Using Polygraph to Detect Passengers Carrying Illegal Items

Runxin Yu, Si Wu, Audrey Huang, Nathan Gold, Huaxiong Huang, Genyue Fu, Kang LeeFrontiers in Psychology 2019 · DOI

Abstract

The present study examined the effectiveness of a Modified-Comparison Questions Technique (Modified-CQT), used in conjunction with the polygraph, to differentiate between common travelers, drug traffickers, and terrorists at transportation hubs. Two experiments were conducted using a mock crime paradigm. In Experiment 1, 78 participants were randomly assigned to either a drug condition (packing and lying about illicit drugs) or a control condition. In Experiment 2, 164 participants were assigned to control, drug, or a bomb condition (packing and lying about a bomb). Physiological markers including RR interval, heart rate, and Galvanic Skin Response (GSR) were measured. Discriminant Analyses revealed accurate classifications above chance level: Experiment 1 (84.2% drug vs. 82.5% control) and Experiment 2 (up to 95.1% accuracy). These findings indicate that Modified-CQT is a viable method for investigating suspects of drug trafficking and terrorism at transportation hubs.

Introduction: Addressing Security Gaps at Transportation Hubs

Security at transportation hubs like airports and train stations remains a critical challenge. Authorities constantly seek to identify smugglers and terrorists, yet current behavioral detection methods—such as analyzing facial expressions or body language—are notoriously unreliable and prone to high error rates.

Traditional polygraph techniques also face scientific and practical hurdles. The Comparison Question Technique (CQT), while widely used by law enforcement, is often criticized for lacking a solid theoretical foundation. Conversely, the Concealed Information Technique (CIT) is scientifically respected but difficult to apply in screening scenarios because it requires interrogators to possess specific details of a crime known only to the perpetrator—information rarely available before a suspect is identified. This research seeks to bridge this gap by introducing a modified protocol that is both scientifically rigorous and practically applicable to general security screening.

Methodology: The Modified-CQT Framework

The researchers developed the Modified-CQT, which blends the structure of traditional polygraphy with Orienting Response (OR) theory. This theory posits that significant or novel stimuli trigger a specific physiological "freeze" or "pay attention" reflex.

Figure 1: Flowchart of the experimental procedure from the participant's perspective.

The protocol utilized a "mock crime" paradigm across two experiments. Participants followed a structured sequence involving random assignment to a condition (Control, Drug, or Bomb) and a staging phase where they packed their luggage according to their assigned role.

Figure 2: Experimental setup showing the staging room (A) where participants packed items and the testing room (B) where physiological data was recorded.

The polygraph test involved three types of questions:

  • Basic Personal Information: Baseline for truthful physiological states.
  • Common Travel Items: Baseline for context-relevant items (e.g., clothes, books).
  • Crime-Related Questions: Specific inquiries about illegal items (e.g., "Did you pack a bomb?").

Physiological data was captured using Electrocardiography (ECG) to measure heart rate and RR intervals, and Galvanic Skin Response (GSR) to measure skin conductivity. To enhance psychological stakes, a "rigged card test" was used to convince participants of the polygraph's infallibility.

Key Insights: The Physiology of Deception

The study revealed several critical physiological patterns:

  • Heart Rate Deceleration: Contrary to the common belief that lying causes a racing heart, "guilty" participants experienced decelerated heart rates (increased RR intervals) when lying about their crime. This confirms the Orienting Response (OR) as a primary mechanism in this context.
  • Specificity of Guilt: Physiological responses were specific to the type of crime. A "drug smuggler" reacted more strongly to drug-related questions than bomb-related ones, suggesting the polygraph detects specific cognitive reactions rather than general anxiety.
  • GSR as a Primary Predictor: While heart rate was a useful marker, the peak-to-peak amplitude of the skin response (GSR) proved to be the most reliable indicator of deception.

Results and Classification Accuracy

The Modified-CQT demonstrated high accuracy in distinguishing between innocent and guilty participants using Discriminant Analysis (DA):

  • Experiment 1 (Drug vs. Control): Correctly identified 84.2% of "smugglers" and 82.5% of "innocents."
  • Experiment 2 (Multi-threat):
    • Drug vs. Control: 82.1% (guilty) vs. 95.1% (innocent).
  • Bomb vs. Control: 93.2% (guilty) vs. 95.1% (innocent).
  • Drug vs. Bomb: The model distinguished between the two types of "criminals" with approximately 91-92% accuracy.

Limitations and Future Directions

While promising, the authors note several hurdles for real-world implementation. The "mock crime" lab setting lacks the life-altering consequences of real-world airport security, which may influence physiological signatures. Additionally, the current setup requires physical electrodes, which is impractical for high-volume passenger screening.

Future research should explore contactless technology, such as thermal imaging or Transdermal Optical Imaging, to detect these physiological changes remotely. Furthermore, testing across more diverse populations is necessary to ensure the Modified-CQT's universal applicability.

Summary updated

Abstract

The present study examined the effectiveness of a Modified-Comparison Questions Technique, used in conjunction with the polygraph, to differentiate between common travelers, drug traffickers, and terrorists at transportation hubs. Two experiments were conducted using a mock crime paradigm. In Experiment 1, we randomly assigned 78 participants to either a drug condition, where they packed and lied about illicit drugs in their luggage, or a control condition, where they did not pack or lie about any illegal items. In Experiment 2, we randomly assigned 164 participants to one of the two conditions in Experiment 1 or an additional bomb condition, where they packed and lied about a bomb in their luggage. For both experiments, we assessed participants' RR interval, heart rate, peak-to-peak amplitude of Galvanic Skin Response (GSR) and all three combined, using Discriminant Analyses to determine the classification accuracy of participants in each condition. In both experiments, we found decelerated heart rates and increased peak-to-peak amplitude of GSR in guilty participants when lying in response to questions regarding their crime. We also found accurate classifications of participants, in both Experiment 1 (drug vs. control: 84.2% vs. 82.5%) and Experiment 2 (drug vs. control: 82:1% vs. 95.1%; bomb vs. control: 93.2% vs. 95.1%; drug vs. bomb: 92.3% vs. 90.9%), above chance level. These findings indicate that Modified-CQT, combined with a polygraph test, is a viable method for investigating suspects of drug trafficking and terrorism at transportation hubs such as train stations and airports.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yu2019using,
  author = {Runxin Yu and Si Wu and Audrey Huang and Nathan Gold and Huaxiong Huang and Genyue Fu and Kang Lee},
  title = {{Using Polygraph to Detect Passengers Carrying Illegal Items}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2019.00322},
}
Figure