Using Blockchain Technology to Mitigate Challenges in Service Access for the Homeless and Data Exchange Between Providers: Qualitative Study

Anjum Khurshid, Vivian Rajeswaren, Steven AndrewsJournal of Medical Internet Research 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study explores the feasibility of using blockchain technology to improve service access and data sharing for individuals experiencing homelessness. While the technology demonstrated potential for secure, decentralized data management, significant challenges remain in user experience, organizational adoption, and navigating complex regulatory landscapes for widespread implementation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Individuals experiencing homelessness face significant hurdles in accessing essential services due to fragmented and inaccessible personal documentation. This lack of control over their data, coupled with disparate data formats across various service providers, creates a barrier to obtaining housing, healthcare, and other support. Existing systems often lack interoperability and client data ownership, leading to delays and inefficiencies. The paper aims to address this by investigating whether blockchain technology can provide a secure, client-controlled platform for managing and sharing this critical information.

Methods

The researchers conducted a qualitative study involving a pilot test of an existing blockchain-based platform. This involved:

  • Platform Demonstrations: Showcasing the platform's capabilities to homeless individuals and service providers.
  • Qualitative Feedback Interviews: Gathering in-depth insights on user needs, barriers to adoption, and overall perceptions of the technology.
  • Assumption Testing: Evaluating specific hypotheses related to the platform's appropriateness, user understanding, provider trust, necessity of blockchain, data privacy, service facilitation, and inter-organizational efficiency.
  • Prototype Iteration: Using multiple fidelity levels of prototypes (from journals with locks to digital prototypes) to explain the complex blockchain concepts to users.

The study focused on testing an existing platform initially developed for refugees, adapting it for the homeless population.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focused on qualitative feedback and the performance of a blockchain platform rather than training or evaluating on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Blockchain's Potential for Data Autonomy: The core promise of blockchain – decentralized, immutable, and transparent data management – aligns well with the goal of empowering individuals experiencing homelessness with control over their own records.
  • User Experience is Paramount: For vulnerable populations with varying technological access, a user-friendly interface and intuitive workflow are critical for adoption. The existing platform, designed for a different use case, presented significant usability challenges.
  • Organizational Readiness is a Major Hurdle: Service providers face their own set of challenges, including integrating new technologies, understanding data standards, and navigating regulatory compliance (like HIPAA).
  • Trust is a Two-Way Street: Both individuals experiencing homelessness and service providers need to trust the system. For users, this involves trusting self-uploaded documents; for providers, it's about trusting the data's integrity and accessibility.
  • Blockchain as a Complement, Not a Replacement (Yet): The study suggests that blockchain might initially work alongside existing systems (like HMIS) rather than replacing them entirely, especially for documents not currently stored in those legacy databases.

Key Results

  • Successful Account Creation and Permissions: Homeless individuals and care organizations were able to create accounts, grant/revoke data sharing permissions, and transmit documents across the distributed network.
  • Significant Usability Issues: Users encountered difficulties with account creation, data sharing workflows, and understanding blockchain concepts.
  • Security and Privacy Concerns: Despite blockchain's inherent security features, users expressed concerns about the security of shared data and overall privacy.
  • Organizational Preparedness Gaps: Service providers showed varying levels of preparedness and willingness to adopt the technology, with concerns about workload and data validation requirements.
  • Platform Mismatch: The existing blockchain platform, originally designed for refugees, was not fully suitable for the homeless population's specific needs, leading to invalidated assumptions about its equivalence.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Platform Limitations: The study was constrained by the use of an existing platform that could not be significantly modified due to time and budget limitations. This prevented the development of an optimal end-user experience.
  • Regulatory Ambiguity: Navigating legal and regulatory frameworks, particularly HIPAA, for sharing sensitive health information remains a significant challenge.
  • Scalability and Cost-Effectiveness: The paper acknowledges that cost-effectiveness and scalability were not fully evaluated due to the pilot nature of the study.
  • Future Research Directions: The authors suggest further research is needed to compare blockchain's efficacy and costs against alternative approaches, explore standardized data types, and investigate the role of a centralized, city-owned database. They also highlight the importance of developing user-friendly interfaces and addressing organizational workflow changes for successful implementation.

Summary updated

Abstract

BACKGROUND: In the homeless population, barriers to housing and supportive services include a lack of control or access to data. Disparate data formats and storage across multiple organizations hinder up-to-date intersystem access to records and a unified view of an individual's health and documentation history. The utility of blockchain to solve interoperability in health care is supported in recent literature, but the technology has yet to be tested in real-life conditions encompassing the complex regulatory standards in the health sector. OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to test the feasibility and performance of a blockchain system in a homeless community to securely store and share data across a system of providers in the health care ecosystem. METHODS: We performed a series of platform demonstrations and open-ended qualitative feedback interviews to determine the key needs and barriers to user and stakeholder adoption. Account creation and data transactions promoting organizational efficiency and improved health outcomes in this population were tested with homeless users and service providers. RESULTS: Persons experiencing homelessness and care organizations could successfully create accounts, grant and revoke data sharing permissions, and transmit documents across a distributed network of providers. However, there were issues regarding the security of shared data, user experience and adoption, and organizational preparedness for service providers as end users. We tested a set of assumptions related to these problems within the project time frame and contractual obligations with an existing blockchain-based platform. CONCLUSIONS: Blockchain technology provides decentralized data sharing, validation, immutability, traceability, and integration. These core features enable a secure system for the management and distribution of sensitive information. This study presents a concrete evaluation of the effectiveness of blockchain through an existing platform while revealing limitations from the perspectives of user adoption, cost-effectiveness, scalability, and regulatory frameworks.
BibTeX
@article{khurshid2020using,
  author = {Anjum Khurshid and Vivian Rajeswaren and Steven Andrews},
  title = {{Using Blockchain Technology to Mitigate Challenges in Service Access for the Homeless and Data Exchange Between Providers: Qualitative Study}},
  journal = {Journal of Medical Internet Research},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.2196/16887},
}
Figure