USER-CENTERED DESIGN AND USABILITY EVALUATION OF A CANCER PREVENTION WEB APPLICATION: AN ITERATIVE APPROACH IN GERMANY

Pricivel M. Carrera, Odile Elias, Ruidong Zhang, Tobias Norajitra, Ângela Gonçalves, Klaus Maier‐HeinmedRxiv 2025 · DOI

Abstract

Limited public awareness of cancer risk factors necessitates effective dissemination of cancer prevention information. Digital technologies offer an opportunity to address this gap, yet there is scant information on tools for communicating cancer prevention evidence. This article describes the user-centered design, development and usability evaluation of a web application for personalized cancer prevention tailored to the German population. Prototypes of the web-app were developed through early and continuous formative evaluations. These prototypes integrated validated cancer risk prediction models and recommendations using an evidence-based risk communication approach. In a graphical user interface (GUI) test usability was assessed using the system usability scale (SUS), deriving scores for overall usability, usefulness, and learnability. Qualitative data on user experience (UX) and user interface (UI) issues were also collected through think-aloud protocols, interviews, and questionnaires. The GUI test showed a SUS score of 69.7/100 and a usefulness score of 75.8, indicating acceptable usability, while the learnability score was 48.4. Eight categories of UX/UI problems were identified, including one severe and three moderate issues related to data input, user guidance and risk visualization. Qualitative feedback highlighted strengths in navigation, information presentation, and interactive features such as the risk simulation tool. The iterative development and early user testing yielded valuable feedback, identifying key usability concerns during prototyping. The usability score was within an acceptable range, and the usefulness score was above average. However, the lower learnability score indicated potential challenges in user understanding and satisfaction. Identified usability issues highlight areas for improvement while positive feedback supports the design choices, particularly the use of visual aids, numerical data, and personalized feedback to improve risk comprehension and motivate behavior change. The NCPC cancer prevention web application represents a significant step towards effective digital health promotion in Germany. Addressing identified usability concerns through continued iterative refinement and user involvement is crucial for enhancing the tool’s effectiveness. The integration of evidence-based risk communication strategies shows promise in improving risk comprehension and motivating behavior change among users.

Introduction

Despite the fact that 30% to 50% of all cancer cases are preventable through lifestyle changes, public awareness of specific risk factors remains alarmingly low. While digital "risk calculators" exist, many are restricted to specific cancer types, designed for use only by clinicians, or not tailored to the specific demographic and clinical guidelines of the German population. The authors address the challenge of evidence-based risk communication: how to take rigorous epidemiological models and present them in a way that is not only understandable to a layperson but also motivating enough to trigger behavioral change.

Methods

The researchers followed a multi-stage User-Centered Design (UCD) framework, beginning with five months of stakeholder consultations and evidence reviews to establish architectural requirements. Development progressed from low-fidelity mock-ups to a high-fidelity functional prototype.

The application's technical foundation is a modern microservice architecture. It utilizes a Python/Django backend for logic, a PostgreSQL database for storage, and a Vue.js/Vuetify frontend for the user interface. The entire system is deployed via Docker containers to ensure scalability and consistency across environments.

System architecture of the NCPC web application.

The application's "intelligence" is powered by eight validated lifestyle-based cancer risk models tailored for the German population (e.g., the LiFeCRC score for colorectal cancer) and adherence logic based on the 2018 World Cancer Research Fund/American Institute for Cancer Research (WCRF/AICR) recommendations.

A formal Graphical User Interface (GUI) test was conducted with eight participants using three distinct "personas" to standardize the evaluation. Usability was measured quantitatively via the System Usability Scale (SUS) and qualitatively through think-aloud protocols and interviews.

Results and User Experience

The GUI test yielded a SUS score of 69.7/100, indicating "acceptable" usability for a prototype. However, a striking disconnect was observed between the "Usefulness" score (75.8) and the "Learnability" score (48.4). While users recognized the value of the personalized data, they struggled with the initial cognitive load of navigating the interface.

User interface of the lifestyle and nutrition questionnaires.

Key design insights included:

  • Visual Shorthand: A "traffic-light" system (green/yellow/red-orange) was preferred for risk communication. The team specifically adjusted "red" to "red-orange" to improve accessibility and soften the emotional impact.
  • Risk Simulation: The "Risk Simulation Tool" was highly praised, allowing users to interactively see how lifestyle changes (e.g., reducing processed meat) would impact their risk pictograms.
  • Prioritization: Simple icons, such as exclamation marks next to high-impact risk factors, effectively helped users prioritize lifestyle changes.

Despite these strengths, the team identified eight categories of UX/UI issues. The most severe involved "Inability to input data," where users were confused by specific units (like waistband circumference) or the sequence of the questionnaire. The resulting Net Promoter Score (NPS) of -25 highlights the friction remaining in the user journey.

Discussion and Conclusion

The primary limitation of this study was the test population, which consisted of DKFZ employees who likely possess higher-than-average health and digital literacy. Future work will involve alpha testing with the general public and implementing onboarding tutorials to bridge the learnability gap.

In conclusion, the NCPC cancer prevention web application represents a significant step toward digital health promotion in Germany. The integration of evidence-based risk communication strategies shows promise in improving risk comprehension. Addressing identified usability concerns through iterative refinement is crucial for enhancing the tool’s effectiveness in motivating behavioral change.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Objectives Limited public awareness of cancer risk factors necessitates effective dissemination of cancer prevention information. Digital technologies offer an opportunity to address this gap, yet there is scant information on tools for communicating cancer prevention evidence. This article describes the user-centered design, development and usability evaluation of a web application for personalized cancer prevention tailored to the German population. Materials and Methods Prototypes of the web-app were developed through early and continuous formative evaluations. These prototypes integrated validated cancer risk prediction models and recommendations using an evidence-based risk communication approach. In a graphical user interface (GUI) test usability was assessed using the system usability scale (SUS), deriving scores for overall usability, usefulness, and learnability. Qualitative data on user experience (UX) and user interface (UI) issues were also collected through think-aloud protocols, interviews, and questionnaires. Findings The GUI test showed a SUS score of 69.7/100 and a usefulness score of 75.8, indicating acceptable usability, while the learnability score was 48.4. Eight categories of UX/UI problems were identified, including one severe and three moderate issues related to data input, user guidance and risk visualization. Qualitative feedback highlighted strengths in navigation, information presentation, and interactive features such as the risk simulation tool. Discussion The iterative development and early user testing yielded valuable feedback, identifying key usability concerns during prototyping. The usability score was within an acceptable range, and the usefulness score was above average. However, the lower learnability score indicated potential challenges in user understanding and satisfaction. Identified usability issues highlight areas for improvement while positive feedback supports the design choices, particularly the use of visual aids, numerical data, and personalized feedback to improve risk comprehension and motivate behavior change. Conclusion The NCPC cancer prevention web application represents a significant step towards effective digital health promotion in Germany. Addressing identified usability concerns through continued iterative refinement and user involvement is crucial for enhancing the tool’s effectiveness. The integration of evidence-based risk communication strategies shows promise in improving risk comprehension and motivating behavior change among users.
BibTeX
@misc{carrera2025user,
  author = {Pricivel M. Carrera and Odile Elias and Ruidong Zhang and Tobias Norajitra and Ângela Gonçalves and Klaus Maier‐Hein},
  title = {{USER-CENTERED DESIGN AND USABILITY EVALUATION OF A CANCER PREVENTION WEB APPLICATION: AN ITERATIVE APPROACH IN GERMANY}},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1101/2025.04.29.25326679},
  howpublished = {medRxiv},
}
Figure