Unraveling the Complex Behavior of Mrk 421 with Simultaneous X-Ray and VHE Observations during an Extreme Flaring Activity in 2013 April *

V. A. Acciari, Stefano Ansoldi, L. A. Antonelli, A. Arbet Engels, Dominik Baack, A. Babić, B. Banerjee, U. Barres de Almeida, J. A. Barrio, J. Becerra González, W. Bednarek, Lorenzo Bellizzi, E. Bernardini, A. Berti, Jürgen Besenrieder, W. Bhattacharyya, C. Bigongiari, A. Biland, O. Blanch, G. Bonnoli, Ž. Bošnjak, G. Busetto, R. Carosi, G. Ceribella, M. Cerruti, Yating Chai, A. Chilingarian, S. Cikota, S. M. Colak, U. Colin, E. Colombo, J. L. Contreras, J. Cortina, S. Covino, V. D’Elia, P. Da Vela, F. Dazzi, A. De Angelis, B. De Lotto, Francesca Del Puppo, M. Delfino, J. Delgado, Davide Depaoli, F. Di Pierro, L. Di Venere, E. Do Souto Espiñeira, D. Dominis Prester, Alice Donini, D. Dorner, M. Doro, D. Elsäesser, V. Fallah Ramazanı, Alicia Fattorini, G. Ferrara, L. Foffano, M. V. Fonseca, L. Font, C. Fruck, Satoshi Fukami, R. J. Garcı́a López, M. Garczarczyk, S. Gasparyan, M. Gaug, N. Giglietto, F. Giordano, Paweł Gliwny, N. Godinović, D. Green, D. Hadasch, A. Hahn, T. Hassan, J. Herrera, John Hoang, Dario Hrupec, Moritz Hütten, Tomohiro Inada, Susumu Inoue, Kazuma Ishio, Y. Iwamura, L. Jouvin, Y. Kajiwara, D. Kerszberg, Yukiho Kobayashi, H. Kubo, J. Kushida, A. Lamastra, A. La Barbera, F. Leone, E. Lindfors, S. Lombardi, F. Longo, Marcos López, R. López-Coto, A. López-Oramas, S. Loporchio, B. Machado de Oliveira Fraga, C. Maggio, P. Majumdar, M. Makariev, M. MallamaciThe Astrophysical Journal Supplement Series 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents an unprecedented, multi-instrument study of the blazar Mrk 421 during an extreme flaring event in April 2013. By combining X-ray and very-high-energy (VHE) gamma-ray data with high temporal resolution, the authors reveal complex, energy-dependent variability and correlations, favoring multi-zone emission models, particularly those involving magnetic reconnection.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Blazars, active galactic nuclei with relativistic jets pointed towards Earth, are powerful emitters across the electromagnetic spectrum. Understanding the physical processes driving their emission, especially during extreme flaring events, is crucial for unraveling the physics of particle acceleration and energy dissipation in astrophysical jets. Mrk 421, being a nearby and bright blazar, is an ideal target for such studies. However, previous observations often lacked the simultaneous, high-cadence, multi-energy coverage needed to disentangle the complex interplay of emission processes. This paper addresses this gap by providing a detailed, multi-band analysis of Mrk 421 during a particularly intense flare, aiming to shed light on the origin of its rapid variability and the correlations between its X-ray and VHE gamma-ray emissions.

Methods

The study leverages a comprehensive dataset from multiple observatories, including NuSTAR (X-ray), MAGIC and VERITAS (VHE gamma-ray), Fermi-LAT (gamma-ray), Swift (X-ray and UV), and ground-based optical and radio telescopes. The core of the analysis involves:

  • High-cadence variability studies: Analyzing light curves in 15-minute time bins to capture rapid flux changes.
  • Multi-band correlation analysis: Quantifying the relationship between flux variations in different energy bands using Pearson correlation coefficients and Discrete Correlation Functions (DCF).
  • Light curve modeling: Fitting the observed light curves with a two-component model (slow trend + fast flare) to characterize temporal evolution and identify achromatic/chromatic behaviors.
  • Spectral energy distribution (SED) analysis: Implicitly, by studying the energy dependence of variability and correlations, the paper probes the underlying emission mechanisms.
  • Correction for instrumental offsets: Addressing systematic differences between MAGIC and VERITAS VHE data through energy-dependent scaling factors.

