Unveiling the Importance of SIC in NOMA Systems - Part 1: State of the Art and Recent Findings

Zhiguo Ding, Robert Schober, H. Vincent PoorIEEE Communications Letters 2020 · DOI

Abstract

The key idea of non-orthogonal multiple access (NOMA) is to serve multiple users simultaneously at the same time and frequency, which can result in excessive multiple-access interference. As a crucial component of NOMA systems, successive interference cancelation (SIC) is key to combating this multiple-access interference, and is the focus of this letter, where an overview of SIC decoding order selection schemes is provided. In particular, selecting the SIC decoding order based on the users' channel state information (CSI) and the users' quality of service (QoS), respectively, is discussed. The limitations of these two approaches are illustrated, and then a recently proposed scheme, termed hybrid SIC, which dynamically adapts the SIC decoding order is presented and shown to achieve a surprising performance improvement that cannot be realized by the conventional SIC decoding order selection schemes individually.

Introduction: The NOMA Interference Challenge

In the evolution toward 5G and beyond, Non-Orthogonal Multiple Access (NOMA) has emerged as a promising technique to increase spectral efficiency by allowing multiple users to share the same time and frequency resources. Unlike traditional Orthogonal Multiple Access (OMA), NOMA intentionally introduces multiple-access interference to accommodate more users.

To manage this interference, receivers employ Successive Interference Cancellation (SIC). This process involves decoding users sequentially and subtracting their signals from the composite received signal to "peel away" interference for subsequent users. A critical design decision in NOMA is the SIC decoding order, which traditionally follows one of two fixed strategies:

  1. CSI-based SIC: Decodes the user with the strongest channel first.
  2. QoS-based SIC: Decodes the user with the most basic data requirements (Quality of Service) first.

However, both strategies possess inherent limitations. CSI-based SIC often encounters an outage probability error floor, where increasing transmit power fails to further reduce errors. Conversely, QoS-based SIC struggles to scale effectively as the number of users increases.

Methods: The Hybrid SIC Approach

To overcome these limitations, researchers have proposed Hybrid SIC, a dynamic scheme that adapts the decoding order based on instantaneous conditions. The core of this approach includes:

  • Threshold Mechanism: The system establishes a channel quality threshold ($\tau$).
  • Dynamic Grouping: Users are categorized based on whether their channel gain exceeds or falls below this threshold.
  • Opportunistic Decoding: The base station dynamically selects the decoding order that maximizes the achievable data rate for the admitted user, effectively combining the strengths of both CSI- and QoS-based methods.

This theoretical framework was validated using Monte Carlo simulations under Rayleigh fading channel models, representing typical urban signal propagation environments.

Key Insights: Beyond Simple Averaging

The analysis reveals that Hybrid SIC is not merely a compromise between traditional methods; it fundamentally alters the system's mathematical behavior.

  • Hidden Constraints: The hybrid approach introduces a "hidden constraint" in the outage probability calculation that effectively cancels out the error floor seen in CSI-based systems.
  • Leveraging Redundancy: For users with low data rate requirements (e.g., IoT sensors), heavy error-correction coding allows successful decoding even under significant interference from "stronger" users.
  • Multi-user Diversity: Unlike QoS-based SIC, Hybrid SIC performance improves with higher user density, as the system has more options to optimize the transmission candidate.

Key Results and Performance Gains

Numerical evaluations highlight the significant advantages of the Hybrid SIC scheme. As shown in Figure 3, while CSI-based and QoS-based SIC curves eventually flatten into an error floor, the Hybrid SIC outage probability continues to decrease as the Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR) improves.

Comparison of Outage Probability and Sum Rate Gain for CSI-based, QoS-based, and Hybrid SIC schemes.

Furthermore, Hybrid SIC consistently delivers the highest sum rate gains over traditional OMA. It remains robust even when users have similar channel conditions—a scenario where CSI-based NOMA typically degrades to OMA performance levels.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This study underscores that the SIC decoding order is a pivotal factor in NOMA performance. By adopting a hybrid, dynamic approach, networks can eliminate performance bottlenecks like error floors and significantly enhance overall throughput.

Future work in this series (Part 2) will extend these findings to more complex scenarios, including the impact of transmit power control, downlink transmissions, and diverse network topologies.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{ding2020unveiling,
  author = {Zhiguo Ding and Robert Schober and H. Vincent Poor},
  title = {{Unveiling the Importance of SIC in NOMA Systems - Part 1: State of the Art and Recent Findings}},
  journal = {IEEE Communications Letters},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1109/lcomm.2020.3012604},
}
Figure