Upper eyelid subcutaneous orbital fat prolapse: A case series on a condition that deserves a separate name

Bin Hu, Yun Liu, Yingli Ji, Chen Zhang, Yan-ming TianHeliyon 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes a new classification for a specific type of upper eyelid swelling, "Upper Eyelid Subcutaneous Orbital Fat Prolapse" (UESOFP), distinct from the more commonly recognized subconjunctival orbital fat prolapse. By presenting three case studies, the authors highlight the unique clinical features, surgical management, and differential diagnoses of UESOFP, advocating for its recognition as a separate entity to improve clinical understanding and treatment.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In ophthalmology, orbital fat prolapse is often discussed in the context of subconjunctival prolapse, which is typically associated with aging and weakening of the orbital septum. However, the authors identify a less understood condition where orbital fat protrudes into the subcutaneous tissue of the upper eyelid, particularly in younger individuals. This condition, often presenting as a subtle swelling or "pseudo-occlusion," is frequently misdiagnosed or inadequately classified. The paper aims to address this gap by delineating the specific characteristics of this subcutaneous prolapse, differentiating it from other eyelid conditions, and proposing a distinct name to facilitate better diagnosis and management.

Methods

The study employs a case series approach, detailing three distinct cases of patients presenting with upper eyelid swelling. The methodology involves:

  • Clinical Observation and Examination: Thorough assessment of patient history, physical examination findings (swelling, eyelid crease changes, eyebrow elevation), and photographic documentation.
  • Surgical Intervention: Surgical excision of the prolapsed orbital fat through either a sub-brow or double eyelid incision.
  • Pathological Examination: Analysis of excised tissue to confirm the presence of increased adipocytes and fibroplasia.
  • Imaging: Utilization of orbital computed tomography (CT) scans to visualize the prolapsed fat and surrounding tissues.
  • Differential Diagnosis: Comparison of UESOFP with other conditions like subconjunctival orbital fat prolapse, lacrimal gland prolapse, and blepharitis.

The novelty lies in the systematic presentation and proposed classification of this specific subcutaneous fat prolapse, rather than the surgical techniques themselves, which are standard procedures.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on three individual patient cases.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Distinct Entity: Upper Eyelid Subcutaneous Orbital Fat Prolapse (UESOFP) is proposed as a distinct clinical entity, separate from subconjunctival orbital fat prolapse, due to its unique presentation and typical patient demographic.
  • Younger Demographic: UESOFP predominantly affects younger individuals, contrasting with the age-related pathogenesis of subconjunctival prolapse.
  • Subcutaneous Location: The key differentiator is the prolapse of orbital fat into the subcutaneous tissue of the mid-upper eyelid, rather than beneath the conjunctiva.
  • Cosmetic Impact: UESOFP can lead to significant cosmetic concerns, including eyelid swelling, loss of the double eyelid crease, and compensatory eyebrow elevation, impacting facial aesthetics.
  • Diagnostic Clues: CT scans can reveal medium-to low-density lesions with unclear boundaries in the anterior orbital septum, indicative of prolapsed fat and associated fibrous tissue.
  • Surgical Efficacy: Surgical excision of the prolapsed fat, with careful attention to avoiding over-removal, leads to satisfactory cosmetic and functional outcomes, including restoration of the double eyelid and normalization of eyebrow position.

Key Results

The study presents three cases with positive surgical outcomes:

  • Case 1: A 12-year-old girl experienced restoration of her double eyelid and reduced eyebrow elevation after orbital lipectomy.
  • Case 2: A 41-year-old woman showed improvements in eyelid ptosis and eyebrow elevation, with partial restoration of her double eyelid fold, one month post-surgery.
  • Case 3: A 38-year-old woman achieved complete resolution of eyelid edema and full restoration of her double eyelid and symmetrical appearance nine years after surgery.

These cases demonstrate the effectiveness of surgical intervention in addressing UESOFP and improving the aesthetic appearance of the upper eyelids.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations: The authors acknowledge the small sample size (three cases) and the brief follow-up period as significant limitations that may affect the generalizability of their findings.
  • Future Work: They suggest the need for larger, multi-center studies with extended follow-up durations to validate and generalize their findings. Further research is also required to fully elucidate the specific underlying pathogenesis of UESOFP, distinguishing it from other conditions and potentially leading to refined treatment and prevention strategies.

Summary updated

Abstract

In the field of ophthalmology, orbital fat prolapse under the upper eyelid is less recognized than subconjunctival orbital fat prolapse. Despite its occasional occurrence in clinical practice, this condition is often inadequately understood and incorrectly classified due to its subtle manifestations and the limited number of focused studies. Typically affecting young patients, the prolapse is located subcutaneously in the mid-upper eyelid, resulting in a pseudo-occlusion. This study aims to investigate this specific ocular anomaly, we delineate the clinical presentations, surgical interventions, and differential diagnoses of this condition through three representative cases, proposing its classification as a distinct disease entity named Upper Eyelid Subcutaneous Orbital Fat Prolapse (UESOFP).
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hu2024upper,
  author = {Bin Hu and Yun Liu and Yingli Ji and Chen Zhang and Yan-ming Tian},
  title = {{Upper eyelid subcutaneous orbital fat prolapse: A case series on a condition that deserves a separate name}},
  booktitle = {Heliyon},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1016/j.heliyon.2024.e37982},
}
Figure