Uranyl/12-crown-4 Ether Complexes and Derivatives: Structural Characterization and Isomeric Differentiation

Jiwen Jian, Shu‐Xian Hu, Wan‐Lu Li, Michael J. Van Stipdonk, Jonathan Martens, Giel Berden, Jos Oomens, Jun Li, John K. GibsonInorganic 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores the intricate structures and bonding of uranyl (UO₂²⁺) complexes with the 12-crown-4 (12C4) ligand in the gas phase. By combining electrospray ionization, collision-induced dissociation, and infrared multiphoton dissociation spectroscopy with theoretical calculations, the researchers successfully synthesized and characterized distinct isomers of these complexes, revealing unique coordination behaviors and bond cleavage mechanisms.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the coordination chemistry of actinide ions, particularly uranyl, with macrocyclic ligands like crown ethers is crucial for applications such as nuclear waste partitioning and the development of novel materials. While solid-state studies have provided insights, the behavior of these complexes in the gas phase, where solvent effects are absent and specific coordination geometries can be isolated, remains less explored. This paper aims to elucidate the gas-phase structures, bonding, and reactivity of uranyl/12C4 complexes, focusing on how the relatively small 12C4 ligand interacts with the uranyl ion and how different synthetic routes can lead to distinct isomeric forms. A key challenge is differentiating between species with the same elemental composition but different structural arrangements, which can lead to varied chemical properties.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Electrospray Ionization (ESI): This technique was used to generate gas-phase uranyl/12C4 complexes from solution.
  • Quadrupole Ion Trap Mass Spectrometry (QIT/MS): This instrument was used for isolating specific ions and performing subsequent reactions.
  • Collision-Induced Dissociation (CID): Ions were subjected to CID to induce fragmentation and generate derivative species.
  • Spontaneous Hydration: The reactivity of certain ions with background water in the ion trap was studied to form hydrated species.
  • Infrared Multiphoton Dissociation (IRMPD) Spectroscopy: This technique was used to probe the vibrational modes of the isolated ions, providing structural fingerprints.
  • Quantum Chemical Calculations: Density Functional Theory (DFT) was used for geometry optimizations, vibrational frequency analyses, and to compute IR spectra for comparison with experimental data. Various computational methods, including Energy Decomposition Analysis (EDA) and Extended Transition State (ETS) with Natural Orbitals for Chemical Valence (NOCV), were employed to analyze bonding.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental data generated through mass spectrometry and spectroscopy, coupled with theoretical calculations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • C-O Bond Cleavage in 12C4: A significant finding is the cleavage of a C-O bond within the 12C4 ring upon CID of [UO₂(12C4)₂]²⁺, leading to the formation of an organouranyl species with a U-O single bond. This is a notable departure from simple ligand loss.
  • Isomer Differentiation: The study successfully differentiates between two isomers with the same composition, [UO₂(12C4)(OH)]⁺ and [UO₂(12C4-H)(H₂O)]⁺, based on their distinct reactivity with water and their unique IRMPD spectra.
  • Structural Flexibility of Uranyl: The uranyl moiety, while typically linear, can exhibit significant deviations from linearity (bent to ~149°) when coordinated by the compact and rigid 12C4 ligand, especially in the [UO₂(12C4)₂]²⁺ complex.
  • Role of Steric Congestion: Steric hindrance introduced by the hydroxyl ligand in [UO₂(12C4)₂(OH)]⁺ leads to reduced coordination of the 12C4 oxygen atoms, influencing its fragmentation pathways.
  • Energetic Favorability vs. Kinetic Pathways: Although the hydrate isomer [UO₂(12C4-H)(H₂O)]⁺ is energetically more favorable than the hydroxide isomer [UO₂(12C4)(OH)]⁺, the CID pathway from [UO₂(12C4)₂(OH)]⁺ preferentially yields the hydroxide, suggesting kinetic control in the reaction.
  • Gas-Phase vs. Condensed Phase: The observed high coordination of the 12C4 ligand in the gas phase highlights the influence of the absence of strongly coordinating solvent molecules, which often dominate in condensed-phase systems.

