Using e‐learning for student sustainability literacy: framework and review

Susannah Diamond, Brian IrwinInternational Journal of Sustainability in Higher Education 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper reviews how e-learning is currently used to foster sustainability literacy in higher education. It proposes a framework for analyzing this, finding that e-learning is primarily used for information delivery rather than developing deeper skills, identity, and confidence, suggesting a need for more student-centered pedagogical approaches.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Universities are increasingly tasked with developing "sustainability literacy" in students, equipping them with the knowledge, skills, and attitudes to address global ecological challenges. While e-learning offers a powerful tool for education, there's a gap in understanding how it's specifically being leveraged to cultivate sustainability literacy within higher education curricula. This paper aims to bridge that gap by exploring current e-learning practices, identifying best practices, and pinpointing areas for improvement in embedding sustainability literacy through digital means.

Methods

The authors conducted a literature review to explore existing practices. They developed a four-part framework for analyzing sustainability literacy development:

  1. Conceptual awareness: Understanding sustainability issues.
  2. Personal identity: Aligning values with sustainability.
  3. Skill development: Acquiring competencies for sustainability action.
  4. Confidence: Believing in one's ability to contribute to sustainability.

They searched for examples of e-learning use in higher education related to sustainability literacy, categorizing these examples based on how well they addressed the four developmental areas.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • E-learning is widely used, but often superficially: While e-learning is prevalent in sustainability education, its application tends to be focused on delivering information rather than fostering deeper engagement.
  • A pedagogical shift is needed: The current reliance on didactic, teacher-centric e-learning approaches limits its potential. A move towards more student-centered, constructivist methods is crucial for developing the more complex aspects of sustainability literacy.
  • Beyond knowledge: Identity and confidence matter: Sustainability literacy isn't just about knowing facts; it's about developing personal values, skills, and the confidence to act. E-learning has a significant, yet largely untapped, potential to support these crucial areas.
  • Blended learning offers a promising path: Combining online learning with real-world experiences (like work placements or community projects) can create richer learning environments for sustainability.

Key Results

The review identified 34 examples of e-learning use in sustainability literacy education. The findings indicate:

  • Most common use: Providing flexible access to information (e.g., via intranets, VLEs).
  • Second most common: Supporting communication and collaboration (e.g., via email, wikis).
  • Least common: Developing discipline-specific skills, personal identity, and confidence.
  • Conceptual development: While 23 examples addressed this, many were didactic and passive.
  • Identity development: Only 8 examples focused on this, often through role-playing or reflective logs.
  • Skill development: 7 examples showed e-learning supporting skills like carbon footprint calculation or critical analysis.
  • Confidence development: Only 5 examples specifically targeted this, often through sharing opinions or publishing work.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the sample of case studies provided limited evidence, and a broader survey of practitioners would be beneficial. They also note a scarcity of literature that rigorously evaluates the effectiveness of e-learning in developing sustainability literacy, often finding "story-telling" about practice rather than in-depth analysis of pedagogical choices and their impact.

Future work should focus on:

  • More in-depth studies to understand why effectiveness is not often reported.
  • Testing whether the observed imbalances in tool use and supported SSL aspects are widespread.
  • Exploring the effectiveness of participative e-learning approaches for developing advanced aspects of sustainability literacy (identity, competence, confidence).
  • Leveraging e-learning to enhance blended and distance learning modes for sustainability education.

Summary updated

Abstract

Purpose The paper aims to explore staff practices in using e‐learning to embed sustainability literacy, highlight best practice and determine areas for improvement. Design/methodology/approach A framework of four areas for developing student sustainability literacy (SSL) was proposed as a basis for analysing practice. A literature review then explored the extent to which e‐learning is used to support embedding SSL in the curriculum, and the types of e‐learning currently in use for this. Findings E‐learning tools were most frequently used to provide flexible access to information, followed by support for communication and collaboration, and were less frequently used for the development of specific skills, personal identity and confidence. Research limitations/implications The sample of case studies provided only limited evidence. A survey of practitioners could be undertaken to explore and validate the issues raised by the literature review. Practical implications The review highlighted scope for a pedagogical shift away from using e‐learning for information delivery and practical communication, and towards supporting rich, student‐centred forms of learning in both blended and distance learning modes. Social implications This shift would create more powerful learning experiences for students, more effectively develop students' personal identities and skills, and yield graduates who are more confident in their ability to create more sustainable futures. Originality/value This paper will be of value to academic staff and educational developers looking to develop practice in embedding SSL in teaching and learning, and to harness the potential of e‐learning.
BibTeX
@article{diamond2013using,
  author = {Susannah Diamond and Brian Irwin},
  title = {{Using e‐learning for student sustainability literacy: framework and review}},
  journal = {International Journal of Sustainability in Higher Education},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1108/ijshe-09-2011-0060},
}
Figure