Using Gamification to Support Users’ Adoption of Contextual Achievement Goals

Jian Tang, Yilin Jia, Ping ZhangProceedings of the ... Annual Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences/Proceedings of the Annual Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Gamification is a promising approach for motivating and engaging users in nongame tasks. However, theoretical support on why and how gamification enhances users’ motivation or behavior is limited. Considering the concepts of goal orientation and goal structure suggested by achievement goal theory, we prescribe gamification design as purposely creating goal structures to support users’ goal adoption and achievement behaviors. This conceptual work addresses the question: what types of achievement goals can be associated with gamification design? Particularly, how can the use of gamification design help construct goal structures to support users’ goal adoption? Adapting achievement goal theory, we identify three sets of achievement goals, namely, cognitive competence, social competence, and social purpose, and develop six propositions on gamification design. Each proposition is illustrated with empirical examples from the literature. This research contributes to the theoretical advancement of gamification design and provides additional insights into the motivational design of information systems.

Introduction

While gamification is widely deployed to boost engagement across domains like fitness and education, a deep theoretical understanding of why specific game elements change behavior is often missing. Existing research frequently relies on Self-Determination Theory (SDT) or Goal-Setting Theory (GST). While valuable, these frameworks often overlook the contextual influence of the environment on goal adoption. This paper addresses this gap by adapting Achievement Goal Theory (AGT) to provide a framework for designing "goal structures"—environments that nudge users toward adopting specific cognitive, social, and purpose-driven goals.

Theoretical Foundations: Goal Structure vs. Orientation

A central contribution of this work is the distinction between a user's internal disposition (Goal Orientation) and the environment created by the designer (Goal Structure). Effective gamification design is not merely about adding "fun" elements; it is the act of building a Goal Structure that encourages a desired Goal Orientation. By providing specific feedback and information, designers can help users commit to particular "end states" or achievement goals.

A Taxonomy of Achievement Goals

The authors identify three primary categories of achievement goals that can be shaped through gamified design:

  1. Cognitive Competence: Focuses on the mastery of tasks or knowledge. This is further broken down by the "referent" used for evaluation (Task-based, Self-based, or Other-based).
  2. Social Competence: Focuses on developing or demonstrating skills required for social interaction, such as improving relationship quality or gaining positive social judgments.
  3. Social Purpose: Focuses on the social consequences of achieving competence, such as gaining status, affiliation, or fulfilling social responsibilities.
Table 1: Definitions and Propositions for Achievement Goal Types in Gamification.

Design Propositions

Based on the taxonomy above, the paper formulates six specific design propositions that guide how gamification can support different goal types. For instance, Propositions 1a through 1c suggest that gamification can support cognitive goals by displaying different referents—such as progress bars for self-based goals or leaderboards for other-based goals. Propositions 2a and 2b highlight the role of socially interactive venues in helping users develop social competence. Finally, Proposition 3 suggests that gamification supports social purpose by highlighting the social rewards of competence, such as badges that confer reputation.

Discussion and Future Work

By re-examining previous studies through the lens of AGT, the authors demonstrate that this framework can explain inconsistent findings in gamification research. For example, it clarifies why a leaderboard might motivate a user seeking "other-based" competence while causing anxiety in another.

While this conceptual framework provides a robust foundation, future research is needed to empirically test these propositions in controlled environments. Additionally, more work is required to map specific UI/UX design objects to high-level goal structures, as the field currently lacks a universally agreed-upon taxonomy of game elements.

Summary updated

Abstract

Gamification is a promising approach for motivating and engaging users in nongame tasks. However, theoretical support on why and how gamification enhances users’ motivation or behavior is limited. Considering the concepts of goal orientation and goal structure suggested by achievement goal theory, we prescribe gamification design as purposely creating goal structures to support users’ goal adoption and achievement behaviors. This conceptual work addresses the question: what types of achievement goals can be associated with gamification design? Particularly, how can the use of gamification design help construct goal structures to support users’ goal adoption? Adapting achievement goal theory, we identify three sets of achievement goals, namely, cognitive competence, social competence, and social purpose, and develop six propositions on gamification design. Each proposition is illustrated with empirical examples from the literature. This research contributes to the theoretical advancement of gamification design and provides additional insights into the motivational design of information systems.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{tang2020using,
  author = {Jian Tang and Yilin Jia and Ping Zhang},
  title = {{Using Gamification to Support Users’ Adoption of Contextual Achievement Goals}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the ... Annual Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences/Proceedings of the Annual Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.24251/hicss.2020.151},
}
Figure