US Cosmic Visions: New Ideas in Dark Matter 2017: Community Report

Yonit Hochberg, A. N. Villano, Andrei Afanasev, Andrew Geraci, N. Randazzo, C. Hearty, M. Wing, T. Markiewicz, Sheldon Campbell, J. P. Coleman, C. E. Dahl, Glennys R. Farrar, M. G. Boulay, Jason M. Hogan, S. Benson, Tracy R. Slatyer, Kimberly K. Boddy, Vasiliy Morozov, B. Rybolt, Yue Zhao, J. Barrow, Adam Ritz, Eric Kuflik, Simon Knapen, M. Carpinelli, I. Stancu, Matthew Solt, Samuel D. McDermott, G. Fiorillo, L. Marsicano, Dongming Mei, Stephen E. Derenzo, Christopher McCabe, Mariangela Lisanti, P. Crivelli, Nikita Blinov, K. van Bibber, M. Bondí, Guojian Wang, M. B. Crisler, D. Loomba, M. Holtrop, J. Liu, Asher Berlin, A. Renshaw, Omar Moreno, N. Phinney, A. Scarff, Tim Nelson, W. A. Terrano, Alexander Kusenko, D. Banerjee, John Clarke, James Battat, V. Sipala, S. Vahsen, Stefano Profumo, R. Budnik, Jonathan Kozaczuk, T. Yu, M. T. Graham, Howard Baer, B. Srivastava, Xilin Zhang, Philip Schuster, Sahara Mohammed Prem Nazeer, Sabato Stefano Caiazza, A.b. McDonald, G. Cavoto, N. S. Oblath, Annika H. G. Peter, T. Cao, Maxim Pospelov, Brianna Thorpe, Joseph Lykken, D. G. Hitlin, D. D’Urso, Jae Hyeok Chang, E. G. Adelberger, Surjeet Rajendran, K. D. Irwin, Emanuele Di Marco, M. Szydagis, B. Wojtsekhowski, T. W. Hossbach, Yi-Ming Zhong, M. Köhl, Owen Colegrove, A. Drlica-Wagner, Katherine J. Mack, D. B. Tanner, Gordan Krnjaic, Thomas G. Rizzo, T. Saab, Jordan Smolinsky, M. Brodeur, Keith R. Dienes, Ming Liu, Kenneth Clark, D. Snowden-IfftarXiv 2017 · arXiv

Abstract

This white paper summarizes the workshop U.S. Cosmic Visions: New Ideas in Dark Matter held at University of Maryland on March 23-25, 2017. It outlines a strategic pivot in the search for dark matter, moving beyond the traditional WIMP paradigm to explore Hidden Sector and Ultra-Light candidates through small-scale, high-precision experiments.

Introduction: Beyond the WIMP Paradigm

For decades, the search for dark matter (DM) has been dominated by the Weakly Interacting Massive Particle (WIMP) hypothesis. Flagship "Generation 2" (G2) experiments, such as LZ and SuperCDMS, are world-class at hunting for WIMPs heavier than a few GeV. However, if dark matter is significantly lighter, these massive detectors lack the sensitivity to register the tiny recoils produced by such light particles.

This community report addresses the urgent need to diversify search strategies, identifying a massive, unexplored "parameter space" where dark matter could be hiding. We are currently in a "technological sweet spot" where new, smaller experiments can provide outsized scientific returns by probing mass ranges and coupling strengths previously considered invisible.

Experimental Pillars and Methods

The proposed roadmap is built on three main experimental pillars designed to cover the new territory of sub-GeV and ultra-light dark matter.

1. Low-Threshold Direct Detection

To find sub-GeV dark matter, researchers are moving toward materials with tiny "energy gaps" that can register incredibly faint energy depositions.

  • Skipper-CCDs: These sensors can count individual electrons, effectively reaching sub-electron noise levels to detect the faint "kick" of a light dark matter particle.
  • Superfluid Helium and Superconductors: These materials allow detectors to register minimal energy depositions from dark matter hitting an electron or nucleus, potentially sensitive to meV-scale interactions.

2. Accelerator-Based Searches

Instead of waiting for a dark matter particle to hit a detector, accelerator experiments seek to produce them in a laboratory setting.

  • LDMX (Light Dark Matter Experiment): By using electron beams hitting a fixed target and measuring "missing momentum," scientists can infer the production of invisible dark sector particles. This method provides a controlled way to determine fundamental properties like mass and spin.

