Unpacking Mentorship: A Review of Its Role in Contemporary Postgraduate Surgical Education

Daniel Thomas, Thomas Oldfield, Hannah BamfordCureus 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This review synthesizes evidence from 13 studies on mentorship in surgical residency, revealing its crucial role in enhancing academic output, clinical skills, professional identity, and trainee well-being. Despite its clear benefits, inconsistent access and implementation due to time constraints, inadequate training, and institutional support gaps remain significant challenges.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the persistent inconsistency in providing effective mentorship to surgical residents. While mentorship is widely recognized as vital for developing competent, resilient, and well-rounded surgeons, access to it is often fragmented, informal, or insufficient. This gap is particularly concerning in the high-pressure environment of surgical training, where residents face steep learning curves, heavy workloads, and significant psychosocial challenges. The lack of structured mentorship can lead to increased burnout, uncertainty, and potentially impact patient care. The authors aim to consolidate current evidence on the impact, challenges, and enablers of mentorship in postgraduate surgical education to inform better practices.

Methods

The authors conducted a systematic literature review following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines. They searched major databases (Ovid Medline, Embase, Emcare) for studies published between January 2015 and July 2025 that examined mentorship in postgraduate surgical education. Inclusion criteria focused on English-language articles concerning surgical residency programs. Due to methodological heterogeneity across the included studies, a narrative synthesis approach was used to organize and present the findings thematically. Quality assessment of the included studies was performed using Joanna Briggs Institute (JBI) Critical Appraisal Checklists.

Datasets

Not applicable. This paper is a systematic review of existing literature and does not involve the creation or use of new datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Mentorship is a Multi-faceted Boon: It's not just about technical skills; mentorship significantly impacts academic productivity (publications, presentations), professional identity formation (career trajectory, leadership), and crucially, psychological well-being (reduced burnout, increased confidence).
  • Structured Programs Trump Ad Hoc: While informal mentorship can be helpful, formal, structured programs with clear goals, regular meetings, and institutional support yield more consistent and sustainable positive outcomes.
  • Peer Mentorship is a Valuable Complement: Near-peer and peer mentorship models offer accessible and relatable support, particularly beneficial during the challenging transition periods of early residency.
  • Time is the Biggest Enemy: The most frequently cited barrier to effective mentorship is the sheer lack of protected time due to demanding clinical schedules for both mentors and mentees.
  • Mentor Training is Underdeveloped: A significant challenge is the inadequate training and preparedness of mentors, leading to variable quality of guidance.
  • Institutional Buy-in is Critical: Without formal recognition, protected time, and administrative support, mentorship programs struggle to thrive and demonstrate long-term impact.

Key Results

The review included 13 studies and found consistent positive impacts of mentorship across several domains:

  • Academic Productivity: Mentored residents showed increased publications, presentations, and engagement in research and quality improvement initiatives. For example, one study reported a fourfold increase in publications per resident after implementing a structured mentorship program.
  • Clinical Competence: Mentorship supported technical skill acquisition and reflective learning, leading to improved procedural confidence and self-assessment.
  • Professional Identity and Leadership: Trainees reported clearer career trajectories and stronger leadership development. One study indicated that mentored residents were significantly more likely to pursue academic careers.
  • Psychosocial Support: Mentorship was associated with reduced burnout, improved confidence, and a greater sense of belonging, acting as a protective factor against stress.
  • Challenges: Key barriers identified include time constraints (cited by both mentors and mentees), insufficient mentor availability and training, and a lack of consistent program structure and sustainability.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Methodological Heterogeneity: The included studies varied in design (observational, cohort, qualitative), outcome measures, and reporting strategies, making direct comparisons challenging.
  • Reliance on Self-Reported Data: Many studies relied on subjective measures, increasing the risk of bias.
  • Short Follow-up Durations: The long-term sustainability of mentorship effects was difficult to assess in many studies.
  • Inconsistent Definition of Mentor Factors: Key mentor attributes like experience and commitment were not consistently defined or measured.
  • Lack of Standardized Evaluation: The absence of validated instruments to assess mentorship effectiveness hinders cross-study comparisons and program improvement.

Future research should focus on:

  • Developing standardized outcome measures for mentorship effectiveness.
  • Conducting longitudinal studies to assess long-term impacts on career progression and leadership.
  • Exploring innovative mentorship delivery models, such as digital and group-based approaches.
  • Evaluating mentorship interventions across diverse populations to promote equity in surgical training.
  • Prioritizing protected time for mentorship, formal mentor training, and institutional recognition of mentorship as an academic contribution.

Summary updated

Abstract

Mentorship is a cornerstone of postgraduate surgical education, supporting the development of clinical competence, research capability, professional identity, and psychological well-being. Despite its recognised importance, access to effective mentorship during surgical training remains inconsistent. This review aimed to evaluate the role, impact, and challenges of mentorship within postgraduate surgical education. A systematic review was conducted according to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses guidelines. Comprehensive searches of Ovid Medline, Embase, and Emcare identified studies published between 2015 and 2025 that examined mentorship in surgical residency programs. Eligible studies explored mentorship models, outcomes, and implementation strategies. Data were extracted on study design, participant characteristics, mentorship approaches, and key outcomes. Due to methodological heterogeneity, findings were synthesised narratively. In total, 13 studies met the inclusion criteria, encompassing a range of surgical specialties and mentorship formats. Mentorship demonstrated consistent benefits across multiple domains. Structured programs enhanced academic productivity, with mentored residents producing more publications, engaging in research, and achieving greater scholarly output. Mentorship also improved technical skills, procedural confidence, and reflective practice. Professionally, mentored trainees reported stronger leadership development, clearer career trajectories, and higher examination success. Psychosocially, mentorship was associated with reduced burnout, improved confidence, and greater work-life balance. Peer and near-peer mentoring models further strengthened collegiality and accessibility. However, barriers such as limited time, inadequate mentor training, and inconsistent institutional support were frequently reported. Mentorship is integral to postgraduate surgical training, offering substantial academic, clinical, and professional benefits. Structured, well-resourced programs with protected time, trained mentors, and formal institutional recognition yield the most sustainable outcomes. Future initiatives should focus on standardised evaluation frameworks, long-term impact assessment, and innovative mentorship delivery models. Embedding mentorship as a core component of surgical education is essential for cultivating competent, resilient, and future-ready surgical professionals.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{thomas2025unpacking,
  author = {Daniel Thomas and Thomas Oldfield and Hannah Bamford},
  title = {{Unpacking Mentorship: A Review of Its Role in Contemporary Postgraduate Surgical Education}},
  booktitle = {Cureus},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.7759/cureus.99455},
}
Figure