UPPER LIMITS ON THE VHE GAMMA-RAY EMISSION FROM THE WILLMAN 1 SATELLITE GALAXY WITH THE MAGIC TELESCOPE

E. Aliu, H. Anderhub, L. A. Antonelli, P. Antoranz, Michael Backes, C. Baixeras, S. Balestra, J. A. Barrio, H. Bartko, D. Bastieri, J. Becerra González, J. K. Becker, W. Bednarek, K. Berger, E. Bernardini, A. Biland, R. K. Böck, G. Bonnoli, P. Bordas, D. Borla Tridon, V. Bosch-Ramón, D. Bose, T. Bretz, I. Britvitch, Montaña Cámara, E. Carmona, S. Commichau, J. L. Contreras, J. Cortina, M. T. Costado, S. Covino, V. Curtef, F. Dazzi, A. De Angelis, E. De Cea del Pozo, R. de los Reyes, B. De Lotto, Mónica María, F. De Sabata, C. Delgado Mendez, A. Domínguez, D. Dorner, M. Doro, D. Elsäesser, M. Errando, D. Ferenc, E. Fernández, R. Firpo, M. V. Fonseca, L. Font, N. Galante, R. J. Garcı́a López, M. Garczarczyk, M. Gaug, F. Göebel, D. Hadasch, M. Hayashida, A. Herrero, D. Höhne-Mönch, J. Hose, C. C. Hsu, Stefan Huber, T. Jogler, D. Kranich, A. La Barbera, A. Laille, E. Leonardo, E. Lindfors, S. Lombardi, F. Longo, Marcos López, E. Lorenz, P. Majumdar, G. Maneva, N. Mankuzhiyil, K. Mannheim, L. Maraschi, M. Mariotti, M. Martı́nez, D. Mazin, M. Meucci, M. Meyer, J. M. Miranda, R. Mirzoyan, J. Moldón, M. Moles, A. Moralejo, D. Nieto, K. Nilsson, J. Ninković, A. N. Otte, R. Paoletti, J. M. Paredes, M. Pasanen, D. Pascoli, F. Pauß, R. Pegna, M. A. P. Torres, M. PersicThe Astrophysical Journal 2009 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper reports on observations of the ultrafaint dwarf galaxy Willman 1 using the MAGIC telescope, searching for very high-energy gamma-ray emission from dark matter annihilation. No significant signal was detected, leading to upper limits on the gamma-ray flux. These limits are stringent enough to require significant boosts (up to three orders of magnitude) for most standard dark matter models to explain a potential signal, highlighting the challenges in direct dark matter detection from such sources.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The nature of dark matter (DM) remains one of the most significant mysteries in modern physics. While its gravitational effects are well-established, its particle composition is unknown. One leading candidate is the neutralino, a hypothetical particle predicted by supersymmetry. Neutralinos are expected to annihilate, producing a flux of gamma-rays. Dwarf spheroidal galaxies (dSphs), like Willman 1, are considered prime targets for detecting this annihilation signal because they are thought to be the most dark matter-dominated objects in the universe, are relatively nearby, and have low astrophysical backgrounds. However, the predicted gamma-ray flux from these sources is highly dependent on the DM density profile and the specific particle physics model of neutralino annihilation. This paper aims to constrain these models by searching for gamma-ray emission from Willman 1, a particularly promising dSph candidate due to its high inferred dark matter content.

Methods

The researchers utilized the MAGIC (Major Atmospheric Gamma Imaging Cherenkov) telescope, a 17-meter diameter telescope located in the Canary Islands, to observe Willman 1. The telescope detects very high-energy gamma rays by observing the faint Cherenkov light flashes produced by atmospheric showers initiated by these photons. The observation period spanned 15.5 hours between March and May 2008.

Key methodological aspects include:

  • Target Selection: Willman 1 was chosen due to its status as an ultrafaint dwarf galaxy with a high mass-to-light ratio, suggesting a significant dark matter halo.
  • Data Analysis: Standard gamma-ray analysis techniques were employed, including image cleaning, event selection based on the "hadronness" estimator (to distinguish gamma rays from hadronic background), and energy reconstruction.
  • Astrophysical Modeling: The Navarro-Frenk-White (NFW) density profile was used to model the dark matter distribution within Willman 1, incorporating recent estimates of its structural parameters. The "astrophysical factor" (J(Ψ)) was calculated based on this profile and the telescope's angular resolution.
  • Particle Physics Modeling: Several benchmark models within the Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (mSUGRA) framework were used to predict the gamma-ray emission spectrum. Crucially, the analysis included the contribution of "internal bremsstrahlung" (IB), a recently quantified mechanism that can significantly boost gamma-ray emission at higher energies. The "particle physics factor" (ΦPP) was calculated for these models.
  • Upper Limit Calculation: Since no significant signal was detected, upper limits on the gamma-ray flux were derived using statistical methods (Rolke et al. 2005) at a 90% confidence level. These limits were then compared to the theoretical predictions from the benchmark models to constrain the allowed parameter space.

