Urban Form, Growth, and Accessibility in Space and Time: Anatomy of Land Use at the Parcel-Level in a Small to Medium-Sized American City

Long Zhou, Guoqiang Shen, Wu Yao, Robert A. Brown, Tian Chen, Chenyu WangSustainability 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This study analyzes the historical urban growth and land-use patterns of Corvallis, Oregon, from 1853 to 2014 to understand their impact on urban accessibility. It reveals that increasing land-use mix, rather than urban density, is a more effective strategy for reducing travel distances and improving accessibility in small to medium-sized cities.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Urbanization is a complex process that significantly alters how cities grow and how accessible different areas are to their residents. While much research has focused on large metropolitan areas, the unique dynamics of small to medium-sized cities, which play a crucial role in regional systems, are less understood. This paper aims to fill this gap by investigating the intricate relationship between urban form (how a city is shaped), urban growth (its expansion over time), and urban accessibility (how easily people can reach destinations) in a typical small to medium-sized American city. Specifically, it seeks to understand how changes in land use, parcel development, and density over a long historical period have influenced travel distances and accessibility for residents.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach to analyze Corvallis's urban development:

  • Spatial-Temporal Analysis: They examined land use and parcel data across 5-year intervals from 1853 to 2014, providing a detailed historical perspective.
  • GIS-Based Accessibility Measurement: Urban accessibility was quantified using the "least-cost path distance" calculated through Origin-Destination (OD) cost matrix analysis in GIS. This method determines the shortest travel path between residential parcels and various non-residential land uses (commerce, industry, office, open space).
  • Statistical Correlation: Pearson correlation models were used to identify and quantify the statistical relationships between various urban form variables (e.g., population density, building square footage, land-use mix) and urban accessibility measures.
  • Data Visualization: Scatterplot matrices were utilized to visually represent the correlations between numerous variables, offering a comprehensive overview of their interrelationships.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this study was a comprehensive, open-access tax-lot parcel database for the City of Corvallis, Oregon. This database included attributes such as:

  • Year built (urbanization year)
  • Land use category
  • Building finished size (square footage)
  • Parcel size (land acreage)
  • Land value
  • Improved value

This data was collected and analyzed for 5-year intervals from 1853 to 2014.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Land-Use Mix is Key: The most significant finding is that increasing the diversity of land uses within neighborhoods (land-use mix) is a more effective strategy for reducing travel distances and improving accessibility than simply increasing urban density or development density. This challenges some conventional planning approaches.
  • Population Growth Drives Urbanization: The study strongly confirms that population growth is the primary driver behind the expansion of urbanized parcels and the need for residential housing, which in turn fuels overall urbanization.
  • Accessibility Fluctuations: While urban growth has been relatively consistent, urban accessibility has experienced periods of both improvement and decline over time, influenced by various factors.
  • Density's Limited Impact: Unlike findings in larger metropolitan areas, increasing urban density in Corvallis did not show a significant impact on urban accessibility, possibly due to factors like high automobile ownership and preferences for suburban living.
  • Residential Dominance: Residential land use consistently accounted for the largest proportion of urbanized land throughout the study period, reflecting its direct link to population growth.

Key Results

  • Corvallis experienced spatial growth at varying rates throughout its history, with accessibility showing a similar pattern of ups and downs.
  • Population growth closely mirrored urban growth, with residential housing needs being a primary factor.
  • Decreasing population density negatively impacted urban accessibility to commercial, industrial, and office areas for most of the historical periods.
  • After 1950, urban density increased alongside urban sprawl, but this density did not significantly affect urban accessibility in Corvallis.
  • Increasing land-use mix was found to be a more effective approach to reduce urban travel path distance and enhance accessibility compared to increasing population or development density.
  • The average travel distance from residential to commercial and office land uses was generally shorter than to industrial and open space, suggesting that sustainable zoning policies have recognized the importance of proximity to daily destinations.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Measurement Granularity: Using building square footage and land use parcel acreage for density measurements might not be fully accurate, as buildings can be multi-story and parcels may not be entirely urbanized.
  • Accessibility Simplification: The study used average distances from all residential parcels. More realistic accessibility measures could be achieved by considering individual homes and incorporating real urban street networks and transportation modes.
  • Causality: The reliance on correlation and linear regression limits the ability to establish causality. Future work could benefit from qualitative research, such as historical analysis, to better understand drastic changes.
  • Representativeness: The study is based on a single American city, limiting its generalizability. Further research is needed in comparable cities to validate these findings.

Future work could involve exploring these limitations to provide a more nuanced understanding of urban dynamics and to develop more robust policy recommendations for sustainable urban development in small to medium-sized cities.

Summary updated

Abstract

Using the City of Corvallis, Oregon, a small to medium sized American city, as a test-bed, this paper examines the City’s urban growth in relation to urban accessibility. This relationship is explored in an anatomic spatial-temporal fashion, taking account of: the number and size of developed land use parcels over time; urban accessibility from residential to non-residential land use areas; and the statistical relationships between urban form and urban accessibility. This investigation of land use is structured around use-classification and examined within a range of dimensional and demographic measurements over 5-year time periods from 1853 to 2014; concurrently, urban accessibility is measured by the least-cost path distance as calculated through the OD cost matrix analysis in GIS. The results indicate that the city grew spatially at different rates and its urban accessibility experienced both ups and downs over time. The city’s population growth corresponded closely with urban growth and its decreasing population density negatively impacted on the city’s urban accessibility to commerce, industry, and office for most time periods. Significantly, while the urban density increased steadily after 1950s concurrent with an increase in urban sprawl, in contrast to previous studies on the metropolitan condition, the urban density had no evident impact on urban accessibility in Corvallis. Instead, increasing the land-use mix was a more effective and feasible approach to reduce urban travel path distance and enhance accessibility than increasing population density or urban development density. Accordingly, this research provides evidence-based policy recommendations for planning sustainable urban mobility and urban form in small to medium-sized cities.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhou2018urban,
  author = {Long Zhou and Guoqiang Shen and Wu Yao and Robert A. Brown and Tian Chen and Chenyu Wang},
  title = {{Urban Form, Growth, and Accessibility in Space and Time: Anatomy of Land Use at the Parcel-Level in a Small to Medium-Sized American City}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3390/su10124572},
}
Figure