Uptake and Transport of Different Concentrations of PPCPs by Vegetables

Yongfu Zeng, Yiming Zhang, Haichao Zhang, Jing Wang, Kaoqi Lian, Lianfeng AiInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the uptake, transport, and accumulation of 27 common pharmaceuticals and personal care products (PPCPs) in radish, buckwheat, and okra sprouts irrigated with PPCP-contaminated water. The findings demonstrate that plants absorb and accumulate PPCPs, with higher concentrations in the culture solution leading to increased uptake, posing a potential risk to human health through the food chain.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Water scarcity is a growing global concern, leading to increased reliance on treated wastewater for agricultural irrigation. However, this wastewater often contains pharmaceuticals and personal care products (PPCPs), which are emerging contaminants with potential adverse effects on ecosystems and human health. While it's known that PPCPs can enter the environment and be absorbed by plants, a comprehensive understanding of which PPCPs are taken up, how they are transported within the plant, and their accumulation levels across different plant species and concentrations is still developing. This paper aims to fill this knowledge gap by systematically examining the uptake, transport, and accumulation of a broad range of PPCPs in common edible sprouts, highlighting the potential risks associated with consuming produce irrigated with contaminated water.

Methods

The researchers employed a controlled laboratory experiment to assess PPCP uptake and transport. Three types of sprouts – radish, buckwheat, and okra – were cultivated in a controlled environment for 12 days using nutrient solutions spiked with PPCPs at three different concentrations: 0.5, 5.0, and 50.0 ng/mL. A control group received no PPCPs. After the incubation period, the plants were harvested, and their roots, stems, and leaves were separated.

Sample preparation involved lyophilization, grinding, and extraction using a combination of deionized water, acetonitrile, and solid-phase extraction. The identification and quantification of PPCPs in the plant tissues were performed using high-performance liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry (HPLC-MS/MS). This technique allows for sensitive and specific detection of a wide range of compounds.

To evaluate the movement of PPCPs within the plants, a translocation factor (TF) was calculated. TF is defined as the ratio of the concentration of a PPCP in the stems or leaves to its concentration in the roots (TF = C_leaf/stem / C_root). A TF greater than 1.0 indicates that the compound has moved from the roots to other plant tissues. Bioconcentration factors (BCF) were also calculated to quantify the accumulation of PPCPs in plant tissues relative to the culture medium.

Datasets

This study did not use pre-existing datasets for training or evaluation. Instead, it generated its own experimental data through controlled laboratory experiments. The "dataset" consists of the measured concentrations of 27 PPCPs in the roots, stems, and leaves of radish, buckwheat, and okra sprouts grown in PPCP-spiked nutrient solutions at varying concentrations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Ubiquitous Uptake: Plants are efficient accumulators of a wide range of PPCPs, even at relatively low environmental concentrations (0.5 ng/mL). This suggests that even trace levels of contamination in irrigation water can lead to significant PPCP burdens in edible plants.
  • Concentration-Dependent Accumulation: The amount of PPCPs absorbed and accumulated by plants directly correlates with the concentration of PPCPs in the culture medium. Higher PPCP levels in the water lead to higher concentrations in the plant tissues.
  • Active Translocation: PPCPs are not confined to the roots; they actively translocate to stems and leaves, which are often the edible parts of sprouts. This movement is more pronounced at higher PPCP concentrations, indicating that the plant's internal transport mechanisms are influenced by the pollutant load.
  • Species-Specific Differences: While all three plant species showed PPCP uptake, there were notable differences in the extent of accumulation and translocation. Buckwheat and okra generally accumulated higher levels of PPCPs than radish, suggesting that plant species plays a significant role in determining the risk of PPCP contamination.
  • Targeted PPCPs of Concern: Certain PPCPs, such as amantadine, diphenhydramine, chlorpheniramine maleate, sibutramine, and carbamazepine, consistently showed higher bioaccumulation and/or translocation, making them key targets for future research and monitoring.

