Unraveling the proton transfer of cellulose dissolution in aqueous NaOH/Urea solution: insights from thermodynamics by molecular dynamics simulation

Wenze Cao, Jinghua Wu, Yu Chen, Jierui Ye, Lingfeng Zhou, Xiaojing Fan, Yiwei Li, Jingyu LiResearch Square 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have used a combination of classical and first-principles molecular dynamics to reveal that cellulose dissolution in NaOH/Urea isn't just a physical mixing process—it involves a "temporary" chemical activation. Sodium hydroxide triggers a rapid deprotonation and proton recapture cycle at the cellulose C2 position, briefly turning the polymer into a charged polyelectrolyte and providing the thermodynamic "kick" needed to break its stubborn crystalline structure.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cellulose is the most abundant natural polymer on Earth, but its tight network of internal hydrogen bonds makes it notoriously difficult to dissolve. While a cold solution of sodium hydroxide (NaOH) and urea is a known solvent, it only works within a very narrow "Q-region" (8–10 wt% NaOH) and at low temperatures.

The exact molecular mechanism—specifically how the ions interact with the cellulose chain to overcome its lattice energy—has remained a subject of debate. Previous studies struggled due to a lack of accurate "force field" parameters for the hydroxide ion ($OH^-$). This paper aims to fill that gap by visualizing the proton transfer phenomenon and exploring the thermodynamic origin of cellulose's conformational changes during dissolution.

Methods

The authors employed a dual-scale simulation approach:

  • Classical Molecular Dynamics (MD): Using GROMACS with the GROMOS56<sub>ACARBO</sub> force field, they simulated eight different systems (combinations of water, urea, NaOH, and cellulose) to perform an energy decomposition analysis of enthalpy. This allowed them to calculate "excess enthalpy"—the heat released or absorbed specifically due to the mixing of components.
  • First-Principles MD (DFT): Using the VASP software package, they performed high-accuracy simulations on a simplified cellulose model ($\beta$-O-methyl-D-glucopyranoside). This allowed them to observe actual chemical bond breaking and forming (proton transfer) that classical MD cannot capture.
  • Novelty: The study utilizes a modified polarized force field for the hydroxide ion to ensure compatibility with standard carbohydrate models, allowing for a more precise look at $OH^-$ coordination.

Datasets

As a computational chemistry paper, the "datasets" consist of the specific molecular models and simulation boxes constructed:

  • Eight Simulation Boxes: Ranging from pure water (W) to a complex cellulose/urea/NaOH/water system (C/U/B/W).
  • Cellulose Model: A chain with a Degree of Polymerization (DP) of 8 for classical MD.
  • Glycoside Model: $\beta$-O-methyl-D-glucopyranoside used as the fundamental unit for first-principles calculations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Temporary" Polyelectrolyte: The most striking finding is that $OH^-$ forms a "double hydrogen bond" with the C2 and C3 hydroxyl groups. This leads to the C2 group losing a proton to the $OH^-$ (forming water). For a brief moment, the cellulose chain becomes a negatively charged polyelectrolyte. This charge repulsion helps push the chains apart.
  • Proton Recapture: The process is cyclic. The ionized oxygen at C2 quickly recaptures a proton from surrounding water molecules, regenerating the hydroxyl group and releasing a new $OH^-$ ion. This "activation" provides additional reaction enthalpy that drives dissolution.
  • Structural Transformation: The presence of NaOH breaks the internal $HO3...O5$ hydrogen bonds that maintain cellulose's standard $2_1$-helix structure, twisting it into something closer to a triple helix (similar to the structure of Na-cellulose II).
  • Na+ Coordination: Sodium ions ($Na^+$) aren't just spectators; they complex simultaneously with three oxygen atoms (O3, O5, and O6) near the glycosidic bond, further stabilizing the dissolved state.

Key Results

  • Exothermic Mixing: The mixing of NaOH and cellulose solutions is strongly exothermic. The excess enthalpy ($\Delta\Delta H_{mix,ex}$) for the full system was calculated at approximately -301 ± 4 kJ/mol, with the largest contribution coming from the interaction between cellulose and $OH^-$ ions.
  • Electrostatic Dominance: NaOH binds to cellulose primarily through electrostatic interactions, which reduces the cellulose-water electrostatic energy but increases London dispersion interactions.
  • Ion Enrichment: $Na^+$ and $OH^-$ ions are significantly enriched within 0.5 nm of the cellulose surface. The coordination number of oxygen around $Na^+$ on the cellulose surface is 0.2 higher than in the bulk solution.
  • Ionization Probability: The simulations suggest the hydroxyl groups on cellulose have a 50% probability of ionization in this environment.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Simplification: The first-principles study used a single glycoside unit. While this captures the chemistry of the functional groups, it doesn't account for the long-range cooperative effects of a full crystalline lattice.
  • DP Constraints: The classical MD used a relatively short chain (DP=8). Real-world cellulose has much higher degrees of polymerization, which might affect the kinetics of the "activation" cycle.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest this "activation" mechanism might be a necessary precursor for cellulose derivatization reactions (like making cellulose ethers). Future work could extend this thermodynamic framework to other challenging polymers, such as chitin.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> Sodium hydroxide (NaOH) plays a crucial role in the coordination structure and enthalpy contribution of cellulose dissolution. This paper utilized classical molecular dynamics (MD) simulation to reveal that NaOH mainly bound to the cellulose chain through electrostatic interaction, which reduced the electrostatic interaction between cellulose and water, but increased the London dispersion interactions between water and cellulose. In addition, the mixing of NaOH solution and cellulose solution was an exothermic process, with the largest contribution coming from cellulose and hydroxide ions (OH<sup>−</sup>). NaOH also affected the free energy change by reducing the enthalpy change of the system. The hydroxyl group at the C2 losed protons, "temporarily" transforming the molecular chain into a polyelectrolyte. Subsequently, protons were recaptured from the surrounding water molecules to achieve the diffusion of OH<sup>−</sup> around cellulose. This "activation" phenomenon involving deprotonation followed by reduction can provide additional "reaction enthalpy" for the dissolution of cellulose and increase the free energy of dissolution. With regard to Na<sup>+</sup>, it complexed with three oxygen atoms (O3, O5 and O6) near the glycosidic bond of cellulose simultaneously, and additionally complexes with around 3 water molecules. The total oxygen coordination number of Na<sup>+</sup> on the surface of the cellulose chain was 0.2 more than that of Na<sup>+</sup> in the bulk phase, leading to a certain enthalpy reduction effect. This study highlights that the enthalpy effect of NaOH may be a key step in the low-temperature dissolution of cellulose using NaOH solvent, and it may also be a necessary step in the cellulose derivatization reaction process.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cao2024unraveling,
  author = {Wenze Cao and Jinghua Wu and Yu Chen and Jierui Ye and Lingfeng Zhou and Xiaojing Fan and Yiwei Li and Jingyu Li},
  title = {{Unraveling the proton transfer of cellulose dissolution in aqueous NaOH/Urea solution: insights from thermodynamics by molecular dynamics simulation}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-5025826/v1},
}
Figure