Unmanned air vehicle adaptability and application evaluation for new rice panicle fertilizers: Fertilizer characteristics and mechanical adaptability

Shilin Zhu, Wei Zhou, Zhu Li, Boteng Sun, Song Huang, Zhenyuan Wu, Qin Qin, Tao Wang, Yong Chen, Fei Deng, Xiaolong Lei, Youfeng Tao, Hong Cheng, Wanjun RenTechnology 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces two novel granular compound fertilizers designed for unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) application in rice cultivation. These fertilizers, formulated with urea, potassium chloride, humic acid, and synergists like PASP or GABA, exhibit controlled release properties and improved physical characteristics, leading to enhanced spraying uniformity and a significant increase in economic benefits for farmers.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional rice panicle fertilization often relies on manual application, which is labor-intensive, costly, and prone to uneven distribution, leading to reduced fertilizer use efficiency and economic losses. While Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs) offer a promising solution for uniform and efficient fertilization, existing granular fertilizers are not always optimized for UAV spraying. Specifically, the need for panicle fertilizers with a precise nitrogen-to-potassium ratio (30-50% N, 50% K) and suitable physical properties (hardness, sphericity, particle size) for UAV application presents a challenge. This paper aims to address this gap by developing and evaluating new compound fertilizers specifically engineered for UAV spraying, focusing on their chemical and physical characteristics, release kinetics, and field performance.

Methods

The researchers developed two types of compound fertilizers, Hcf-P (with PASP) and Hcf-G (with GABA), by combining urea, potassium chloride, humic acid (HA), and the respective synergist.

  • Chemical and Physical Characterization: Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy (FTIR) and Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) were used to analyze the chemical functional groups and surface morphology of the fertilizers. Physical properties such as moisture content, hygroscopicity, hardness, and sphericity were measured.
  • Release Kinetics: A soil column leaching experiment was conducted to study the nitrogen release rate of the new fertilizers compared to a control (Cf: urea and potassium chloride mixture). Various kinetic models (first-order, second-order, Elovich, Freundlich) were applied to describe the release mechanisms.
  • UAV Adaptability Optimization: An orthogonal simulation experiment was performed to optimize particle size, centrifugal speed, and flux for achieving uniform UAV spraying, using the lateral variation coefficient (CV) as the response.
  • Bench Testing: A bench test was conducted to evaluate the actual spraying uniformity of the fertilizers using a simulated UAV spreader.
  • Field Application: Field experiments were carried out over two years to assess the impact of the new fertilizers on rice dry matter accumulation, nitrogen accumulation, yield, nitrogen use efficiency (NUE), and net economic benefit (NEB) when applied via UAV.

Datasets

The study utilized experimental data generated from laboratory analyses, simulation experiments, and field trials. No pre-existing public datasets were used for training or evaluation. The field experiments were conducted in Dayi County, Sichuan Province, China, over the years 2020 and 2021.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Synergistic Chemical Interactions: The combination of humic acid and synergists (PASP/GABA) with urea and potassium chloride leads to the formation of stable chemical complexes (e.g., C-NH-C, -CO-NH-). This chemical interaction is crucial for modifying fertilizer particle morphology and influencing release behavior.
  • Controlled Release Mechanism: The formation of these complexes and particle voids results in a delayed fertilizer release, extending the effective nutrient supply period by 5-10 days compared to conventional fertilizers. This is a significant advantage for meeting the specific nutrient demands of rice during critical growth stages.
  • Optimized Physical Properties for UAVs: The developed fertilizers exhibit improved hardness (over 20 N) and sphericity (over 85%), which are critical for uniform distribution by UAVs. These properties reduce friction and prevent particle breakage during spraying.
  • UAV Spraying Uniformity: The optimized particle size range (2.07-5.13 mm) and the inherent physical properties of the new fertilizers contribute to a lateral variation coefficient (CV) of less than 15% in UAV spraying, meeting acceptable uniformity standards.
  • Economic and Agronomic Benefits: Field trials demonstrated that UAV application of these new fertilizers not only maintains or increases rice yield and nitrogen use efficiency but also significantly boosts economic benefits for farmers, ranging from 916 to 2742 CNY ha⁻¹.

