Unveiling the Impacts of Sodium Hypochlorite on the Characteristics and Fouling Behaviors of Different Commercial Polyvinylidene Fluoride Hollow Fiber Membranes

Muqiao Han, Qi Han, Shanwei Wu, Xiao Hu, Lei Zhang, Yibo Lin, Fangang Meng, Shanshan ZhaoMembranes 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how sodium hypochlorite (NaOCl), a common cleaning agent for membranes, affects the properties and fouling behavior of three commercial PVDF hollow fiber membranes. The findings reveal that NaOCl can alter membrane pore structure and surface chemistry, leading to varied impacts on performance and fouling resistance, with pH playing a crucial role.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Membrane bioreactors (MBRs) are widely used for wastewater treatment due to their high effluent quality and compact design. However, membrane fouling remains a significant challenge, necessitating regular cleaning to restore performance and extend membrane lifespan. Sodium hypochlorite (NaOCl) is a popular choice for chemical cleaning due to its low cost and effectiveness against organic and biological foulants. Despite its widespread use, NaOCl can also degrade the intrinsic properties of membranes, potentially reducing their long-term performance. While previous research has explored NaOCl's impact on various membrane materials, a comprehensive understanding of its effects on different commercial PVDF hollow fiber membranes, particularly concerning the interplay of NaOCl concentration, pH, and subsequent fouling behavior, is still needed for optimizing cleaning strategies.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach to characterize the membranes:

  • NaOCl Exposure: Three commercial PVDF hollow fiber membranes (SMM-1010, MEMCOR® CS II, and ZeeWeed 500) were exposed to NaOCl solutions at different concentrations (up to 2000 ppm) and pH levels (8 and 10) for extended periods (up to 500 hours).
  • Morphological Analysis: Field Emission Scanning Electron Microscopy (FESEM) was used to examine changes in the surface and cross-section morphologies of the membranes.
  • Chemical Composition Analysis: Attenuated Total Reflectance Fourier Transform Infrared (ATR-FTIR) spectroscopy was employed to identify changes in the surface functional groups.
  • Surface Hydrophilicity Measurement: Dynamic water contact angles (WCAs) were measured using a force tensiometer to quantify changes in surface hydrophilicity.
  • Mechanical Property Testing: Tensile stress tests were performed on individual fibers, and collapse pressure was measured for membrane modules to assess mechanical integrity.
  • Separation Performance Evaluation: Pure water permeability (PWP) was measured, and humic acid (HA) rejection was assessed to evaluate the membranes' separation capabilities.
  • Fouling Behavior Assessment: Bench-scale crossflow filtration experiments using HA as a model foulant were conducted to evaluate the fouling propensity of the pristine and NaOCl-aged membranes. Flux recovery ratios (FRRs) were also determined after physical cleaning to assess the reversibility of fouling.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized commercially available membranes and prepared chemical solutions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • NaOCl Alters Membrane Surface Morphology: NaOCl exposure, especially at lower pH (8), leads to the formation of new pores and a wrinkled surface structure on PVDF membranes, indicating chemical degradation.
  • Surface Chemistry Transformation: FTIR analysis revealed the degradation of hydrophilic additives (like PVP) and the formation of new functional groups (carboxylic acid at pH 10, succinimide at pH 8) on the membrane surface, influencing hydrophilicity.
  • pH-Dependent Impacts: The study highlights that NaOCl's effect on membrane properties is significantly influenced by pH. Lower pH (8) generally resulted in more pronounced changes, such as increased pore formation.
  • Varied Responses Among Membrane Types: Different commercial PVDF membranes exhibited distinct responses to NaOCl aging. Some showed minor changes in hydrophilicity and permeability, while others experienced more significant alterations.
  • Antifouling Performance Divergence: While some membranes showed slightly improved antifouling properties after NaOCl treatment, one membrane type (ZeeWeed 500) exhibited aggravated fouling, suggesting that NaOCl's impact isn't universally beneficial.
  • PVDF's Robustness: Overall, PVDF membranes demonstrated good chemical resistance to NaOCl, with mechanical properties remaining largely unaffected, which is a significant advantage for their application.