3. Coherent Field Searches

For "Ultra-Light" dark matter (such as axions), particles behave more like a classical wave than a discrete billiard ball.

  • Resonant Cavities: Experiments like ADMX act like a cosmic radio tuned to the dark matter frequency, converting axions into detectable photons.
  • NMR and Atom Interferometry: These techniques, used in projects like CASPEr, detect the subtle oscillations this "dark field" would induce in normal matter.

Key Insights and the "Small Experiment" Revolution

A major takeaway from the report is that fundamental physics does not always require billion-dollar facilities. Many promising searches can be executed for under $10M on short timescales (2–5 years). This allows for a rapid, iterative approach to exploring new theories.

Furthermore, the report highlights the concept of the Dark Sector. Dark matter may not be a single particle but part of a complex hidden sector with its own forces and "dark photons." Current anomalies, such as the 8Be anomaly and the muon g-2 discrepancy, serve as potential signposts for these new force carriers.

Projections and Future Outlook

The report projects that these new techniques could extend the search range by over 20 orders of magnitude in mass—from $10^{-22}$ eV to the scale of black holes.

  • Thermal Relic Targets: Experiments like SENSEI and DAMIC-1K aim to test "Freeze-in" models, which involve couplings previously thought untestable.
  • Axion Discovery: Upgrades to ADMX and new projects like CASPEr are poised to reach the "DFSZ" sensitivity level, the theoretical gold standard for axion couplings.

Limitations and R&D

As detectors become more sensitive, they will eventually encounter the "neutrino floor," where solar neutrinos create background noise indistinguishable from dark matter. Overcoming this will require investment in directional detection and continued theoretical support to interpret new signals and connect them to disparate astrophysical observations.

Summary updated

Abstract

This white paper summarizes the workshop U.S. Cosmic Visions: New Ideas in Dark Matter held at University of Maryland on March 23-25, 2017.
BibTeX
@misc{hochberg2017us,
  author = {Yonit Hochberg and A. N. Villano and Andrei Afanasev and Andrew Geraci and N. Randazzo and C. Hearty and M. Wing and T. Markiewicz and Sheldon Campbell and J. P. Coleman and C. E. Dahl and Glennys R. Farrar and M. G. Boulay and Jason M. Hogan and S. Benson and Tracy R. Slatyer and Kimberly K. Boddy and Vasiliy Morozov and B. Rybolt and Yue Zhao and J. Barrow and Adam Ritz and Eric Kuflik and Simon Knapen and M. Carpinelli and I. Stancu and Matthew Solt and Samuel D. McDermott and G. Fiorillo and L. Marsicano and Dongming Mei and Stephen E. Derenzo and Christopher McCabe and Mariangela Lisanti and P. Crivelli and Nikita Blinov and K. van Bibber and M. Bondí and Guojian Wang and M. B. Crisler and D. Loomba and M. Holtrop and J. Liu and Asher Berlin and A. Renshaw and Omar Moreno and N. Phinney and A. Scarff and Tim Nelson and W. A. Terrano and Alexander Kusenko and D. Banerjee and John Clarke and James Battat and V. Sipala and S. Vahsen and Stefano Profumo and R. Budnik and Jonathan Kozaczuk and T. Yu and M. T. Graham and Howard Baer and B. Srivastava and Xilin Zhang and Philip Schuster and Sahara Mohammed Prem Nazeer and Sabato Stefano Caiazza and A.B. McDonald and G. Cavoto and N. S. Oblath and Annika H. G. Peter and T. Cao and Maxim Pospelov and Brianna Thorpe and Joseph Lykken and D. G. Hitlin and D. D’Urso and Jae Hyeok Chang and E. G. Adelberger and Surjeet Rajendran and K. D. Irwin and Emanuele Di Marco and M. Szydagis and B. Wojtsekhowski and T. W. Hossbach and Yi-Ming Zhong and M. Köhl and Owen Colegrove and A. Drlica-Wagner and Katherine J. Mack and D. B. Tanner and Gordan Krnjaic and Thomas G. Rizzo and T. Saab and Jordan Smolinsky and M. Brodeur and Keith R. Dienes and Ming Liu and Kenneth Clark and D. Snowden-Ifft},
  title = {{US Cosmic Visions: New Ideas in Dark Matter 2017: Community Report}},
  year = {2017},
  eprint = {1707.04591},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1707.04591},
}
Figure