically generated from the underlying RDF data and captures key semantic relationships, entity types, and similarities.

Here's a breakdown of their approach:

  • Summary Graph Construction: The process involves computing pairwise similarities between entities. Instead of comparing all neighbors to all neighbors, they focus on comparing neighbors connected by the same predicate. They employ a similarity measure that iteratively refines similarity scores based on common predicates and neighborhood relationships. For literal nodes, string similarity combined with TF-IDF weighting is used.
  • Keyword Indexing: A keyword index is created to map user-supplied keywords to graph elements (entities, classes, properties, literals).
  • Search Algorithm: When a keyword query is received, the system first identifies potential "hits" in the keyword index. It then explores the summary graph, considering both direct hits and their "neighbors" (entities semantically related through the summary graph). A similarity threshold is used to filter candidates.
  • Ranking and Relevance Scoring: The framework ranks candidates based on their semantic relatedness, considering both their similarity to the query and their entity type. A "Relevance Confidence Score" is generated for each result, indicating the inferred semantic relatedness.

Datasets

The evaluation was performed on a subset of DBpedia containing 10,000 triples. The authors note that DBpedia was chosen as a well-known, general-purpose dataset suitable for evaluating semantic search applications. They also mention the need for future evaluations on larger and more diverse datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beyond String Matching: The most significant insight is the move away from simple keyword matching towards understanding semantic relationships. By using a summary graph, the system can infer connections between entities that might not share exact keywords but are semantically linked through their types and properties.
  • The Power of Entity Types: Entity type information plays a crucial role in ranking results. This suggests that understanding what an entity is (e.g., a person, a country, a disease) is as important as its descriptive keywords for semantic search.
  • Summary Graph Efficiency: Constructing a summary graph upfront allows for faster query processing. This pre-computation step offloads the most resource-intensive tasks, making the search responsive.
  • Near-Neighbor Exploration: The concept of exploring "near neighbors" in the summary graph is key to discovering related entities that might not be directly obvious from the initial keyword hits.

Key Results

The framework was evaluated using precision, recall, and F-measure. For entity search queries on the DBpedia subset, the system achieved:

  • Average Precision: 0.652
  • Average Recall: 0.891
  • Macro-averaged F-measure: 0.753

The authors highlight the high recall (over 0.89) as particularly important, especially in specialized domains where missing relevant results is undesirable. They also provide qualitative examples, such as finding "Acacia" and "Aloe" for a query related to plants, and identifying "Anna Kournikova" as related to "Andre Agassi" due to their shared entity type (athlete) and inferred semantic connections.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Dataset Dependency: The accuracy of the search results is acknowledged to be dependent on the accuracy of the summary graph generation and the characteristics of the underlying dataset.
  • Future Evaluations: The authors plan to conduct further evaluations on larger and more diverse datasets from various domains.
  • Question Answering: The current framework focuses on entity and list search. Future work includes extending it to handle Question Answering (QA) queries by developing mechanisms for natural language query processing and transformation.

Summary updated

Abstract

The Semantic Web began to emerge as its standards and technologies developed rapidly in the recent years. The continuing development of Semantic Web technologies has facilitated publishing explicit semantics with data on the Web in RDF data model. This study proposes a semantic search framework to support efficient keyword-based semantic search on RDF data utilizing near neighbor explorations. The framework augments the search results with the resources in close proximity by utilizing the entity type semantics. Along with the search results, the system generates a relevance confidence score measuring the inferred semantic relatedness of returned entities based on the degree of similarity. Furthermore, the evaluations assessing the effectiveness of the framework and the accuracy of the results are presented.
BibTeX
@misc{ayvaz2017using,
  author = {Serkan Ayvaz and Mehmet Aydar},
  title = {{Using RDF Summary Graph For Keyword-based Semantic Searches}},
  year = {2017},
  eprint = {1707.03602},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1707.03602},
}
Figure