Key Results

  • Pore Formation: Membrane pores increased with prolonged NaOCl exposure, with more pores observed at pH 8.
  • Functional Group Changes: Amide groups disappeared, while carboxylic acid (pH 10) and succinimide (pH 8) groups were formed.
  • Hydrophilicity and PWP: SMM-1010 and MEMCOR® CS II membranes showed insignificant changes in hydrophilicity and PWP. However, ZeeWeed 500's hydrophilicity slightly decreased, and its PWP increased by approximately 1.4-fold.
  • HA Rejection: HA rejection remained largely unchanged across all membranes and conditions, suggesting robust separation performance despite surface modifications.
  • Fouling Behavior: SMM-1010 and MEMCOR® CS II membranes showed slightly improved antifouling properties after NaOCl aging at pH 10. Conversely, the ZeeWeed 500 membrane experienced more severe flux decline with HA filtration after NaOCl aging.
  • Mechanical Properties: The mechanical properties of the PVDF membranes were robust and largely unaffected by NaOCl aging.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited pH Range: The study focused on alkaline conditions (pH 8 and 10). Further investigation into the effects of NaOCl at neutral or acidic pH, where its oxidation capability is higher, could provide a more complete picture.
  • Model Foulant: Humic acid was used as a model foulant. Future studies could explore the fouling behavior with more complex real wastewater matrices to better reflect practical conditions.
  • Correlation Depth: While correlations between physicochemical changes and fouling behavior were discussed, deeper mechanistic understanding of these relationships could be beneficial.
  • Optimization Guidance: The authors suggest that their findings provide guidance for practical chemical cleaning optimization. Future work could focus on developing specific cleaning protocols tailored to different membrane types and fouling scenarios.
  • Long-Term Performance: While the study involved extended exposure times, long-term operational data under real-world conditions would further validate these findings.

Summary updated

Abstract

Sodium hypochlorite (NaOCl) is a commonly used cleaning agent for recovering membrane performance in membrane technologies. A thorough understanding of the impacts of NaOCl exposure on membrane properties and fouling behavior is important for optimizing chemical cleaning process and extending membrane lifespan. In this study, three commercial polyvinylidene fluoride (PVDF) hollow fiber ultrafiltration membranes (SMM-1010, MEMCOR<sup>®</sup> CS II and ZeeWeed 500) were used to systematically explore the effects of NaOCl dose and solution pH (8 and 10) on membrane properties. The results showed that membrane pores increased with exposure time prolonging, and more pores were observed at pH 8 aging condition. The amide group in the Fourier transformation infrared spectra was disappeared, while the carboxylic acid and succinimide groups were formed at pH 10 and pH 8 conditions, respectively. The hydrophilicity and pure water permeability (PWP) of SMM-1010 and MEMCOR<sup>®</sup> CS II membranes had insignificant changes during NaOCl aging process, whereas the hydrophilicity of ZeeWeed 500 membrane slightly decreased and its PWP increased by 1.4-fold. The antifouling properties of NaOCl-aged SMM-1010 and MEMCOR<sup>®</sup> CS II membranes were slightly improved, whereas the NaOCl-aged ZeeWeed 500 membrane showed severer flux decline with humic acid filtration. Our findings could provide guidance for practical chemical cleaning process optimization.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{han2022unveiling,
  author = {Muqiao Han and Qi Han and Shanwei Wu and Xiao Hu and Lei Zhang and Yibo Lin and Fangang Meng and Shanshan Zhao},
  title = {{Unveiling the Impacts of Sodium Hypochlorite on the Characteristics and Fouling Behaviors of Different Commercial Polyvinylidene Fluoride Hollow Fiber Membranes}},
  booktitle = {Membranes},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/membranes12100965},
}

Loading related content...

Figure