Unraveling the Effect of Spatial Resolution and Scan Acceleration on 3D Image-Based Navigators for Respiratory Motion Tracking in Coronary MR Angiography

Srivathsan Koundinyan, Joseph Y. Cheng, Mario O. Malavé, Phillip C. Yang, Bob S. Hu, Dwight G. Nishimura, Corey A. BaronarXiv 2019 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Purpose: To study the accuracy of motion information extracted from beat-to-beat 3D image-based navigators (3D iNAVs) collected using a variable-density cones trajectory with different combinations of spatial resolutions and scan acceleration factors. Methods: Fully sampled, breath-held 4.4 mm 3D iNAV datasets for six respiratory phases were acquired in a volunteer to establish ground truth. Motion estimates from synthesized undersampled 3D iNAVs (4.4 mm, 5.4 mm, 6.4 mm, and 7.8 mm resolutions) were assessed against this ground truth. Results: Simulations indicated that high acceleration factors (e.g., for 4.4 mm resolution) compromise motion estimate accuracy due to residual aliasing and blurring. The 6.4 mm 3D iNAV (R=4.2) achieved the highest accuracy. In vivo validation confirmed superior coronary vessel sharpness using 6.4 mm 3D iNAVs. Conclusion: Undersampled 6.4 mm 3D iNAVs enable more accurate motion tracking than previously proposed 4.4 mm versions by optimizing the trade-off between resolution and reconstruction artifacts.

Introduction

Coronary Magnetic Resonance Angiography (CMRA) is a promising non-invasive tool for assessing coronary artery disease. However, respiratory motion remains a significant challenge, often leading to image blurring and artifacts. To address this, 3D image-based navigators (3D iNAVs) are used to track heart motion during each heartbeat.

While higher spatial resolution in iNAVs is theoretically desirable for capturing complex nonrigid deformations, it requires higher scan acceleration (undersampling) to fit within the limited cardiac rest period. This study investigates the "Goldilocks zone"—the optimal balance where resolution is sufficient for tracking but acceleration is low enough to maintain image fidelity.

Methods

The study utilized a 3D cones trajectory for iNAV acquisition. The pulse sequence timing, including the trigger delay and the 3D iNAV window, is illustrated in Figure 1.

Pulse sequence diagram showing the timing of the 3D iNAV acquisition within the cardiac cycle.

A simulation framework was developed to evaluate different iNAV configurations (Figure 2A). Ground truth data was obtained from a volunteer performing breath-holds at six respiratory phases. This fully sampled 4.4 mm data was then mathematically undersampled to simulate four isotropic resolutions: 4.4 mm (R=10.9), 5.4 mm (R=7.2), 6.4 mm (R=4.2), and 7.8 mm (R=2.9). The corresponding variable-density trajectory designs are shown in Figure 2B.

Simulation framework (A) for generating undersampled iNAVs and the variable-density trajectory design (B) for different resolutions.

Reconstruction was performed using L1-ESPIRiT. Motion tracking involved rigid-body registration for translations and diffeomorphic demons for nonrigid deformations. The optimized 6.4 mm configuration was then compared against the 4.4 mm standard in six healthy volunteers on a 1.5T scanner.

Results

Translational vs. Nonrigid Motion

The study found that translational motion tracking is highly robust, with all resolutions performing well (errors < 0.1 mm). However, significant differences appeared in nonrigid motion tracking. The 4.4 mm resolution suffered from substantial blurring and aliasing due to its high (10.9x) acceleration factor, leading to less accurate motion estimates than the 6.4 mm version.

The Optimal Resolution

The 6.4 mm iNAV (4.2x acceleration) provided the best balance. It maintained enough structural detail to characterize heart deformation while avoiding the severe reconstruction artifacts associated with higher acceleration.

In Vivo Performance

In volunteer studies, the 6.4 mm iNAV led to significantly better visualization of coronary arteries. Expert reader scores improved from 3.17 to 3.50 for the Right Coronary Artery (RCA) and from 3.33 to 3.81 for the Left Coronary Artery (LCA) when using the 6.4 mm iNAV (P < 0.05).

Conclusion

For 3D iNAV-based respiratory motion tracking in CMRA, a moderate resolution of 6.4 mm outperforms higher resolutions like 4.4 mm when using standard 8-channel coils. The reduced acceleration requirements of the 6.4 mm iNAV minimize reconstruction artifacts, leading to more accurate motion correction and improved coronary vessel sharpness. Future improvements in coil technology or reconstruction algorithms may shift this optimal point toward higher resolutions.

Summary updated

Abstract

Purpose: To study the accuracy of motion information extracted from beat-to-beat 3D image-based navigators (3D iNAVs) collected using a variable-density cones trajectory with different combinations of spatial resolutions and scan acceleration factors. Methods: Fully sampled, breath-held 4.4 mm 3D iNAV datasets for six respiratory phases are acquired in a volunteer. Ground truth translational and nonrigid motion information is derived from these datasets. Subsequently, the motion estimates from synthesized undersampled 3D iNAVs with isotropic spatial resolutions of 4.4 mm (acceleration factor = 10.9), 5.4 mm (acceleration factor = 7.2), 6.4 mm (acceleration factor = 4.2), and 7.8 mm (acceleration factor = 2.9) are assessed against the ground truth information. The undersampled 3D iNAV configuration with the highest accuracy motion estimates in simulation is then compared with the originally proposed 4.4 mm undersampled 3D iNAV in six volunteer studies. Results: The simulations indicate that for navigators beyond certain scan acceleration factors, the accuracy of motion estimates is compromised due to errors from residual aliasing and blurring/smoothening effects following compressed sensing reconstruction. The 6.4 mm 3D iNAV achieves an acceptable spatial resolution with a small acceleration factor, resulting in the highest accuracy motion information among all assessed undersampled 3D iNAVs. Reader scores for six volunteer studies demonstrate superior coronary vessel sharpness when applying an autofocusing nonrigid correction technique using the 6.4 mm 3D iNAVs in place of 4.4 mm 3D iNAVs. Conclusion: Undersampled 6.4 mm 3D iNAVs enable motion tracking with improved accuracy relative to previously proposed undersampled 4.4 mm 3D iNAVs.
BibTeX
@misc{koundinyan2019unraveling,
  author = {Srivathsan Koundinyan and Joseph Y. Cheng and Mario O. Malavé and Phillip C. Yang and Bob S. Hu and Dwight G. Nishimura and Corey A. Baron},
  title = {{Unraveling the Effect of Spatial Resolution and Scan Acceleration on 3D Image-Based Navigators for Respiratory Motion Tracking in Coronary MR Angiography}},
  year = {2019},
  eprint = {1910.12185},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1910.12185},
}
Figure