TL;DR
This study reveals that the total number of drawings in a company's granted invention patents is a significant predictor of stock return rates for China’s A-share companies. While the average number of drawings per patent doesn't tell us much, a high aggregate volume of drawings correlates with superior market performance, suggesting that patent quantity and the depth of technical disclosure still drive investor value in the Chinese market.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
In the world of intellectual property (IP) analytics, researchers usually focus on patent claims (the legal boundaries) or citations (the "impact" factor). Patent drawings are often dismissed as mere secondary support. However, according to examination criteria, drawings are essential because they must "clearly and fully reveal the claimed embodiments."
The authors tackle a specific gap: Does the visual complexity and volume of a company's patent portfolio—specifically the drawing count—correlate with its financial performance on the stock market? By focusing on China’s A-shares (RMB common stocks) between 2017 and 2021, the researchers sought to determine if "drawing count" could serve as a novel indicator for patent quality and, by extension, a tool for stock selection.
Methods
The researchers employed a robust statistical approach to link IP data with financial outcomes:
- Company Integrated Patent Database: Recognizing that large listed companies often hold patents through subsidiaries, the authors built a database that integrated all subsidiary patents into the parent company’s profile.
- Metric Definition: They defined two primary metrics:
- Average Drawing Count (ADC): The mean number of drawings per invention grant.
- Total Drawing Count (TDC): The sum of all drawings across all invention grants issued to a company over the previous year.
- Grouping: Companies were divided into four groups based on percentile ranks (PR 0–25, 25–50, 50–75, and 75–100) for both ADC and TDC.
- ANOVA (Analysis of Variance): This standard statistical method was used to determine if the differences in stock return rates between these groups were statistically significant.
Datasets
The study utilized a massive longitudinal dataset:
- Population: All China A-shares listed on the Shanghai and Shenzhen stock exchanges.
- Effective Samples: Over 50% of listed companies were selected, ranging from 1,613 companies in 2017Q1 to 2,825 companies by 2021Q4.
- Patent Data: Specifically focused on China Invention Grants, which undergo the most rigorous "substantial examination" compared to utility models or design patents.
- Timeframe: 2017Q1 to 2021Q4 (20 quarters).
Key Insights and Ideas
- Total vs. Average: The most striking insight is that the total volume of drawings (TDC) matters, but the average (ADC) does not. This suggests that a company’s overall innovative output—the sheer breadth of technical disclosure—is a better proxy for market value than how detailed any single patent is.
- The "Chemical" Exception: The authors noted that Group #1 (lowest drawing counts) often had means below 1.0. This is because many chemical and pharmaceutical patents relate to compounds and formulas that require no drawings at all, highlighting how industry-specific IP norms can affect these metrics.
- Patent Quality is Rising: Across all groups, the average drawing count per patent significantly increased from 2017 to 2021. This indicates a general trend toward higher-quality, more detailed patent applications in China.
- Quantity Still Matters: Despite global shifts toward "quality over quantity," this paper argues that in the Chinese market, the aggregate quantity of technical disclosure (represented by TDC) remains a powerful differentiator for stock performance.
Key Results
- TDC as a Differentiator: In 16 out of 20 quarters analyzed, the Total Drawing Count showed a statistically significant relationship with stock return rates (an 80% significance rate).
- High TDC = High Returns: Companies in the top 25% (Group #4) of Total Drawing Counts consistently showed significantly higher stock return means compared to the market trend.
- ADC Failure: Conversely, the Average Drawing Count was only significant in 10 out of 20 quarters (50%), making it an unreliable indicator for investors.
- COVID-19 Impact: The researchers observed a dip in total drawing counts in 2020, likely due to the pandemic's impact on R&D and patent office processing, yet the correlation between high TDC and stock performance persisted.
Limitations and Future Work
- Industry Bias: As mentioned, industries like chemicals/biotech naturally have fewer drawings. The study does not currently control for industry sectors, which could skew results if one sector (like electronics) naturally uses more drawings.
- Focus on Grants Only: The study excludes "Invention Publications" (patents not yet granted). Future work could examine if the drawing count in the application phase has a leading effect on stock prices before the patent is even granted.
- Geographic Scope: The findings are specific to the China A-share market. Whether this "drawing count" metric holds up in the US (USPTO) or European (EPO) markets remains an open question for future research.
Practical Takeaway for Firms: If you want to signal value to the market, don't just file a few highly detailed patents. The data suggests that filing a larger volume of patents, each well-supported by technical drawings, is more closely linked to stock market success.
Summary updated