Using Blockchain to Create Transaction Identity for Persons Experiencing Homelessness in America: Policy Proposal

Anjum Khurshid, Ashish GadnisJMIR Research Protocols 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes using blockchain technology to create a secure, immutable digital identity for individuals experiencing homelessness in Austin, Texas. This "transaction identity" aims to overcome fragmented service delivery and lack of verifiable information, enabling better access to healthcare and social services.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Homelessness in America is a complex issue exacerbated by fragmented social and healthcare systems. Individuals experiencing homelessness often lack verifiable identification, leading to difficulties in accessing essential services. This lack of documentation results in misdiagnoses, duplicated efforts, and inefficient service delivery, costing billions of dollars annually. Current information technology solutions have struggled to create a seamless, person-centered system due to issues with data sharing, interoperability, and patient empowerment. The paper highlights that existing systems are often siloed within different agencies, making it challenging for individuals to navigate and benefit from available support.

Methods

The paper proposes a policy-based solution leveraging blockchain technology, specifically a distributed ledger technology (DLT). The core idea is to create a "transaction identity" for individuals experiencing homelessness. This identity would be built on a blockchain platform, allowing individuals to have direct access to their records and control who can access them.

Key aspects of the proposed method include:

  • Digital Identity Creation: Utilizing biometric features to create secure, immutable profiles for individuals on the blockchain.
  • Decentralized Data Management: Storing transaction records (e.g., medical encounters, service interactions) on a distributed ledger, making them accessible and verifiable.
  • Interoperability: Enabling various service providers (hospitals, emergency medical services, social service agencies) to connect to the blockchain platform and share data with the individual's consent.
  • Person-Centered Approach: Shifting from agency-centric data silos to a system where the individual is at the center, controlling their own information.

The paper draws parallels with successful international blockchain applications for refugees and farmers, demonstrating its potential for humanitarian use cases.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on a policy proposal and conceptual framework rather than empirical evaluation on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • "Transaction Identity" as a Solution: The concept of "transaction identity" is crucial. It's not just about having an ID, but about having a verifiable history of interactions and services, which empowers individuals and improves service coordination.
  • Blockchain's Suitability for Homelessness: Blockchain's inherent properties of immutability, transparency (with controlled access), and decentralization make it uniquely suited to address the data fragmentation and trust issues prevalent in services for the homeless.
  • Beyond Cryptocurrencies: The paper emphasizes that the value of blockchain lies in its underlying DLT, not necessarily in its cryptocurrency applications, thus mitigating concerns about volatility.
  • Cost-Effectiveness: The proposal suggests that blockchain can be a more cost-effective solution compared to traditional, siloed IT systems, potentially saving billions in duplicated services and administrative overhead.
  • Empowerment and Resilience: By giving individuals control over their data, the blockchain approach aims to foster resilience and enable them to break cycles of poverty and disadvantage.

Key Results

This paper is a policy proposal and conceptual framework, not an empirical study with quantitative results. Therefore, there are no specific quantitative results to summarize. The "results" are the proposed benefits and potential outcomes of implementing such a system, which include:

  • Improved coordination of services for individuals experiencing homelessness.
  • Reduced misdiagnosis and duplication of medical tests and treatments.
  • Enhanced ability for individuals to access and manage their own health and social service records.
  • Potential for increased efficiency and cost savings in service delivery.
  • Empowerment of individuals experiencing homelessness through verifiable identity and data control.

Limitations and Future Work

The paper acknowledges that this is a proposal and that further planning and funding are required to implement a pilot program on the ground.

  • Implementation Challenges: While the paper outlines the conceptual framework, the practicalities of onboarding individuals experiencing homelessness, ensuring digital literacy, and securing widespread adoption by service providers are significant challenges that will require further exploration.
  • Biometric Data Security: The reliance on biometric features for identity creation raises questions about data security and privacy, which will need robust solutions.
  • Scalability and Interoperability with Existing Systems: While blockchain offers interoperability, integrating it seamlessly with existing, often legacy, systems used by various agencies will be a complex undertaking.
  • Future Work: The authors explicitly state that "Further planning for creating a program on the ground with additional funding will demonstrate the results of using blockchain technology to establish digital identity for persons experiencing homelessness." This indicates a clear path for future research and development, including pilot testing and evaluation.

Summary updated

Abstract

More than 500,000 people experience homelessness in America each day. Local and federal solutions to the problem have had limited success because of the fragmentation of services and lack of valid and timely information. Billions of dollars spent to provide reliable, timely, and actionable information in health care have exposed the difficulty of establishing such a system using the prevalent information technology solutions. However, relying on successful examples of the use of blockchain to help refugee populations and poor farmers internationally, we have partnered to propose an innovative solution to this problem using the case of people experiencing homelessness in Austin, Texas. This paper aims to describe one of the first applications of blockchain technology for addressing homelessness in the United States by creating a digital identity for people experiencing homelessness and engaging emergency medical services and clinical providers. The authors argue that a lack of documentation to prove personal identity and the inability to access own records are major hurdles for empowering persons experiencing homelessness to be resilient and overcome the life challenges they face. Furthermore, it is argued that this lack of information causes misdiagnosis, duplication, and fragmentation in service delivery, which can be potentially addressed by blockchain technology. Further planning for creating a program on the ground with additional funding will demonstrate the results of using blockchain technology to establish digital identity for persons experiencing homelessness.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{khurshid2019using,
  author = {Anjum Khurshid and Ashish Gadnis},
  title = {{Using Blockchain to Create Transaction Identity for Persons Experiencing Homelessness in America: Policy Proposal}},
  booktitle = {JMIR Research Protocols},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.2196/10654},
}
Figure