Unravelling the complexities of DNA-PK activation by structure-based mutagenesis.

Katheryn Meek, Christopher J. Buehl, Noah J. Goff, Mariia Mikhova, Steven W. Hardwick, Tom L. Blundell, Mauro Modesti, Jens C. Schmidt, Amanda K. ChaplinResearch Square 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper reveals that DNA-PK activation isn't a one-size-fits-all process. It hinges on how DNA ends interact with specific structural elements of DNA-PK, leading to either full activation for DNA repair or partial activation for end processing. This work clarifies a crucial step in DNA double-strand break repair, highlighting the intricate molecular dance required for maintaining genomic integrity.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

DNA-dependent protein kinase (DNA-PK) is a critical enzyme for repairing DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs), a particularly dangerous type of DNA damage. While it's known that DNA-PK needs to bind to a broken DNA end to become active, the precise molecular mechanisms governing this activation have remained elusive. Specifically, how the enzyme "recognizes" different types of DNA ends and translates that recognition into distinct functional outcomes (like full activation for repair versus processing of the break) is not well understood. This paper aims to dissect these activation mechanisms by investigating the role of specific DNA-PK structural features in sensing and responding to different DNA end structures.

Methods

The researchers employed a structure-based mutational approach. They designed and created various mutant forms of DNA-PKcs (the catalytic subunit of DNA-PK) by altering specific amino acid residues predicted to be involved in DNA interaction. These mutants were then tested in several assays:

  • Episomal VDJ coding and signal joining assays: These assays assess the efficiency of DNA repair pathways in cells expressing the mutant DNA-PKcs.
  • Clonogenic survival assays: This measures the ability of cells to survive DNA damage (induced by calicheamicin) when expressing different DNA-PK variants.
  • Immunoblot analyses: Used to detect and quantify autophosphorylation events on DNA-PKcs, which are indicators of kinase activity.
  • Single-molecule imaging: Employed to visualize the recruitment of DNA-PKcs to DNA breaks in living cells.
  • In vitro kinase assays: Used to directly measure the enzymatic activity of purified DNA-PKcs mutants.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental data generated from cell-based assays and in vitro experiments.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Two Modes of DNA-PK Activation: The study reveals that DNA-PK can be activated in at least two distinct ways, depending on the nature of the DNA end.
  • The DEB Helix is a Key Sensor: The "DNA End Blocking" (DEB) helix is identified as a crucial element that "senses" the DNA end. Its ability to interact with the DNA end dictates the activation pathway.
  • DNA End "Splitting" is Critical for Full Activation: When DNA ends can "split" around the DEB helix, it leads to a stable interaction with the DEB and the Helix-Hairpin-Helix (HHH) motif, resulting in full DNA-PK activation. This full activation is essential for DNA end protection and efficient repair.
  • Hairpin Ends Lead to Partial Activation: DNA ends that cannot split around the DEB (like hairpins) or when the DEB is mutated, lead to only partial and transient activation. This partial activation primarily targets specific autophosphorylation sites (ABCDE) and promotes nucleolytic end-processing, rather than full repair.
  • DEB Mutation Dysregulates End Processing: Disrupting the DEB helix leads to a failure in proper DNA end processing, causing excessive nucleotide loss at repair junctions.
  • Cooperation of DEB and HHH Motifs: The DEB helix and the HHH motif work together to signal kinase activation, with the HHH motif allosterically communicating with the N-terminus of DNA-PKcs.
  • Dimer Formation is Crucial for Repair: The formation of specific DNA-PK dimer complexes (XLF-dependent and Ku80-mediated) is vital for different aspects of DNA repair. Mutations affecting the DEB helix appear to impair the formation of the XLF-dependent dimer, which is necessary for efficient NHEJ.

Key Results

  • Mutations disrupting the DNA binding cradle (four patches in the N-HEAT region) severely impair coding and signal end joining, and cells become sensitive to calicheamicin.
  • Mutations in the DEB helix (e.g., YARK>AAAA) lead to partial activation, promoting only ABCDE autophosphorylation and increased nucleolytic end processing.
  • The DEB helix mutants exhibit increased sensitivity to calicheamicin and more nucleotide loss at repair junctions, indicating dysregulated end processing.
  • The HHH motif mutant also shows deficits in end joining, and when combined with DEB mutations, exacerbates these defects.
  • Promoting the formation of the XLF-mediated dimer (by disrupting the Ku80-mediated dimer) can partially rescue the sensitivity of DEB mutants to calicheamicin, suggesting that DEB function is linked to XLF-dependent dimer formation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Unclear Mechanism of DEB Helix Formation: The paper notes that it is still unclear what signals the structural transition that leads to the formation of the ordered DEB helix in some DNA-PK complexes but not others.
  • Shuttling Between Dimers: The precise mechanism by which DNA ends are shuttled between the Ku80-mediated and XLF-dependent dimers, and how intermediate complexes progress to ligation, remains an open question.
  • Role of PQR Phosphorylation: While PQR phosphorylation is known to limit nucleolytic activity, its precise mechanistic role in promoting the stability of the XLF-dependent dimer requires further investigation.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest further exploration into the formation of the DEB helix and the dynamics of dimer formation in DNA repair. Understanding these processes could have implications for cancer therapy, as DNA-PK is a target in some cancer treatments.

Summary updated

Abstract

It has been known for decades that the DNA-dependent protein kinase (DNA-PK) is only an active serine/threonine protein kinase when it is bound to a DNA double-stranded end; still, the molecular details of how this activation is achieved have remained elusive. The recent surge in structural information for DNA-PK complexes has provided valuable insights into the process of DNA end recognition by DNA-PK. A particularly intriguing feature of this kinase is a region of the protein that can transition from a seemingly structurally disordered state to a single alpha-helix that traverses down the DNA binding cradle. The DNA-PK bound DNA end of the DNA substrate engages with and appears to split around this helix which has been named the <b>D</b>NA <b>E</b>nd <b>B</b>locking helix (DEB). Here a mutational approach is utilized to clarify the role of the DEB, and how DNA ends activate the enzyme. Our data suggest two distinct methods of kinase activation that is dependent on the DNA end chemistry. If the DNA end can split around the helix and stabilize the interaction between the DNA end and the DEB with a recently defined <b>H</b>elix-<b>H</b>airpin-<b>H</b>elix (HHH) motif, the kinase forms an end-protection monomer that is active towards DNA-PK's many substrates. But if the DNA end cannot stably interact with the DEB [because of the DNA end structure, for instance hairpins, or because the DEB has been disrupted by mutation], the kinase is only partially activated, resulting in specific autophosphorylations of the DNA-PK monomer that allows nucleolytic end-processing. We posit that mutants that disrupt the capacity to stably generate the DEB/HHH DNA end-interaction are inefficient in generating the dimer complex that is requisite for NHEJ. In support of this idea, mutations that promote formation of this dimer partially rescue the severe cellular phenotypes associated with mutation of the DEB helix.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{meek2023unravelling,
  author = {Katheryn Meek and Christopher J. Buehl and Noah J. Goff and Mariia Mikhova and Steven W. Hardwick and Tom L. Blundell and Mauro Modesti and Jens C. Schmidt and Amanda K. Chaplin},
  title = {{Unravelling the complexities of DNA-PK activation by structure-based mutagenesis.}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-3627471/v1},
}
Figure