Unpacking the Mental Health of Nurses during COVID-19: Evidence from Pakistan

Xinxing Xu, Faiza Manzoor, Shaoping Jiang, Ayesha MumtazJournal of Clinical Medicine 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the impact of COVID-19 fear and exposure on the mental health of nurses in Pakistan, finding that both significantly contribute to psychological distress and anxiety. While social support was found to have a limited moderating effect in this context, the authors emphasize its crucial role in mitigating these negative impacts.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The COVID-19 pandemic has placed immense strain on healthcare systems worldwide, with frontline workers, particularly nurses, bearing a significant burden. Beyond the direct risk of infection, nurses face heightened psychological distress due to the constant exposure to suffering, death, and the inherent uncertainties of the pandemic. While research has explored the mental health impacts of COVID-19 globally, there's a need for specific evidence from diverse settings, especially in developing countries like Pakistan, where healthcare resources and support systems may differ. This paper aims to fill this gap by examining how fear of COVID-19 and direct exposure to the virus affect nurses' psychological distress, anxiety, and overall well-being, and to what extent social support can buffer these effects.

Methods

The researchers employed a quantitative approach using cross-sectional data. They utilized multiple regression analysis to assess the direct impact of COVID-19 fear and exposure on nurses' mental health outcomes (psychological distress, anxiety, and psychological well-being). To explore the role of social support, they conducted moderation analysis using the Hayes process, a statistical technique that examines how a third variable (social support) influences the relationship between two other variables (COVID-19 fear/exposure and mental health outcomes). Standardized and validated questionnaires were used to measure the study variables.

Datasets

The study collected data from 250 nurses working in 12 public hospitals across the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (KPK) and Punjab provinces of Pakistan. Data collection occurred between May and June 2020. The sample predominantly consisted of female nurses.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Fear is a potent driver of distress: The study highlights that the fear of contracting COVID-19, even more than direct exposure, significantly contributes to nurses' psychological distress and anxiety. This underscores the psychological toll of the pandemic beyond the physical threat.
  • Social support's complex role: While social support is theoretically a buffer, this study found it to be "not very constructive" in the Pakistani context during the pandemic. This suggests that the quality and availability of social support might be more critical than its mere presence, and that existing support systems may have been insufficient to meet the overwhelming demands.
  • Nurses' well-being is critical: The findings reinforce the understanding that nurses' mental health is significantly impacted, and their well-being is paramount for the functioning of healthcare systems, especially during crises.

Key Results

  • Fear of COVID-19 was positively and significantly associated with psychological distress (coefficient = 0.532) and anxiety (coefficient = 0.326).
  • COVID-19 exposure was also positively associated with psychological distress (coefficient = 0.096) and anxiety (coefficient = 0.254).
  • Fear of COVID-19 had a significant negative association with psychological well-being (coefficient = -0.551).
  • COVID-19 exposure had a negative but insignificant association with psychological well-being.
  • The moderation analysis indicated that social support did moderate the relationship between fear of COVID-19 and psychological distress, anxiety, and psychological well-being. However, its effect on the relationship between COVID-19 exposure and psychological distress was insignificant, while it did moderate the association with anxiety and psychological well-being. The authors noted that social support was generally found to be low in Pakistan during this period.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Cross-sectional design: This design limits the ability to establish causal relationships definitively.
  • Convenience sampling: The sample was drawn from specific hospitals, which may limit the generalizability of findings to all nurses in Pakistan.
  • Focus on nurses: Future research could include other healthcare professionals (doctors, epidemiologists, etc.) to provide a broader perspective.
  • Single country study: Expanding research to other developing nations with similar socioeconomic contexts would be beneficial.

The authors suggest future work could:

  • Employ longitudinal study designs to better understand causal pathways.
  • Investigate symptoms of depression, stress, and anxiety in the aftermath of the pandemic.
  • Assess public perception of COVID-19 risk and its influence on preventive behaviors.
  • Explore the impact of different types and sources of social support more deeply.

Summary updated

Abstract

The prime objective of the present study is to test the effect of COVID-19 fear on the mental condition of nurses in the public health sector of Pakistan. This study seeks to measure the psychological distress, anxiety, and psychological well-being of nurses due to fear of COVID-19 and exposure to COVID-19. This research further reveals the moderating role of "social support" in the link between COVID-19 fear, exposure and mental health. Through a convenient sampling technique, 250 sample contributors were chosen from 12 public hospitals. The results were obtained by applying multiple regression and moderation analysis by SPSS and the Hayes process. The outcomes indicated that fear of exposure to COVID-19 affects the mental health of nurses. The findings also discovered that social support is not very constructive in the pandemic. However, we suggested that social support is the best weapon to encourage nurses to relieve their fear and minimize negative emotions.
BibTeX
@article{xu2021unpacking,
  author = {Xinxing Xu and Faiza Manzoor and Shaoping Jiang and Ayesha Mumtaz},
  title = {{Unpacking the Mental Health of Nurses during COVID-19: Evidence from Pakistan}},
  journal = {Journal of Clinical Medicine},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/jcm10163546},
}
Figure