Unveiling Thermal Degradation and Fire Behavior of 110 kV Ultra-High-Voltage Flame-Retardant Cable Sheath After Thermal Aging

Yaqiang Jiang, Wei He, Xiaoming Huo, Xuelian Lu, Kaiyuan Li, Fei XiaoPolymers 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how thermal aging affects the fire safety of 110 kV ultra-high-voltage (UHV) flame-retardant PVC cable sheaths. Surprisingly, while aging slightly reduces flame retardancy metrics like LOI, it actually leads to a reduced fire hazard under forced combustion conditions, evidenced by longer ignition times and lower heat release rates, due to improved char formation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Ultra-high-voltage (UHV) cables are critical for modern power grids, but their extensive use of combustible polymer materials (like PVC sheaths) poses a significant fire risk, especially within confined utility tunnels where they operate under elevated temperatures. While flame retardants are incorporated into these sheaths, their effectiveness can degrade over time due to "thermal aging" – the cumulative effect of prolonged exposure to heat during service. Previous research has yielded conflicting results on whether aging increases or decreases fire risk, highlighting a need for a comprehensive understanding of how aging impacts the thermal degradation and combustion behavior of these essential cables. This paper aims to fill this gap by systematically evaluating the fire safety of aged UHV cable sheaths.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach to assess the fire behavior of both unaged (S1) and thermally aged (S2) 110 kV flame-retardant PVC cable sheaths. Key techniques included:

  • Thermogravimetric Analysis (TGA) & Derivative Thermogravimetric (DTG): To understand the thermal stability and decomposition stages of the materials.
  • Limiting Oxygen Index (LOI): A standard test to quantify the minimum oxygen concentration required to sustain combustion.
  • UL-94 Vertical Burning Test: To assess flammability, fire spread, and self-extinguishing properties.
  • Cone Calorimeter: A crucial instrument for measuring heat release rate (HRR), total heat release (THR), smoke production, and time to ignition (TTI) under controlled radiant heat flux.
  • Open Flame Test (Butane Torch): To simulate a direct flame impingement scenario and observe real-time temperature changes and visual combustion behavior.
  • Muffle Furnace Test: To examine thermal stability at various elevated temperatures.
  • Fourier Transform Infrared (FTIR) Spectroscopy: To analyze changes in chemical composition and functional groups due to aging.
  • Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM): To observe surface morphology and the structure of char residues.
  • Contact Angle (CA) Test: To assess changes in surface hydrophilicity.

The thermal aging itself was conducted in an air circulation oven at 135 °C for 14 days, simulating long-term service conditions.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on experimental characterization of cable sheath materials.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Aging Paradox: The most striking finding is that while some basic flame retardancy metrics (like LOI) slightly decrease after aging, the overall fire hazard under forced combustion conditions appears to decrease. This challenges the intuitive assumption that aging always worsens fire performance.
  • Char Formation is Key: The improved fire performance post-aging is strongly linked to the formation of a more robust and complex char layer. This char acts as a thermal barrier, insulating the underlying material and hindering the release of flammable gases.
  • Surface Changes Matter: Thermal aging significantly alters the surface morphology, increasing roughness and creating cracks. This, surprisingly, leads to increased hydrophilicity (lower contact angle), which might influence how the material interacts with heat and moisture.
  • De-chlorination and Cross-linking: FTIR analysis suggests that thermal aging involves de-chlorination reactions and the formation of cross-linked structures within the PVC matrix. These structural changes are likely responsible for the altered thermal and combustion behaviors.

Key Results

  • LOI: Slightly decreased from 28.5% (unaged) to 28.3% (aged).
  • UL-94: Both unaged and aged samples passed the V-0 rating, though the aged sample had a slightly longer afterglow.
  • Cone Calorimeter:
    • Time to Ignition (TTI) increased from 6s to 8s.
  • Peak Heat Release Rate (pHRR1) decreased by ~18% (162.1 kW/m² to 133.7 kW/m²).
  • Total Heat Release (THR) decreased by ~24.4% (163.6 MJ/m² to 123.7 MJ/m²).
  • Smoke production (TSP) significantly decreased (76.7 m² to 41.7 m²).
  • FIGRA (flame growth rate index) decreased from 1.33 to 0.92.
  • Open Flame Test: Aged samples showed more violent initial ignition but exhibited better fire resistance in sustained burning, with lower peak backside temperatures in later stages compared to unaged samples.
  • TGA: The initial decomposition temperature (T5%) slightly decreased for aged samples (277.5 °C to 271.5 °C), indicating earlier onset of degradation. However, the residual char yield increased at higher temperatures (21.0% to 23.9%).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Conflicting Indicators: The paper acknowledges the apparent contradiction between slightly reduced LOI/UL-94 performance and improved cone calorimeter results. This highlights the complexity of fire behavior and the need to consider multiple metrics.
  • Aging Conditions: The study used a specific aging temperature (135 °C) and duration (14 days). Future work could explore a wider range of aging conditions to better map the degradation pathways and their impact on fire safety.
  • Material Complexity: While focusing on the sheath, UHV cables are complex multi-component systems. Future research could investigate the synergistic or antagonistic effects of aging on other cable components (insulation, conductor).
  • Real-World Scenarios: While the tests provide valuable insights, simulating the full spectrum of real-world fire scenarios in utility tunnels (e.g., ventilation, cable arrangement) would offer further validation.

The authors suggest their findings provide crucial theoretical support for improving cable sheath formulations, enhancing durability, and refining fire protection designs for UHV cables.

Summary updated

Abstract

To evaluate the fire safety of 110 kV ultra-high-voltage flame-retardant polyvinyl chloride (PVC) cables in the service process, the effects of thermal aging on the pyrolysis and combustion behavior of the cable sheaths were studied using thermogravimetric (TG), limiting oxygen index (LOI), UL-94 vertical burning, cone calorimeter, open flame, and muffle furnace tests. The results showed that thermal aging causes a slight decrease in the LOI value of the cable sheath (28.3% vs. 28.5%), but it also passed the UL-94 V-0 test. The butane torch test showed that the cable sheath was more easily ignited after aging; however, a better char layer was formed in the later stage of burning, which led to a longer failure time. Interestingly, the aging treatment prolonged the ignition time of the cable sheaths and reduced the peak heat release rate (pHRR) and total heat release (THR) by 17.5% and 24.4%, respectively, in the cone calorimeter test, indicating that aging resulted in a reduction in the fire hazard of the cable sheaths. Moreover, aging mechanisms were proposed based on the composition and structural evolution of the cable sheaths. In summary, this work comprehensively evaluated the fire hazard of 110 kV ultra-high-voltage cables and provided theoretical support for the formulation improvement, durability enhancement, and fire protection design of cable sheath materials.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{jiang2025unveiling,
  author = {Yaqiang Jiang and Wei He and Xiaoming Huo and Xuelian Lu and Kaiyuan Li and Fei Xiao},
  title = {{Unveiling Thermal Degradation and Fire Behavior of 110 kV Ultra-High-Voltage Flame-Retardant Cable Sheath After Thermal Aging}},
  booktitle = {Polymers},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/polym17091273},
}
Figure