Datasets

  • Observation Data: 15.5 hours of observation data of the Willman 1 dSph galaxy collected by the MAGIC telescope between March and May 2008.
  • Background Data: Corresponding "OFF" data (observations of regions near Willman 1) were used for background estimation.
  • Monte Carlo Simulations: Used for event selection, energy reconstruction, and background rejection optimization.
  • Benchmark Models: Four modified Battaglia et al. (2001, 2004) benchmark models (I', J', K', F*) within the mSUGRA framework, incorporating internal bremsstrahlung, were used to predict theoretical gamma-ray fluxes. These models represent different regions of the mSUGRA parameter space (bulk, co-annihilation, funnel, focus point).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Willman 1 as a Dark Matter Probe: The paper reinforces Willman 1's status as a highly attractive target for dark matter searches due to its extreme DM dominance and relatively low astrophysical background.
  • The Importance of Internal Bremsstrahlung (IB): The inclusion of IB in the theoretical predictions is highlighted as a crucial factor. IB can significantly boost gamma-ray fluxes at energies relevant for ground-based telescopes like MAGIC, potentially making detection more feasible.
  • Stringent Constraints on Standard Models: The derived upper limits on the gamma-ray flux are sufficiently low to place strong constraints on many standard neutralino annihilation models. Even with the IB boost, most models require an additional "boost factor" of up to three orders of magnitude to be consistent with the observations.
  • The Role of Astrophysical Uncertainties: The paper emphasizes that uncertainties in the dark matter density profile, the potential presence of DM substructures, and the influence of baryonic matter can significantly affect the predicted flux, potentially bridging the gap between theoretical predictions and observational limits.

Key Results

  • No significant gamma-ray excess detected from Willman 1 above 100 GeV.
  • Upper limits on the integral gamma-ray flux were derived, on the order of $10^{-12}$ photons cm$^{-2}$ s$^{-1}$.
  • Boost factors of up to three orders of magnitude are required for most of the considered mSUGRA benchmark models to explain a potential signal that would match the observed upper limits.
  • The benchmark model K' (funnel region) showed the "best prospects" for detection, requiring the smallest boost factor, due to its favorable combination of neutralino mass and annihilation cross-section.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Dependence: The results are highly dependent on the chosen benchmark models and the assumed dark matter density profile. The paper acknowledges that the astrophysical factor can vary by more than an order of magnitude due to uncertainties in the DM distribution.
  • Substructure and Sommerfeld Effect: The paper explicitly mentions that the presence of DM substructures and the Sommerfeld effect (which can enhance the flux at low velocities) could significantly reduce the required boost factors, potentially bringing some models within reach of current observations.
  • Limited Observation Time: The 15.5 hours of observation time, while substantial, is still limited.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that deeper observations with the upcoming MAGIC II telescope could improve the flux limits by a factor of 2-10, potentially leading to more definitive conclusions or even a detection. Further theoretical work is also encouraged to explore the parameter space more comprehensively and to better understand the impact of astrophysical uncertainties.

Summary updated

Abstract

We present the result of the observation of the ultrafaint dwarf galaxy Willman 1 performed with the 17 m MAGIC telescope during 15.5 hr between March and May 2008. No significant gamma-ray emission was found. We derived upper limits of the order of 10(-12) ph cm(-2) s(-1) on the integral flux above 100 GeV, which we compare with predictions from several of the established neutralino benchmark models in the mSUGRA parameter space. The neutralino annihilation spectra are defined after including the recently quantified contribution of internal bremsstrahlung from the virtual sparticles that mediate the annihilation. Flux boost factors of three orders of magnitude are required even in the most optimistic scenario to match our upper limits. However, uncertainties in the dark matter intrinsic and extrinsic properties (e.g., presence of substructures, Sommerfeld effect) may significantly reduce this gap.
BibTeX
@article{aliu2009upper,
  author = {E. Aliu and H. Anderhub and L. A. Antonelli and P. Antoranz and Michael Backes and C. Baixeras and S. Balestra and J. A. Barrio and H. Bartko and D. Bastieri and J. Becerra González and J. K. Becker and W. Bednarek and K. Berger and E. Bernardini and A. Biland and R. K. Böck and G. Bonnoli and P. Bordas and D. Borla Tridon and V. Bosch-Ramón and D. Bose and T. Bretz and I. Britvitch and Montaña Cámara and E. Carmona and S. Commichau and J. L. Contreras and J. Cortina and M. T. Costado and S. Covino and V. Curtef and F. Dazzi and A. De Angelis and E. De Cea del Pozo and R. de los Reyes and B. De Lotto and Mónica María and F. De Sabata and C. Delgado Mendez and A. Domínguez and D. Dorner and M. Doro and D. Elsäesser and M. Errando and D. Ferenc and E. Fernández and R. Firpo and M. V. Fonseca and L. Font and N. Galante and R. J. Garcı́a López and M. Garczarczyk and M. Gaug and F. Göebel and D. Hadasch and M. Hayashida and A. Herrero and D. Höhne-Mönch and J. Hose and C. C. Hsu and Stefan Huber and T. Jogler and D. Kranich and A. La Barbera and A. Laille and E. Leonardo and E. Lindfors and S. Lombardi and F. Longo and Marcos López and E. Lorenz and P. Majumdar and G. Maneva and N. Mankuzhiyil and K. Mannheim and L. Maraschi and M. Mariotti and M. Martı́nez and D. Mazin and M. Meucci and M. Meyer and J. M. Miranda and R. Mirzoyan and J. Moldón and M. Moles and A. Moralejo and D. Nieto and K. Nilsson and J. Ninković and A. N. Otte and R. Mirzoyan and R. Paoletti and J. M. Paredes and M. Pasanen and D. Pascoli and F. Pauß and R. Pegna and M. A. P. Torres and M. Persic},
  title = {{UPPER LIMITS ON THE VHE GAMMA-RAY EMISSION FROM THE WILLMAN 1 SATELLITE GALAXY WITH THE MAGIC TELESCOPE}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal},
  year = {2009},
  doi = {10.1088/0004-637x/697/2/1299},
}
Figure