Using concept and structure similarities for ontology integration

Xiulei Liu, Payam M. Barnaghi, Klaus Moessner, Jianxin LiaoOM 2010 · OpenReview

Abstract

Ontology integration is a critical challenge for the Semantic Web, where heterogeneous knowledge representations must be reconciled to enable machine interoperability. This paper presents a hybrid framework that combines lexical analysis, leveraging WordNet synsets, with structural analysis of concept hierarchies. By mapping identified semantic relations to the standardized Simple Knowledge Organization System (SKOS) model, the approach facilitates the creation of unified, machine-readable links between disparate ontologies. The framework's efficacy is demonstrated through alignment examples and evaluation on the OAEI2008 dataset.

Introduction

In the Semantic Web, ontologies serve as the backbone for knowledge representation. However, developers often create "heterogeneous" ontologies—different ways of describing the same domain—even when using standardized languages like OWL. For example, one library might categorize a resource under "Computer Science," while another uses "Information Technology." For machines to understand that these concepts are related or identical, robust ontology integration is required. The primary challenge lies in accurately identifying when two concepts in different ontologies share a relationship based on both their linguistic labels (lexical) and their positions within a hierarchy (structural).

Methodology

The proposed framework addresses integration through a two-step process: Alignment and SKOS Translation.

1. Alignment (The Matching Phase)

This phase identifies similarities between concepts using a dual-pronged approach. Lexical analysis employs a tokenizer and a synset finder to understand the linguistic meaning of concept names beyond simple keyword matching. Simultaneously, structural analysis examines the "semantic structure"—how concepts are nested or linked within their respective ontologies. A similarity measure, $S(A, B)$, is calculated for concept pairs, and the system assigns one of five relation types: equal, beIncluded, include, disjoint, or related.

2. SKOS Translation (The Standardization Phase)

To ensure the integrated results are useful for other Semantic Web tools, the identified relations are mapped to standard SKOS properties. For instance, an "equal" relation is translated to skos:exactMatch, while a "beIncluded" relation becomes skos:broadMatch. This process results in a new, SKOS-based bridge ontology. Finally, a reasoning step (e.g., using the Pellet reasoner) checks for consistency to ensure the new links do not create logical contradictions.

Figure 1: The proposed framework for ontology integration, illustrating the flow from lexical/structural analysis to SKOS translation and consistency checking.

Evaluation and Results

The authors evaluated their method using the OAEI2008 (Ontology Alignment Evaluation Initiative 2008) dataset, a standard benchmark for testing alignment algorithms. Figure 2 provides a snapshot of the framework's output, showing the integration of "Ontology 101" and "Ontology 302."

The system successfully identified several key mappings:

  • An exactMatch between "Book" in both ontologies.
  • A broadMatch between "Monograph" in Ontology 101 and "Book" in Ontology 302.
  • A narrowMatch between "Collection" and "Publication."

These results demonstrate that by leveraging WordNet as a semantic anchor, the framework can recognize hierarchical relationships even when concept names differ significantly.

Figure 2: A snapshot of the integrated ontology showing SKOS-based mappings between Ontology 101 and Ontology 302.

Limitations and Future Work

While the framework shows promise, several areas remain for future development. The paper introduces the similarity measure $S(A, B)$ but does not detail the specific mathematical weights used to balance lexical versus structural scores. Additionally, the scalability of the system for web-scale ontologies containing tens of thousands of concepts has not yet been established. Future work will focus on refining the mapping rules between synsets and SKOS relations to further improve integration accuracy and exploring the complexity of the reasoning logic required for large-scale consistency checks.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2010using,
  author = {Xiulei Liu and Payam M. Barnaghi and Klaus Moessner and Jianxin Liao},
  title = {{Using concept and structure similarities for ontology integration}},
  booktitle = {OM},
  year = {2010},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=4QKDinWzHD},
}
Figure