Abstract: We present new global fits of the constrained Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (cMSSM), including LHC 1/fb integrated luminosity SUSY exclusion limits, recent LHC 5/fb constraints on the mass of the Higgs boson and XENON100 direct detection data. Our analysis fully takes into account astrophysical and hadronic uncertainties that enter the analysis when translating direct detection limits into constraints on the cMSSM parameter space. We provide results for both a Bayesian and a Frequentist statistical analysis. We find that LHC 2011 constraints in combination with XENON100 data can rule out a significant portion of the cMSSM parameter space. Our results further emphasise the complementarity of collider experiments and direct detection searches in constraining extensions of Standard Model physics. The LHC 2011 exclusion limit strongly impacts on low-mass regions of cMSSM parameter space, such as the stau co-annihilation region, while direct detection data can rule out regions of high SUSY masses, such as the Focus-Point region, which is unreachable for the LHC in the near future. We show that, in addition to XENON100 data, the experimental constraint on the anomalous magnetic moment of the muon plays a dominant role in disfavouring large scalar and gaugino masses. We find that, should the LHC 2011 excess hinting towards a Higgs boson at 126 GeV be confirmed, currently favoured regions of the cMSSM parameter space will be robustly ruled out from both a Bayesian and a profile likelihood statistical perspective.
Introduction
This study represents a pivotal moment in particle physics: the point where the first major results from the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) began to collide with the theoretical predictions of Supersymmetry (SUSY). Specifically, the authors perform a "global fit" of the constrained Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (cMSSM), checking if this popular theory can survive the combined pressure of new collider data and dark matter searches.
Supersymmetry is a theoretical framework that extends the Standard Model (SM) by predicting a "superpartner" for every known particle. The cMSSM is a simplified version of SUSY defined by just a handful of parameters. For years, it was a leading candidate for explaining dark matter and the "hierarchy problem" (why the Higgs boson is so light). However, as the LHC ramped up, it failed to find these superpartners immediately. Simultaneously, direct detection experiments like XENON100 were looking for dark matter particles (WIMPs) hitting a target on Earth. The challenge addressed here is to synthesize these disparate data points—collider limits, Higgs mass hints, dark matter density, and precision measurements—into a single statistical map.
Statistical Framework and Methodology
The authors use a sophisticated statistical toolset to perform global fits, employing the MultiNest nested sampling algorithm to explore the high-dimensional cMSSM parameter space. The paper provides results from two distinct statistical perspectives:
- Bayesian Analysis: Marginalized posterior distributions, which account for "volume effects" and depend on the choice of priors (e.g., flat vs. log priors).
- Frequentist Analysis: Profile likelihoods, which focus strictly on the best-fit points.
Unlike many previous studies, this analysis explicitly includes "nuisance parameters" to account for uncertainties in Standard Model values (like the top quark mass) and astrophysical/nuclear physics (like the local density of dark matter). This makes the constraints from direct detection experiments much more robust.
Data Integration and Complementarity
The study integrates several high-impact datasets available at the time, including 1 fb⁻¹ of LHC SUSY searches, 5 fb⁻¹ of Higgs search data (including a 2.3σ excess at 126 GeV), and 100.9 days of XENON100 exposure.
A key insight of the paper is the experimental complementarity: the LHC is most effective at ruling out low-mass regions (like the "stau co-annihilation" region), while XENON100 is better at ruling out high-mass regions (like the "Focus-Point" region) that the LHC cannot yet reach. Furthermore, the anomalous magnetic moment of the muon ($(g-2)_\mu$) remains a primary driver for favoring low-mass SUSY; without this constraint, the "best-fit" regions would drift toward much heavier, harder-to-detect particles.
Key Results and the Higgs Tension
The combination of LHC 2011 and XENON100 data rules out large swaths of previously favored cMSSM territory. The best-fit points moved to significantly higher masses compared to 2010 analyses; for example, the best-fit gluino mass moved toward the 1.5–2 TeV range.
Perhaps the most significant finding is the "Higgs Tension." The authors find that if the 126 GeV Higgs signal is confirmed, it would be in direct conflict with the regions of the cMSSM favored by other data. To accommodate a 126 GeV Higgs in the cMSSM, one generally requires very heavy stop squarks, which contradicts the "light" SUSY preferred by the $(g-2)_\mu$ measurement. The paper explicitly states that a 126 GeV Higgs would "robustly rule out" the currently favored regions of the cMSSM from both statistical perspectives.
Conclusion and Outlook
While the results are specific to the cMSSM, they highlight the increasing pressure on minimal SUSY models. The authors acknowledge that more complex versions of SUSY (like the pMSSM) might more easily accommodate a 126 GeV Higgs. At the time of writing, the 126 GeV Higgs was an "excess," not a discovery, but the authors correctly anticipated that its confirmation would necessitate a major rethink of minimal Supersymmetry.
Summary updated