TL;DR
This study uses a meta-analysis of 37 empirical studies to identify and rank the most impactful transaction costs (TCs) in Modular Integrated Construction (MiC). It reveals that operational and procedural issues like "Poor Logistics," "Design Change," and "Insufficient Quality Inspection Standards" are the biggest drivers of TCs, diverging significantly from factors that are merely most frequently discussed in the literature. This provides a data-driven roadmap for improving MiC adoption.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Modular Integrated Construction (MiC) offers significant advantages in sustainability and efficiency over traditional building methods. However, its widespread adoption is hampered by "transaction costs" (TCs) – the expenses associated with coordinating, negotiating, and enforcing agreements. While many studies have identified barriers to MiC, there's been a lack of a systematic, quantitative approach to understand which of these barriers have the greatest impact on TCs. This paper aims to fill that gap by using a meta-analysis to precisely quantify and rank these influential factors, moving beyond simple frequency counts of discussed barriers.
Methods
The researchers employed a hybrid approach combining a systematic literature review with a meta-analysis.
- Systematic Review: They scoured major databases (Web of Science, Scopus, IEEE Xplore) for studies on MiC and transaction costs, filtering for relevance and quality. This process identified 37 relevant empirical studies.
- Meta-Analysis: Data from these studies were extracted and statistically aggregated. A random-effects model was used to account for the inherent variability across different studies (e.g., geographic context, project types). The "effect size" for each TC driver was measured using the pooled mean Likert scale rating from the studies, indicating its perceived severity. This allowed for a quantitative ranking of the factors.
- Subgroup and Sensitivity Analyses: To explore sources of variation and confirm the reliability of findings, subgroup analyses were conducted based on publication year, economic development level, and study region. A "leave-one-out" sensitivity analysis was also performed to check if any single study disproportionately influenced the results.
Datasets
The study did not introduce new datasets. Instead, it synthesized data from 37 existing empirical studies published between 2005 and 2025. These studies utilized various methodologies, including questionnaire surveys (16 studies, n=2262 respondents), mixed-methods approaches (6 studies), in-depth case studies (9 studies), literature reviews (6 studies), and data mining/archival analysis (2 studies).
Key Insights and Ideas
- Frequency vs. Impact: The most striking insight is the significant divergence between factors most frequently discussed in the literature and those that most severely impact transaction costs. This highlights a critical limitation of relying solely on citation counts for prioritization.
- Operational Hurdles Dominate: The top drivers of TCs are not abstract financial or institutional barriers, but rather practical, operational, and governance issues that arise during project execution.
- Context Matters, But Core Issues Persist: While subgroup analyses show that institutional and regulatory factors are more severe in developing economies, and coordination issues intensify as the industry matures, certain core challenges remain consistently impactful.
- Meta-Analysis as a Superior Tool: The study validates meta-analysis as a powerful tool for evidence-based decision-making in construction management, offering a more precise and reliable understanding of factor importance than traditional narrative reviews.
Key Results
The meta-analysis identified and ranked 32 influencing factors of TCs in MiC. The top 15 most influential factors, ranked by pooled mean effect size (on a 1-5 Likert scale), are:
- Poor Logistics (D3): Pooled Mean = 3.87
- Design Change (D2): Pooled Mean = 3.85
- Insufficient Quality Inspection Standards and Regulations (D15): Pooled Mean = 3.82
- Insufficient Stakeholder Collaboration (D24): Pooled Mean = 3.78
- Shortage of Skilled Professionals (D27): Pooled Mean = 3.69
- Inadequate Awareness of Modular Construction (D29): Pooled Mean = 3.69
- Lack of Relevant Technical Support (D8): Pooled Mean = 3.62
- Insufficient Government Support and Incentives (D11): Pooled Mean = 3.53
- Increased Initial Investment Requirement (D1): Pooled Mean = 3.53
- Economies of Scale (D14): Pooled Mean = 3.48
The heterogeneity statistics (I²) for the top factors consistently exceeded 90%, indicating extreme variability across studies, underscoring the context-dependent nature of these impacts. Subgroup analyses revealed that institutional and regulatory drivers were more pronounced in developing economies, and coordination-related challenges intensified with industry maturation.
Limitations and Future Work
- Data Availability & Heterogeneity: The meta-analysis was limited by the quantitative data available in the literature, with some factors supported by only a few studies. High residual heterogeneity (I² > 90%) across most factors indicates that unmeasured contextual variables (e.g., specific project types, regional response styles) significantly influence TC impacts.
- No Formal Risk-of-Bias Assessment: The study did not conduct a formal risk-of-bias assessment, as standardized instruments are not always applicable to this type of research. However, transparency was maintained through a descriptive overview of study methodologies.
- Future Research:
- Conduct primary empirical research with standardized measurement scales to improve data comparability.
- Employ advanced meta-regression techniques to quantitatively examine how multiple contextual factors influence TC drivers.
- Investigate the interactions and cascading effects among different TC drivers using methods like structural equation modeling.
- Develop standardized measurement scales for transaction cost drivers to enrich the meta-analytic database and facilitate more robust cross-study comparisons.
Summary updated