Key Results

  • Broad Detection: Out of 27 tested PPCPs, a significant number were detected in the plant tissues across all three species and tested concentrations. For instance, at 0.5 ng/mL, 11 PPCPs were found in radish, 16 in buckwheat, and 16 in okra.
  • Concentration Effect: Increasing PPCP concentration in the culture solution from 0.5 to 50.0 ng/mL led to a clear increasing trend in the amount of PPCPs absorbed and accumulated by the plants.
  • Translocation Factors (TF): Several PPCPs exhibited translocation factors (TF > 1.0), indicating movement beyond the roots. For example, amantadine, chlorpheniramine maleate, carbamazepine, and N, N-bisdemethyl sibutramine showed active translocation in okra at 50 ng/mL.
  • High Accumulation PPCPs: Amantadine, diphenhydramine, chlorpheniramine maleate, sibutramine, haemosibutramine, chlorosibutramine, N-monomethyl sibutramine, N, N-desmethyl sibutramine, and carbamazepine were found to bioaccumulate significantly higher than other PPCPs in plants.
  • No Phytotoxicity: Importantly, the study found no significant difference in the growth, appearance, or health of the plants exposed to PPCPs compared to the control group, suggesting that the tested concentrations did not cause immediate phytotoxic effects.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Controlled Environment: The study was conducted under controlled laboratory conditions. The results may differ in real-world agricultural settings due to variations in soil properties, microbial activity, environmental factors, and irrigation practices.
  • Limited Plant Species: While three common sprout types were tested, a wider range of crops and plant parts (e.g., fruits, grains) would provide a more comprehensive understanding of PPCP accumulation across the agricultural landscape.
  • Temporal Dynamics: The study focused on a 12-day growth period. Investigating the long-term temporal dynamics of PPCP uptake, transport, and accumulation over entire plant life cycles would be valuable.
  • Mixture Effects: The study examined individual PPCPs or assumed additive effects. Future research could explore the complex interactions and synergistic or antagonistic effects of PPCP mixtures commonly found in wastewater.
  • Human Health Risk Assessment: While the study highlights the presence of PPCPs in edible plants, a direct quantitative risk assessment for human consumption is needed, considering dietary intake and potential toxicological impacts.

The authors suggest that further studies should focus on precise transfer pathways and temporal patterns of PPCPs to better understand their environmental fate and inform strategies for controlling cumulative toxic effects and reducing harmful impacts on human health.

Summary updated

Abstract

In many parts of the world, water resources are scarce or even extremely scarce, and the reuse of water resources has become mainstream in today's world. Many regions use treated wastewater for agricultural irrigation, aquaculture, and other activities. However, in recent years, wastewater has been found to contain large amounts of pharmaceuticals and personal care products (PPCPs). Therefore, there is a potential risk of PPCPs being transported in the environment and affecting human health. In this study, we compared the uptake, transport, and accumulation of 27 PPCPs in three types of sprouts (radish, buckwheat, and okra).The bioaccumulation of amantadine, diphenhydramine, chlorpheniramine maleate, sibutramine, hemosibutramine, chlorosibutramine, N-monomethyl sibutramine, N, N-desmethyl sibutramine, and carbamazepine was found to be significantly higher in plants grown for 12 days in media containing 0.5, 5.0, and 50.0 ng/mL PPCPs. With increasing concentration of PPCPs in the culture solution, the amount of PPCPs absorbed by plants and the degree of accumulation also showed an increasing trend. At the same time, it was demonstrated that there was an obvious uptake transfer phenomenon of PPCPs by plants, and the trend of uptake transfer became more and more obvious as the concentration of external environmental pollutants increased. In addition, amantadine, chlorpheniramine maleate, carbamazepine, N, N-desmethyl sibutramine, hemosibutramine, and chlorosibutramine showed more active translocation in some plants (TF > 1.0).
BibTeX
@article{zeng2022uptake,
  author = {Yongfu Zeng and Yiming Zhang and Haichao Zhang and Jing Wang and Kaoqi Lian and Lianfeng Ai},
  title = {{Uptake and Transport of Different Concentrations of PPCPs by Vegetables}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph192315840},
}
Figure