Using Net Primary Productivity to Characterize the Spatio-Temporal Dynamics of Ecological Footprint for a Resource-Based City, Panzhihua in China

Shuhui Zhang, Fuquan Li, Yuke Zhou, Ziyuan Hu, Ruixin Zhang, Xiaoyu Xiang, Yali ZhangSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces an enhanced ecological footprint framework using Net Primary Productivity (NPP) to assess the sustainability of Panzhihua, a resource-based city in China. The study reveals that Panzhihua has shown significant improvements in resource utilization efficiency and ecological sustainability from 2000-2020, indicating a positive shift towards sustainable development.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Resource-based cities, often heavily reliant on natural resource extraction, face unique challenges in achieving sustainable development. Traditional ecological footprint models provide a valuable indicator of a region's environmental impact, but there's a need for more refined methodologies that accurately capture the complex interplay between human activities and ecological capacity. Specifically, this paper addresses the gap in assessing the spatio-temporal dynamics of sustainability in resource-based cities by integrating Net Primary Productivity (NPP) into the ecological footprint model, offering a more nuanced understanding of regional ecological security and development.

Methods

The study employs an NPP-based ecological footprint model adapted for a provincial hectare scale. This approach refines the traditional ecological footprint calculation by using NPP data to derive more accurate equivalence factors (EQF) and yield factors (YF). These factors are crucial for standardizing the calculation of the ecological footprint (EF) and ecological capacity (EC) across different land types. The model calculates:

  • Ecological Footprint (EF): The total area of biologically productive land required to support a region's consumption.
  • Ecological Capacity (EC): The biologically productive land available within a region.
  • Ecological Deficit/Surplus (ES): The difference between EC and EF, indicating whether a region is living within its ecological means.

Beyond these core metrics, the study also evaluates sustainable development capability using a suite of indices:

  • Ecological Pressure Index (EPI): Measures the ratio of ecological footprint per capita to ecological capacity per capita (ef/ec).
  • Ecological Footprint per Ten Thousand GDP (EFG): Assesses resource utilization efficiency in relation to economic output.
  • Ecological Sustainability Index (ESI): Reflects the degree to which an area's ecological environment meets human needs (ec/(ec + ef)).
  • Ecological Coordination Index (ECI): Evaluates the balance between economic/social development and the ecological environment.

Datasets

The study utilizes the following datasets for Panzhihua City from 2000 to 2020:

  • MODIS Net Primary Productivity (NPP) data: Obtained from NASA Earthdata, providing a 1 km x 1 km spatial resolution of net useful chemical fossil energy production by plants.
  • GlobeLand30 data: A 30m global land cover dataset from the National Basic Geographic Information Center (NGCC), classifying land into ten types (cultivated land, forest, grassland, shrubland, wetland, water bodies, tundra, artificial surface, bare ground, glaciers, and permanent snow and ice). For this study, it was simplified into five categories: cultivated land, forest, grassland, water bodies, and construction land.
  • Social statistical data: Sourced from the Sichuan Statistical Yearbook, Panzhihua Statistical Yearbook, Panzhihua Yearbook, and government websites, including data on population, consumption, and production.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • NPP as a Refined Indicator: Integrating NPP into the ecological footprint model provides a more direct measure of the ecosystem's productive capacity, leading to more accurate estimations of ecological footprint and capacity.
  • Resource-Based City Transformation: Panzhihua, historically a coal-dependent city, has undergone a significant transformation, moving away from overcapacity issues towards becoming a "Vanadium and Titanium Capital" and "Excellent Tourism City." This study provides a quantitative assessment of the sustainability of this transition.
  • Fossil Fuels as a Major Driver: Fossil energy land and forest land were identified as the dominant land types influencing both the ecological footprint and capacity, highlighting the continued reliance on these resources and their environmental implications.
  • Improving Resource Efficiency: The study demonstrates a clear trend of improved resource utilization efficiency in Panzhihua, as evidenced by the significant decrease in the Ecological Footprint per Ten Thousand GDP (EFG).