Key Results

  • Synthesis and Characterization: The paper reports the successful synthesis and characterization of gas-phase uranyl/12C4 complexes: [UO₂(12C4)₂]²⁺, [UO₂(12C4)₂(OH)]⁺, [UO₂(12C4-H)]⁺, [UO₂(12C4-H)(H₂O)]⁺, and [UO₂(12C4)(OH)]⁺.
  • Structural Confirmation: IRMPD spectra, when compared with computed spectra, provided strong evidence for the proposed structures of the ground-state isomers.
  • Bonding Analysis: Theoretical calculations revealed that both electrostatic and orbital interactions contribute to the metal-ligand bonding, indicating a significant covalent character in the U-O bonds.
  • Reactivity Differences: The hydrate [UO₂(12C4-H)(H₂O)]⁺ did not readily add a second water molecule, while the isomeric hydroxide [UO₂(12C4)(OH)]⁺ readily formed a di-hydrated species, confirming their structural distinctness.
  • Energetic Differences: The GS [UO₂(12C4)(OH)]⁺ structure was found to be ~26 kcal/mol higher in energy than the GS [UO₂(12C4-H)(H₂O)]⁺ structure.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Higher-Energy Isomers: While the paper focuses on ground-state (GS) isomers, it acknowledges the existence and provides computed structures for higher-energy isomers, suggesting that their potential role or interconversion could be a subject for future investigation.
  • Rearrangement in CID: The assumption that CID product formation occurs without rearrangement is noted as a potential caveat, particularly for the formation of [UO₂(12C4)(OH)]⁺. Future work could explore the possibility and energetic cost of such rearrangements.
  • Broader Crown Ether Series: The study focuses on 12C4. Extending this methodology to other crown ether sizes (e.g., 15C5, 18C6) could provide a more comprehensive understanding of how ligand size influences uranyl coordination and complex stability.
  • Actinide Series: While this paper focuses on uranyl, future studies could explore similar complexes with other actinide ions (e.g., neptunyl, plutonyl) to investigate trends in coordination chemistry across the actinide series.

Summary updated

Abstract

The following gas-phase uranyl/12-crown-4 (12C4) complexes were synthesized by electrospray ionization: [UO<sub>2</sub>(12C4)<sub>2</sub>]<sup>2+</sup> and [UO<sub>2</sub>(12C4)<sub>2</sub>(OH)]<sup>+</sup>. Collision-induced dissociation (CID) of the dication resulted in [UO<sub>2</sub>(12C4-H)]<sup>+</sup> (12C4-H is a 12C4 that has lost one H), which spontaneously adds water to yield [UO<sub>2</sub>(12C4-H)(H<sub>2</sub>O)]<sup>+</sup>. The latter has the same composition as complex [UO<sub>2</sub>(12C4)(OH)]<sup>+</sup> produced by CID of [UO<sub>2</sub>(12C4)<sub>2</sub>(OH)]<sup>+</sup> but exhibits different reactivity with water. The postulated structures as isomeric [UO<sub>2</sub>(12C4-H)(H<sub>2</sub>O)]<sup>+</sup> and [UO<sub>2</sub>(12C4)(OH)]<sup>+</sup> were confirmed by comparison of infrared multiphoton dissociation (IRMPD) spectra with computed spectra. The structure of [UO<sub>2</sub>(12C4-H)]<sup>+</sup> corresponds to cleavage of a C-O bond in the 12C4 ring, with formation of a discrete U-O<sub>eq</sub> bond and equatorial coordination by three intact ether moieties. Comparison of IRMPD and computed IR spectra furthermore enabled assignment of the structures of the other complexes. Theoretical studies of the chemical bonding features of the complexes provide an understanding of their stabilities and reactivities. The results reveal bonding and structures of the uranyl/12C4 complexes and demonstrate the synthesis and identification of two different isomers of gas-phase uranyl coordination complexes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{jian2018uranyl,
  author = {Jiwen Jian and Shu‐Xian Hu and Wan‐Lu Li and Michael J. Van Stipdonk and Jonathan Martens and Giel Berden and Jos Oomens and Jun Li and John K. Gibson},
  title = {{Uranyl/12-crown-4 Ether Complexes and Derivatives: Structural Characterization and Isomeric Differentiation}},
  booktitle = {Inorganic},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1021/acs.inorgchem.8b00306},
}
Figure