Using healthcare failure mode and effect analysis as a method of vaginal birth after caesarean section management

Ying Liu, Wei Zhu, Shiguan Le, Wenxian Wu, Qun Huang, Weiwei ChengJournal of Clinical Nursing 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel application of Healthcare Failure Mode and Effect Analysis (HFMEA) to improve the management of vaginal birth after cesarean (VBAC) in China. By systematically identifying and mitigating potential risks, the HFMEA-driven protocol significantly increased VBAC success rates while maintaining a low incidence of uterine rupture, addressing a critical need for safer maternal healthcare practices.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Globally, there's a trend towards increasing cesarean section (C-S) rates. In China, this trend, coupled with the "two-child policy," has led many women with a prior C-S to face a difficult choice: undergo another C-S or attempt a vaginal birth after cesarean (VBAC). While VBAC offers benefits, obstetricians and midwives in China have historically been conservative due to limited experience and a lack of standardized clinical routines, leading to low VBAC rates compared to developed countries. This gap in practice creates a need for optimized management strategies to ensure the safety and success of VBAC, thereby empowering women with more delivery options.

Methods

The study employed a prospective quality improvement program utilizing the Healthcare Failure Mode and Effect Analysis (HFMEA) methodology. This involved:

  • Forming an HFMEA Group: A multidisciplinary team of experienced obstetricians, midwives, anesthesiologists, and administrators was assembled.
  • Developing Process Maps: Core processes of antepartum and intrapartum VBAC management were mapped out.
  • Identifying Failure Modes: Through brainstorming, potential failure modes within these processes were identified.
  • Hazard Analysis: Each failure mode was assessed for its potential occurrence (O) and severity of impact (S). A Risk Priority Number (RPN = O x S) was calculated, with an RPN of 8 or higher considered high-risk.
  • Decision Tree Analysis: High-risk failure modes were analyzed to determine if remedial actions were necessary.
  • Developing Remedial Protocols: Specific actions were designed to address the identified high-risk failure modes.
  • Implementation and Evaluation: The revised protocol was implemented as a clinical routine. VBAC success rates and other outcomes were compared before and after the intervention. The Standards for Quality Improvement Reporting Excellence (SQUIRE) 2.0 checklist was used for reporting.

Datasets

The study utilized retrospective data from the years 2013, 2014, and 2015 for comparison with the prospective data collected during the 1-year follow-up period (April 2016 - March 2017). The data included the number of pregnancies with a previous C-S, the number of women attempting Trial of Labour After Caesarean (TOLAC), and the number of successful VBACs.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • HFMEA as a Proactive Tool: The study demonstrates that HFMEA, a risk assessment tool typically used in engineering, can be effectively adapted to identify and mitigate risks in complex healthcare processes like VBAC management.
  • Systemic Approach to Safety: By breaking down the VBAC process into core components and systematically analyzing potential failure points, the HFMEA approach moves beyond individual blame to address systemic weaknesses.
  • Empowering Women's Choices: The improved VBAC rates suggest that a structured, evidence-based approach can increase both clinician confidence and patient willingness to pursue VBAC, offering women more autonomy in their birth choices.
  • The Importance of Multidisciplinary Collaboration: The success of the HFMEA implementation highlights the value of bringing together diverse clinical expertise to analyze and improve patient care pathways.

Key Results

The HFMEA process identified 70 failure modes across seven core processes, with 14 high-risk modes targeted for remediation. Following the implementation of the revised protocol:

  • The VBAC success rate increased significantly to 86.36% during the 1-year follow-up period, compared to rates ranging from 72.16% to 79.69% in the preceding three years.
  • The TOLAC rate also saw an increase, indicating greater willingness among both clinicians and patients to attempt VBAC.
  • Crucially, the incidence of uterine rupture was not compromised, remaining at a low level.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The study was conducted in a single tertiary hospital, which may limit the generalizability of findings to other settings.
  • The study design was not randomized, which is inherent to quality improvement projects.
  • The paper mentions that the B-type ultrasound result (a predictive parameter for VBAC) was considered, but the legal restrictions on gender testing in China meant that parents were informed of risks for both male and female, rather than specific gender-based predictions.
  • Future Work:
    • The authors suggest continued comparison of severe complications to previous practices to further validate the protocol's effectiveness.
  • Further studies on high-quality clinical trials are needed to refine VBAC management processes.
  • The development and validation of local prediction models for VBAC success are ongoing areas of research.

Summary updated

Abstract

This modified vaginal birth after caesarean management protocol has been shown effective in increasing its successful rate, which can be continued for further comparison of severe complications to the previous practice.
BibTeX
@article{liu2019using,
  author = {Ying Liu and Wei Zhu and Shiguan Le and Wenxian Wu and Qun Huang and Weiwei Cheng},
  title = {{Using healthcare failure mode and effect analysis as a method of vaginal birth after caesarean section management}},
  journal = {Journal of Clinical Nursing},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1111/jocn.15069},
}
Figure