Key Results

  • Delayed Release: Hcf-P and Hcf-G showed a sustained release of nitrogen, with cumulative release reaching 60% in 11 and 16 days, respectively, compared to 6 days for the control (Cf).
  • Improved Spraying Uniformity: The lateral variation coefficient (CV) for Hcf-P, Hcf-G, and Cf bench tests were 13.08%, 12.65%, and 14.89%, respectively, all below the 15% threshold for acceptable uniformity.
  • Enhanced Yield and NUE: In field trials, Hcf-G showed significantly higher dry matter, nitrogen accumulation, yield, and NUE compared to the control. Hcf-P also showed improved yield and a substantial increase in NUE.
  • Increased Economic Benefit: The net economic benefit (NEB) for Hcf-P and Hcf-G increased by an average of 916 and 2742 CNY ha⁻¹ respectively, over two years compared to the control.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Optimal Application Period and Rate: While the study suggests the new fertilizers meet nutrient demands during the young panicle differentiation stage, the authors note that further research is needed to determine the optimal application period and rate to further reduce costs and improve production efficiency.
  • Maximum Range of Particle Size: Although the current particle size range (2.07-5.13 mm) meets uniformity requirements, the authors suggest further investigation into the appropriate maximum range to potentially reduce production costs.
  • Long-term Effects: The study was conducted over two years. Long-term effects of these fertilizers on soil health and crop performance could be a subject for future research.
  • Environmental Impact: While the paper mentions environmental benefits, a more detailed life cycle assessment or specific environmental impact study could be valuable.

Summary updated

Abstract

High-efficiency fertilizers suitable for mechanical spraying can improve the fertilizer application and utilization efficiency. In this study, two types of granular compound fertilizers suitable for unmanned air vehicle spraying were developed using urea, potassium chloride, humic acid, and an amino acid synergist according to the fertilization requirements of rice at the booting stage. The physical and chemical properties of the compound fertilizers were analyzed by Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy and scanning electron microscopy. The release kinetics of the fertilizer was studied via a soil column leaching experiment. The effect of fertilizer particles on unmanned air vehicle spraying uniformity was studied via an orthogonal simulation experiment. Results showed that the chemical interaction between compound-fertilizer raw materials formed complexes such as C-NH-C and -CO-NH-, which caused a change in fertilizer particle morphology. This led to chemical monolayer adsorption or internal fertilizer diffusion, which in turn delayed the fertilizer release by 5−10 d. A simulation bench test showed that the fertilizer particle hardness and roundness exceeded 20 N and 85%, respectively, while the particle size was in the range of 2.07−5.13 mm, which resulted in good unmanned air vehicle spraying uniformity with a lateral variation coefficient of less than 15%. Finally, the experimental field results demonstrated that the new compound fertilizers, when sprayed by an unmanned air vehicle, could improve the economic benefit by 916−2742 CNY ha<sup>−1</sup> without reducing the nitrogen utilization rate and rice yield. The new compound fertilizers exhibit delayed release, good spraying uniformity, and improved economic benefit, rendering them suitable for large-scale promotion and application.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhu2022unmanned,
  author = {Shilin Zhu and Wei Zhou and Zhu Li and Boteng Sun and Song Huang and Zhenyuan Wu and Qin Qin and Tao Wang and Yong Chen and Fei Deng and Xiaolong Lei and Youfeng Tao and Hong Cheng and Wanjun Ren},
  title = {{Unmanned air vehicle adaptability and application evaluation for new rice panicle fertilizers: Fertilizer characteristics and mechanical adaptability}},
  booktitle = {Technology},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.48130/tia-2022-0001},
}
Figure