Uranium distribution in pseudowollastonite slag from a phosphorus furnace

Edward Young, Z. S. Altschuler1956 · DOI

Abstract

Silicate slag from the Victor Chemical Company phosphorus furnace at Tarpon Springs, Florida, primarily consists of pseudowollastonite ($\alpha$-CaSiO$_3$). This study investigates the microscopic distribution of uranium within the slag's crystalline structure. Findings indicate that uranium is not uniformly distributed; instead, it concentrates in late-stage, fibrous mineral phases and iron phosphide ($Fe_2P$) spherules. Through heavy-liquid fractionation, researchers achieved a fourfold concentration of uranium in 5% of the material. Nuclear-emulsion studies further reveal that the final phases are eight times more radioactive than early-formed crystals, suggesting potential pathways for uranium recovery from industrial byproducts.

Introduction: The Search for Unconventional Uranium Sources

During the mid-20th century, the U.S. Atomic Energy Commission prioritized the identification of uranium in unconventional geological and industrial sources. High-grade phosphate rock (apatite), a staple of the elemental phosphorus industry, was known to contain trace amounts of uranium. When processed in a furnace, this uranium mobilizes into the calcium silicate slag. This report characterizes the distribution of uranium within that slag to determine if specific mineral phases could be isolated for economic extraction.

Mineralogical Evolution of the Slag

The slag produced at the Tarpon Springs facility is characterized by a specific crystallization sequence. The primary component is pseudowollastonite, which forms in three distinct stages:

  1. Early Stage: The formation of euhedral "lathlike" crystals that create a structural mesh. These make up approximately 65% of the slag.
  2. Intermediate Stage: As cooling continues, the melt composition shifts slightly, depositing more equant, subhedral crystals within the existing framework (approx. 25%).
  3. Late Stage: Finally, anhedral masses of fibrous, poorly crystallized material fill the remaining pore spaces (approx. 10%).

A critical finding is that uranium acts as an "incompatible element" within this system. It does not fit easily into the crystal lattice of the early-forming pseudowollastonite laths. Consequently, uranium is partitioned into the residual melt, becoming increasingly concentrated as the slag nears total solidification.

Experimental Methodology

To map this distribution, researchers employed several analytical techniques:

  • Heavy-Liquid Fractionation: Crushed slag was separated using high-density liquids (acetylene tetrabromide) to isolate fractions based on specific gravity.
  • Nuclear-Emulsion Autoradiography: Thin sections were placed against alpha-particle-sensitive film for three months. By counting alpha tracks under high magnification, radioactivity was precisely mapped to specific microscopic grains.
  • X-Ray Powder Diffraction (XRD): Confirmed the presence of pseudowollastonite and identified shifts in d-spacing across different density fractions, indicating solid-solution evolution.

Key Insights: Scavenging and Trapping

Beyond the silicate phases, the study identified rare metallic spherules of iron phosphide ($Fe_2P$). These spherules, formed from an immiscible melt, were found to be highly enriched in uranium. This suggests that the iron phosphide acts as a chemical "scavenger," stripping uranium from the surrounding silicate liquid.

Furthermore, the researchers noted a correlation between aluminum content and uranium concentration. The late-stage fibrous material, which holds the highest uranium levels, is also richer in aluminum. This observation suggests an industrial strategy: by adjusting the furnace charge to include more aluminum, it might be possible to intentionally increase the volume of the uranium-trapping phase.

Results and Concentration Factors

The experimental results were striking:

  • Radioactivity Differential: Nuclear-emulsion studies showed that the final fibrous phases are eight times more radioactive than the early lathlike crystals.
  • Mechanical Concentration: Through density separation, the team achieved a fourfold concentration of uranium in just 5% of the total mass, and a twofold concentration in 30% of the material.

Limitations and Economic Outlook

While the study successfully identified the "where" and "how" of uranium distribution, several hurdles remain for commercial extraction. The different mineral phases are physically intergrown at a microscopic scale, making clean mechanical separation difficult. Additionally, the exact nature of the fibrous material—whether it is a true crystal or a glass—remains uncertain, which would affect the chemical processing required for extraction.

Ultimately, the report suggests that the most efficient way to recover uranium might be to segregate the "late-stage liquors" before the slag fully solidifies, rather than processing the bulk solid material.

Summary updated

Abstract

Silicate slag from the Victor Chemical Company phosphorus furnace at Tarpon Springs, Fla., has been found to consist essentially of pseudowollastonite, α-CaSiO3. The first-formed crystals are euhedral laths which form a mesh making up most of the slag. As the slag continues to solidify, its composition changes slightly and more equant, subhedral crystals of pseudowollastonite are deposited within the framework of the earlier material. Finally, anherdral masses of fibrous, poorly crystallized material are deposited in the remaining pore spaces which are not always completely filled. Spherules of iron phosphide, Fe2P, occur very sparsely in the slag as inclusions from the immiscible iron phosphide melt. Uranium content increases in the later crystal products of the slag, and by heavy-liquid fractionation it has been possible to segregate partially the phases and to obtain a fourfold concentration of uranium in 5 percent of the material and a twofold concentration in 30 percent of the material. Nuclear-emulsion studies indicate that the last phases of the silicate slag are actually eight times as radioactive as the early phases. In addition, the iron phosphide spherules are comparably enriches in uranium.
BibTeX
@misc{young1956uranium,
  author = {Edward Young and Z. S. Altschuler},
  title = {{Uranium distribution in pseudowollastonite slag from a phosphorus furnace}},
  year = {1956},
  doi = {10.3133/tei615},
}
Figure