Datasets

The study utilizes data from an extensive multiwavelength campaign on Mrk 421 during April 11-19, 2013. Key datasets include:

  • NuSTAR: X-ray data in three energy bands: 3-7 keV, 7-30 keV, and 30-80 keV.
  • MAGIC & VERITAS: VHE gamma-ray data in three energy bands: 0.2-0.4 TeV, 0.4-0.8 TeV, and >0.8 TeV.
  • Fermi-LAT: Gamma-ray data (>0.3 GeV).
  • Swift: X-ray (XRT) and UV (UVOT) data.
  • Optical & Radio: Data from various ground-based telescopes (KVA, Lowell, Crimean, etc., and OVRO, Metsahovi, IRAM).

A significant aspect is the 43 hours of simultaneous NuSTAR and MAGIC/VERITAS observations, enabling high-resolution multi-band analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Achromatic fast flares, chromatic slow variations: The rapid, sub-hour flux variations appear to be largely independent of energy (achromatic), suggesting a single, coherent emission process. In contrast, the slower, multi-hour variations show a strong energy dependence (chromatic), hinting at different emission regions or particle populations contributing at different energies.
  • Complex X-ray/VHE correlations: While X-ray and VHE gamma-ray fluxes are generally positively correlated, the strength and nature of this correlation vary significantly with energy and over time (day-to-day). This complexity challenges simple emission models.
  • Magnetic reconnection as a unifying framework: The observed phenomena, including the two-component variability and the energy-dependent correlations, are well-explained by a magnetic reconnection scenario. In this model, multiple plasmoids (blobs of magnetized plasma) contribute to the slower, chromatic emission, while a single, fast-moving plasmoid drives the achromatic fast flares.
  • No time lag between X-ray and VHE flares: For the fast flares observed on April 15th, the X-ray and VHE emissions are simultaneous down to a 3-minute resolution, providing a strong constraint on emission models.

