Using POI Data to Identify the Demand for Pedestrian Crossing Facilities at Mid-Block

Weifeng Li, Jiawei He, Qing Yu, Yujiao Chang, Peng LiuSustainability 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes a novel method to identify areas with high demand for pedestrian crossing facilities at mid-block locations in Chinese cities, using Point of Interest (POI) data to estimate pedestrian crossing intensity. The approach combines POI density with road network characteristics to pinpoint critical sections, offering a data-driven solution for improving urban walkability and non-motorized transport.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Chinese cities often suffer from a sparse road network, which, while prioritizing vehicular traffic, creates significant challenges for pedestrians. This includes long distances between intersections, forcing pedestrians to cross roads at inconvenient or unsafe mid-block locations. Existing research has focused on pedestrian behavior and the impact of the built environment on crossing volumes, but there's a gap in directly identifying where the demand for mid-block crossing facilities is highest. This lack of demand-specific data hinders effective urban planning for pedestrian infrastructure. The paper aims to fill this gap by developing a method to pinpoint these high-demand areas, thereby supporting targeted improvements to pedestrian safety and convenience.

Methods

The core of the paper's methodology involves a two-pronged approach:

  1. Pedestrian Crossing Demand Intensity Calculation:
    • POI Reclassification: POIs are first categorized into "Large POIs" (universities, hospitals, parks) and "General POIs" (everything else). Large POIs are further refined based on function. For function identification of road sections, POIs are reclassified into six broader categories (Commercial, Life Service, Enterprise Service, Public Service, Education and Research, Culture and Tourism).
  2. Association with Road Sections: A 50-meter buffer is created on both sides of road sections to associate nearby POIs.
  3. Demand Intensity Formula: A weighted sum of POI categories is used to calculate "pedestrian crossing demand intensity" for each road section. The weights are determined using standard variance, giving more importance to POI categories with greater variability across road sections. The formula is empirically derived based on the reclassified POI categories and their observed influence.
  4. Target Road Section Identification:
    • Length Threshold: Road sections longer than 400 meters are considered, as shorter sections can typically be served by intersection crossings.
  5. Demand Intensity Threshold: A threshold of 2 is set for the calculated pedestrian crossing demand intensity, based on observations from typical busy commercial areas in Shanghai.
  6. Mobile Phone Data Validation: Continuous mobile phone location data is used to measure residents' activity intensity across different areas. This data is binned into 500m x 500m cells. The distribution of identified target road sections is then compared with areas of high resident activity to validate the method's effectiveness.

Datasets

  • Point of Interest (POI) Data: Obtained from the Baidu Map open platform for the central city of Shanghai. Approximately 723,649 POIs were collected between February 23-26, 2018. After cleaning and filtering, 236,322 useful POIs were retained.
  • Mobile Phone Data: Provided by a mobile communication operator in Shanghai, covering September 8-11, 2011. This data captures continuous cell phone usage and location information to infer residents' activity intensity.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • POI Density as a Proxy for Pedestrian Demand: The paper posits that the clustering of POIs, particularly those attracting significant foot traffic, directly correlates with pedestrian crossing demand at nearby mid-block locations. This is a crucial insight for leveraging readily available digital data for urban planning.
  • Synthesizing Supply and Demand: The method uniquely combines "supply" (road section length) with "demand" (POI-derived pedestrian crossing intensity) to identify problematic areas. This holistic approach is more robust than considering either factor in isolation.
  • Reclassification is Key: The paper highlights the necessity of reclassifying raw POI data into meaningful categories that reflect their impact on pedestrian activity and road section function. Generic categories are insufficient for nuanced analysis.
  • Mid-Block Focus is Critical: By explicitly excluding POIs near intersections, the study hones in on the specific problem of mid-block crossings, which are often overlooked in broader pedestrian infrastructure planning.
  • Mobile Data as a Powerful Validation Tool: Using mobile phone data to validate the identified target road sections provides strong empirical support for the POI-based method, demonstrating its real-world applicability.

Key Results

  • Identification of 215 Target Road Sections: The proposed method successfully identified 215 road sections in Shanghai's Puxi region that exhibit a strong demand for pedestrian crossing facilities at mid-block.
  • Geographic Concentration: Most of these target road sections are concentrated in Puxi, attributed to its longer development history and higher resident density compared to Pudong.
  • Functional Diversity: The majority of identified road sections were classified as having mixed functions, followed by commercial functions. Life service functions were the least prevalent among the target sections.
  • Validation with Mobile Data: The study found a strong correlation between the identified target road sections and areas with high resident activity intensity derived from mobile phone data. Specifically, 87.91% of target road sections were located in areas with high or very high activity intensity during weekdays. This high overlap indicates the reliability of the identification results.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Spatial Scale of POIs: The paper acknowledges that the spatial scale or area of different POIs is not fully accounted for, as the method primarily measures demand based on the diversity of POIs. This is a trade-off due to the lack of detailed Area of Interest (AOI) data.
  • Other Influencing Factors: The authors suggest that future work should incorporate more factors influencing pedestrian crossing demand, such as the quality of walking space and the design of intersections.
  • Data Acquisition: For future improvements, the paper proposes using questionnaire surveys or pedestrian traffic detectors to acquire more direct and granular data on real pedestrian crossing demand.
  • Generalizability: While Shanghai is used as a case study, the method's applicability to other cities, especially those in similar stages of development, is implied but not exhaustively tested.

Summary updated

Abstract

In Chinese cities, the widespread problem of the low density of the road network has seriously damaged the convenience of pedestrian crossing, resulting in an unfriendly pedestrian experience and restricted development of non-motorized traffic within the city. Only by accurately capturing the crossing needs of pedestrians can we adopt a targeted approach to improve the pedestrian crossing experience. In this paper, the demand and supply are considered synthetically, and a method of using point of interest (POI) data to analyze the demand for pedestrian crossing facilities at the mid-block is proposed. First, we developed the method of calculating the pedestrian crossing demand intensity based on POI data. Secondly, based on the appropriate length threshold and pedestrian crossing demand intensity threshold, a series of road sections with strong demand for pedestrian crossing facilities are identified in the study area. Finally, we use mobile phone data to obtain the intensity of residents’ activity in different areas, and find that the distribution of the areas with more activity is basically the same as that of the target road sections. The result shows that the method proposed in this paper can effectively identify the road sections with strong demand for crossing facilities at mid-block, and can provide support for the improvement of urban non-motorized traffic.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2021using,
  author = {Weifeng Li and Jiawei He and Qing Yu and Yujiao Chang and Peng Liu},
  title = {{Using POI Data to Identify the Demand for Pedestrian Crossing Facilities at Mid-Block}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/su132313256},
}
Figure