Abstract: The purpose of this study is to link security housing with urban competitiveness improvement, reflecting a new trend in the housing reform field. It is proposed that under new development situations, we should shift from the traditional concept of housing security to a modern concept that combines public housing with enhancing city competitiveness. Through various policy systems and market mechanisms, cities can resolve housing problems via development. Effective public housing contributes to urban competitiveness, achieving mutual promotion between the two. We must establish a modern concept of housing security, shifting from a focus on welfare to social benefits, and integrating public housing development with urban competitiveness.
Introduction: From Welfare Burden to Strategic Asset
Urban management has traditionally viewed public housing, or "security housing," through a narrow lens of social welfare—a necessary cost to support low-income populations. However, as cities globally compete for talent and investment, high living costs have emerged as a significant barrier to growth. This paper addresses the disconnect between housing policy and economic strategy, arguing that rapid urbanization requires a diverse set of housing solutions that traditional welfare models fail to meet. The central challenge is redesigning housing security to enhance a city's competitive edge.
Conceptual Framework: The Urban Competitiveness Model
To bridge the gap between social policy and economic performance, this analysis utilizes Professor Iain Begg’s urban competitiveness model. This framework links "City Operations"—including infrastructure and the regulatory environment—to "Standard of Living" and "Productivity."
In this model, housing is categorized as a core component of a city's physical infrastructure. If this infrastructure is inefficient or prohibitively expensive, the city's "wealth creation capacity" suffers. By integrating public housing into this framework, it becomes clear that lowering the "entry price" for skilled migrants is essential for maintaining a high-quality human capital base.
Strategic Insights for Policy Re-engineering
The paper proposes a shift from a "government-as-provider" model to a "government-as-coordinator" model, applying market concepts to public goods. Key strategic pillars include:
- The Talent Magnet: Urban competitiveness is increasingly driven by human capital rather than just industrial output. Public housing serves as a primary tool to attract the "new immigration" of skilled workers.
- Optimizing Existing Stock: Rather than focusing solely on new construction, the author suggests that governments should acquire, lease, and renovate existing housing stock. This approach minimizes market disruption and prevents the formation of isolated low-income enclaves.
- Shared-Equity Mechanisms: To address the affordability gap for middle-income families, a "common property" model is recommended. By sharing ownership based on investment ratios, residents can build equity while the government ensures long-term supply fairness.
Results and Policy Implications
A successful modern public housing system must transition from quantity-based metrics (units built) to quality-based metrics (improvement in labor cost-efficiency). Qualitative analysis suggests:
- Public rental housing is often more effective than price-capped sales for a mobile, talented workforce.
- Market mechanisms, such as tax incentives for non-profits and private developers, offer more sustainable paths than direct government construction.
- Social benefits, including reduced labor costs and increased social inclusion, should serve as the primary Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) for housing officials.
Limitations and Future Directions
While the paper provides a robust theoretical argument, it lacks empirical case studies or quantitative modeling to measure the precise impact of housing interventions on GDP or competitiveness rankings. Future research should focus on exploring specific market mechanisms that balance housing affordability with capital recyclability. Additionally, more scientific policy instruments are needed to match housing types—such as rent, sale, or subsidy—to the specific demographic needs of evolving urban centers.
Summary updated