Key Results

  • Substantial variability: Flux variations on both multi-hour and sub-hour timescales were detected across all X-ray and VHE gamma-ray bands.
  • Energy-dependent fractional variability: The fractional variability (Fvar) generally increases with energy, particularly for the hard X-ray and VHE bands, and is significantly higher during the flaring period compared to low-activity periods.
  • Strong X-ray/VHE correlations: The highest correlation coefficients were found between the lowest X-ray band (3-7 keV) and the highest VHE band (>0.8 TeV), with a near-linear relationship.
  • "Orphan" X-ray flares: Several fast X-ray flares were observed without a detectable counterpart in the VHE gamma-ray light curves, suggesting localized emission processes.
  • Lower limit on Doppler factor: A minimum Doppler factor of 35 was derived, consistent with previous estimates for Mrk 421.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model limitations: While the magnetic reconnection model provides a good framework, the "vanilla" model used in the paper cannot fully explain all observed optical variability patterns, suggesting the need for more complex multi-zone scenarios.
  • Temporal resolution: The loop-like structures predicted by some models for fast flares might be missed in real data due to limited temporal resolution (e.g., 15-minute bins).
  • Optical coverage: The lack of continuous optical coverage during the fastest flares limits the ability to fully test correlations between optical and higher-energy emissions.
  • Future work: The authors suggest that future studies with instruments like the Cherenkov Telescope Array (CTA) will offer even greater precision and enable more detailed investigations of blazar emission mechanisms. Further detailed modeling of the flux-flux correlations and spectral evolution is also planned.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract We report on a multiband variability and correlation study of the TeV blazar Mrk 421 during an exceptional flaring activity observed from 2013 April 11 to 19. The study uses, among others, data from GLAST-AGILE Support Program (GASP) of the Whole Earth Blazar Telescope (WEBT), Swift, Nuclear Spectroscopic Telescope Array (NuSTAR), Fermi Large Area Telescope, Very Energetic Radiation Imaging Telescope Array System (VERITAS), and Major Atmospheric Gamma Imaging Cherenkov (MAGIC). The large blazar activity and the 43 hr of simultaneous NuSTAR and MAGIC/VERITAS observations permitted variability studies on 15 minute time bins over three X-ray bands (3–7 keV, 7–30 keV, and 30–80 keV) and three very-high-energy (VHE; >0.1 TeV) gamma-ray bands (0.2–0.4 TeV, 0.4–0.8 TeV, and >0.8 TeV). We detected substantial flux variations on multi-hour and sub-hour timescales in all of the X-ray and VHE gamma-ray bands. The characteristics of the sub-hour flux variations are essentially energy independent, while the multi-hour flux variations can have a strong dependence on the energy of the X-rays and the VHE gamma-rays. The three VHE bands and the three X-ray bands are positively correlated with no time lag, but the strength and characteristics of the correlation change substantially over time and across energy bands. Our findings favor multi-zone scenarios for explaining the achromatic/chromatic variability of the fast/slow components of the light curves, as well as the changes in the flux–flux correlation on day-long timescales. We interpret these results within a magnetic reconnection scenario, where the multi-hour flux variations are dominated by the combined emission from various plasmoids of different sizes and velocities, while the sub-hour flux variations are dominated by the emission from a single small plasmoid moving across the magnetic reconnection layer.
BibTeX
@article{acciari2020unraveling,
  author = {V. A. Acciari and Stefano Ansoldi and L. A. Antonelli and A. Arbet Engels and Dominik Baack and A. Babić and B. Banerjee and U. Barres de Almeida and J. A. Barrio and J. Becerra González and W. Bednarek and Lorenzo Bellizzi and E. Bernardini and A. Berti and Jürgen Besenrieder and W. Bhattacharyya and C. Bigongiari and A. Biland and O. Blanch and G. Bonnoli and Ž. Bošnjak and G. Busetto and R. Carosi and G. Ceribella and M. Cerruti and Yating Chai and A. Chilingarian and S. Cikota and S. M. Colak and U. Colin and E. Colombo and J. L. Contreras and J. Cortina and S. Covino and V. D’Elia and P. Da Vela and F. Dazzi and A. De Angelis and B. De Lotto and Francesca Del Puppo and M. Delfino and J. Delgado and Davide Depaoli and F. Di Pierro and L. Di Venere and E. Do Souto Espiñeira and D. Dominis Prester and Alice Donini and D. Dorner and M. Doro and D. Elsäesser and V. Fallah Ramazanı and Alicia Fattorini and G. Ferrara and L. Foffano and M. V. Fonseca and L. Font and C. Fruck and Satoshi Fukami and R. J. Garcı́a López and M. Garczarczyk and S. Gasparyan and M. Gaug and N. Giglietto and F. Giordano and Paweł Gliwny and N. Godinović and D. Green and D. Hadasch and A. Hahn and T. Hassan and J. Herrera and John Hoang and Dario Hrupec and Moritz Hütten and Tomohiro Inada and Susumu Inoue and Kazuma Ishio and Y. Iwamura and L. Jouvin and Y. Kajiwara and D. Kerszberg and Yukiho Kobayashi and H. Kubo and J. Kushida and A. Lamastra and A. La Barbera and F. Leone and E. Lindfors and S. Lombardi and F. Longo and Marcos López and R. López-Coto and A. López-Oramas and S. Loporchio and B. Machado de Oliveira Fraga and C. Maggio and P. Majumdar and M. Makariev and M. Mallamaci},
  title = {{Unraveling the Complex Behavior of Mrk 421 with Simultaneous X-Ray and VHE Observations during an Extreme Flaring Activity in 2013 April <sup>*</sup>}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal Supplement Series},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3847/1538-4365/ab89b5},
}
Figure