Unusual KIE and dynamics effects in the Fe-catalyzed hetero-Diels-Alder reaction of unactivated aldehydes and dienes

Yuhong Yang, Xiaoyong Zhang, Liping Zhong, Jialing Lan, Xin Li, Chuang‐Chuang Li, Lung Wa ChungNature Communications 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the mechanism of an iron-catalyzed hetero-Diels-Alder (HDA) reaction, revealing that the iron catalyst significantly alters the reaction's dynamics, promoting a more stepwise process. Surprisingly, unusually large kinetic isotope effects were observed, not solely due to bond formation but also influenced by the catalyst's coordination state.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The hetero-Diels-Alder (HDA) reaction is a cornerstone in organic synthesis for creating valuable six-membered rings, crucial for natural products and pharmaceuticals. However, activating unactivated aldehydes for this reaction typically requires harsh conditions or highly specialized, often toxic, reagents. While a recent iron(III) porphyrin catalyst has shown remarkable selectivity and mild reaction conditions for this challenging transformation, the underlying mechanistic details, particularly the reaction dynamics and the origin of its unusual selectivity, remained elusive. This study aims to elucidate these mechanistic aspects, bridging the gap between experimental observations and theoretical understanding.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach combining advanced computational techniques with experimental validation:

  • Density Functional Theory (DFT) Calculations: Extensive DFT calculations were performed to map out the potential energy surfaces for both uncatalyzed and Fe-catalyzed HDA reactions. This included exploring various transition states, intermediates, and reaction pathways across different spin states (doublet, quartet, sextet) and coordination modes (five-coordinate vs. six-coordinate) of the iron catalyst.
  • Quasi-Classical Molecular Dynamics (MD) Simulations: To understand the dynamic aspects of the reaction, DFT-based quasi-classical MD simulations were conducted. This allowed the researchers to observe the actual time evolution of the reaction, identifying whether bond formation occurred in a concerted or stepwise manner and characterizing the "entrance" and "exit" channels of the reaction trajectory.
  • Kinetic Isotope Effect (KIE) Studies: Both computational and experimental secondary deuterium KIE studies were performed. By comparing the reaction rates of deuterated versus non-deuterated substrates, these experiments provide crucial insights into the transition state structure and the extent of bond breaking/forming at the rate-determining step.
  • Experimental Verification: Key computational predictions, particularly regarding chemoselectivity, were experimentally verified through targeted reactions.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on theoretical calculations and experimental validation of a specific reaction system.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Iron as a Dynamic Modulator: The iron catalyst doesn't just lower the activation barrier; it fundamentally alters the reaction's dynamics. It promotes a more "stepwise" process, with distinct C-C and C-O bond formations, and broadens the "entrance channel" (where reactants approach) while narrowing the "exit channel" (where products depart).
  • The Surprise of Secondary KIE: Unusually large secondary kinetic isotope effects (KIEs) were observed for the five-coordinate pathway, even when significant C-C bond formation was occurring. This was unexpected because typically, larger KIEs are associated with more bond breaking at the transition state.
  • Equilibrium Isotope Effect (EIE) as a Hidden Factor: The large KIEs in the five-coordinate pathway were attributed to a significant secondary equilibrium isotope effect (EIE). This arises from changes in the catalyst's coordination state, which subtly alters the vibrational frequencies of the aldehyde, influencing the equilibrium between reactants and intermediates. This highlights how catalyst coordination can mask the direct KIE information.
  • Spin and Coordination Control Dynamics: The study demonstrates that the iron catalyst's spin state and coordination number (five- vs. six-coordinate) can control whether the reaction proceeds via a dynamically concerted or stepwise mechanism.
  • Predicting Chemoselectivity: Computational analysis successfully predicted the chemoselectivity of the reaction for α,β-unsaturated aldehydes, showing that steric and electronic effects dictated the preference for C=O bond addition, which was then confirmed experimentally.

Key Results

  • Lowered Barriers: The Fe-catalyzed HDA reaction exhibits significantly lower activation barriers (20.3–24.5 kcal mol⁻¹) compared to the uncatalyzed reaction (36.0–37.3 kcal mol⁻¹).
  • Concerted Asynchronous Mechanism: The catalyzed reaction proceeds through concerted asynchronous transition states, with the iron catalyst influencing the timing of C-C and C-O bond formation.
  • Experimental KIE: An experimental secondary KIE value of 0.926 (±0.007) was measured, which aligns with the computed values for both five- and six-coordinate pathways, suggesting a mixed mechanism.
  • Chemoselectivity Prediction: Computational studies accurately predicted that the catalyst would favor C=O addition in α,β-unsaturated aldehydes, a finding experimentally verified.
  • Dynamic Stepwise Dominance: MD simulations showed that the Fe-catalyzed reaction has a higher probability of proceeding via a dynamically stepwise mechanism (~21-87% in the absence of an external electric field) compared to the uncatalyzed reaction.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Masking of KIE by EIE: The study highlights that secondary KIEs can be misleading if not accounting for equilibrium isotope effects arising from catalyst coordination changes. This suggests a need for more sophisticated analysis when interpreting KIE data in metal-catalyzed reactions.
  • OEEF Influence: The paper notes that an oriented external electric field (OEEF) can further enhance the dynamically stepwise character of the reaction, suggesting potential applications in designing catalysts with controlled dynamics.
  • Broader Applicability: The authors propose that the insights gained from this iron-catalyzed system could be relevant for designing other transition metal catalysts, including homogeneous, heterogeneous, and biological catalysts, for challenging cycloaddition reactions. Future work could explore tuning metal coordination and spin states in other catalytic systems to control reaction dynamics and selectivity.

Summary updated

Abstract

Hetero-Diels-Alder (HDA) reaction is an important synthetic method for many natural products. An iron(III) catalyst was developed to catalyze the challenging HDA reaction of unactivated aldehydes and dienes with high selectivity. Here we report extensive density-functional theory (DFT) calculations and molecular dynamics simulations that show effects of iron (including its coordinate mode and/or spin state) on the dynamics of this reaction: considerably enhancing dynamically stepwise process, broadening entrance channel and narrowing exit channel from concerted asynchronous transition states. Also, our combined computational and experimental secondary KIE studies reveal unexpectedly large KIE values for the five-coordinate pathway even with considerable C-C bond forming, due to equilibrium isotope effect from the change in the metal coordination. Moreover, steric and electronic effects are computationally shown to dictate the C=O chemoselectivity for an α,β-unsaturated aldehyde, which is verified experimentally. Our mechanistic study may help design homogeneous, heterogeneous and biological catalysts for this challenging reaction.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yang2020unusual,
  author = {Yuhong Yang and Xiaoyong Zhang and Liping Zhong and Jialing Lan and Xin Li and Chuang‐Chuang Li and Lung Wa Chung},
  title = {{Unusual KIE and dynamics effects in the Fe-catalyzed hetero-Diels-Alder reaction of unactivated aldehydes and dienes}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-020-15599-w},
}
Figure