Key Results

  • Ecological Capacity and Deficit Growth: Panzhihua experienced an increasing trend in per capita ecological capacity (PEC) and per capita ecological deficit/surplus (PED/S) from 2000-2020, indicating an enhanced capacity to support its population.
  • Decreasing Per Capita Footprint: The per capita ecological footprint (PEF) decreased by 1.9 hm²/person over the study period, suggesting reduced per capita resource demand.
  • Reduced Ecological Pressure: Both the Ecological Pressure Index (EPI) and Ecological Footprint per Ten Thousand GDP (EFG) showed significant decreases, indicating a decline in ecological pressure and improved resource utilization efficiency. EPI decreased by 6.6381 hm²/person and EFG by 2.2462 hm²/person.
  • Enhanced Sustainability: The Ecological Sustainability Index (ESI) and Ecological Coordination Index (ECI) increased by 0.3436 hm²/person and 0.2897 hm²/person, respectively, signifying an improvement in the city's overall sustainability and the coordination between its development and its ecological environment.
  • Spatial Patterns: The study found that the downtown area and built-up areas are ecologically fragile zones with low ecological capacity and higher ecological pressure, while areas along rivers and the central location showed lower ecological footprints.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Standardization Challenges: The authors acknowledge that there is no unified and standardized accounting system for ecological footprint accounting, which can lead to variations in results depending on the chosen parameters and methodologies. This limits the direct comparability of findings with other studies.
  • Data Availability: While the study utilized available data, limitations in data availability for specific parameters or regions can influence the precision of the assessment.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests the need for continuous improvement of ecological footprint accounting methods and the development of a framework for standardized calculation of key parameters. Future research could also explore the application of this framework to other resource-based cities to further validate its utility and identify best practices for sustainable development.

Summary updated

Abstract

An ecological footprint is a primary indicator in measuring the sustainability of regional development, especially in resource-based cities. Here, we built an ecological footprint-based framework to assess the sustainability for a resource-based city of Panzhihua, in China. In this framework, a suite of long-term ecological parameters (2000–2020), essentially including Net Primary Productivity (NPP), land cover, as well as social statistical data, was used as the input indices of a provincial hectare ecological footprint model. The model outputs are composed of the ecological footprint (EF), ecological footprint per capita (PEF), ecological capacity (EC), ecological capacity per capita (PEC), ecological deficit/surplus (ED/S), and per capita ecological deficit/surplus (PED/S). Then the sustainable development capability of the city was comprehensively evaluated using a suite of ecological indices, including the ecological pressure index (EPI), ecological footprint per ten thousand GDP (EFG), ecological sustainability index (ESI), and ecological coordination index (ECI). The study reveals that, from 2000–2020, (1) PEC and PED/S presented an increasing trend (0.2401 hm2/person and 2.1421 hm2/person, respectively), while PEF decreased by 1.9 hm2/person. In the case of the ecological deficit, fossil energy land and forest were the dominant land types in controlling the ecological footprint and ecological capacity, (2) EPI and EFG decreased by 6.6381 hm2/person and 2.2462 hm2/person, respectively, and ESI and ECI increased by 0.3436 hm2/person and 0.2897 hm2/person, respectively. These indices also reflect that the utilization rate of natural resources in Panzhihua City has been improved, with enhanced sustainability, as well as a decline in ecological pressure. This ecological footprint-based framework could work as a template for evaluating the sustainability of resource-based cities from positive and negative ecological footprint indices.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2022using,
  author = {Shuhui Zhang and Fuquan Li and Yuke Zhou and Ziyuan Hu and Ruixin Zhang and Xiaoyu Xiang and Yali Zhang},
  title = {{Using Net Primary Productivity to Characterize the Spatio-Temporal Dynamics of Ecological Footprint for a Resource-Based City, Panzhihua in China}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su14053067},
}
Figure