TL;DR
This paper dives into the visual rhetoric of "octopus maps," a persuasive cartography genre that uses octopus imagery to represent powerful, often oppressive, entities. By analyzing a corpus of 90 such maps, the authors reveal a detailed design space of conceptual metaphors and rhetorical strategies, demonstrating how these maps have evolved and continue to be used effectively across different cultures and time periods.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
While the persuasive power of data visualizations is well-established, the underlying mechanisms of rhetorical construction within these visualizations remain under-explored. The authors argue that understanding how visualizations persuade requires a deeper look at their visual rhetoric, moving beyond simply evaluating their effects. They focus on "octopus maps" as a case study because this genre has a long history, significant social impact, and rich design elements that lend themselves to rhetorical analysis. The paper aims to fill the gap by systematically analyzing the design choices in octopus maps to characterize their rhetorical techniques and strategies.
Methods
The researchers employed a multi-stage methodology rooted in iconographic tracking and rhetorical schema theory.
- Corpus Curation: They built a corpus of 90 octopus maps from the 19th century to the present day using a four-phase process:
- Data Hoarding: Broad searches for "octopus map" and similar terms across various digital map collections.
- Data Mining: Identifying keywords like "persuasive maps," "propaganda," and "war map" to refine searches.
- Assembling a Collection: Expanding searches to include more diverse sources like Wikimedia Commons and Reddit.
- Data Cleaning: Applying strict exclusion criteria, ensuring maps encoded geographic data and featured octopuses, and removing purely political cartoons without data.
- Rhetorical Analysis Framework: They developed a coding framework based on rhetorical schema theory, focusing on two main dimensions:
- Conceptual Metaphors: Analyzing how abstract concepts are mapped onto concrete ones (e.g., "the oppressor is an octopus," "ways of oppression are tentacles"). They identified ontological, structural, and orientational metaphors.
- Rhetorical Strategies: Examining how persuasion is achieved across three editorial layers:
- Universal Strategies: Applied across the entire map (e.g., contrast, display, metonymy).
- Octopus Depiction Strategies: Focusing on how the octopus itself is portrayed (e.g., enargeia for vividness, personification, placement).
- Cartographic Strategies: Analyzing map-specific choices (e.g., map type, distortion, color choices, scientific symbols).
- Textual Strategies: Examining the role of text (e.g., explanation, language choice).
- Coding Process: Three researchers independently coded the corpus, followed by discussions to refine codes and ensure inter-coder reliability (achieving a Krippendorff's alpha of 0.82).
Datasets
The primary dataset is a newly curated corpus of 90 octopus maps spanning from 1866 to 2025, collected from various online sources. This corpus is made publicly available.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Octopus Maps Aren't Just Historical: Contrary to common perception, octopus maps are a vibrant and active design convention in the digital age, appearing on social media and blogs.
- Rhetoric is Key to Persuasion: The effectiveness of these maps lies not just in their imagery but in the strategic interplay of conceptual metaphors and rhetorical techniques.
- Cultural Nuances in Metaphor: While Western discourse often casts the octopus as evil, other cultures (like Polynesian and Japanese) can use the octopus metaphor positively, highlighting the dynamic nature of visual rhetoric across different sociocultural settings.
- Embellishments are Powerful: Figurative elements like the octopus aren't mere decoration; they play a significant role in conveying core information and shaping emotional responses, often through sophisticated integration with cartographic elements.
- Ethical Implications: The study underscores the potent persuasive power of visualizations, urging awareness of potential manipulation and the need for visualization literacy.
Key Results
The analysis revealed a detailed "design space" for octopus maps, categorizing their visual rhetoric. Key findings include:
- Dominant Metaphor: The most prevalent conceptual metaphor is "the oppressor is an octopus" (N=68), with tentacles representing "ways of oppression" (N=57).
- Common Orientational Metaphor: "The oppressor is at the top" (N=40) is a frequent orientational strategy.
- Most Used Strategy: Contrast is the most frequently used universal rhetorical strategy (N=210), often employing thematic (e.g., invading vs. invaded) and stylistic (e.g., light vs. dark) contrasts.
- Octopus Depiction: Realistic depiction (enargeia, N=72) and personification (facial expressions, N=50) are common techniques to evoke emotion.
- Cartographic Choices: 2D maps (N=70) are more common than 3D globes (N=20), and various types of distortion (area size, N=26; distance, N=20) are employed to emphasize certain aspects.
- Textual Role: Explanation through labels (N=29) and detailed descriptions (N=18) is crucial for conveying the map's persuasive message.
Limitations and Future Work
- Corpus Limitations: The authors acknowledge that their corpus, while extensive, is not exhaustive due to the ephemeral nature of propaganda and language barriers.
- Media Context: The analysis primarily focused on the maps themselves, with less emphasis on the surrounding media context (articles, etc.) in which they were published.
- Genre Specificity: The study focuses on octopus maps, and while the rhetorical framework is generalizable, some specific techniques might not apply to all visualization types.
Future work could involve:
- Applying the rhetorical lens to other types of visualizations, especially those involving narrative or persuasive intent.
- Expanding the analysis to include more diverse languages and cultural contexts.
- Conducting user studies to further investigate the impact of specific rhetorical strategies on audience perception and attitude change.
- Developing more automated methods for analyzing visual rhetoric in large datasets.
Summary updated