Unmanned Aerial Vehicle With Underlaid Device-to-Device Communications: Performance and Tradeoffs

Mohammad Mozaffari, Walid Saad, Mehdi Bennis, Mérouane DebbahIEEE Trans. Wireless Communications 2015 · DOI · OpenReview

Abstract

In this paper, the deployment of an unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) as a flying base station used to provide on the fly wireless communications to a given geographical area is analyzed. In particular, the co-existence between the UAV, that is transmitting data in the downlink, and an underlaid device-to-device (D2D) communication network is considered. For this model, a tractable analytical framework for the coverage and rate analysis is derived. Two scenarios are considered: a static UAV and a mobile UAV. In the first scenario, the average coverage probability and the system sum-rate for the users in the area are derived as a function of the UAV altitude and the number of D2D users. In the second scenario, using the disk covering problem, the minimum number of stop points that the UAV needs to visit in order to completely cover the area is computed. Furthermore, considering multiple retransmissions for the UAV and D2D users, the overall outage probability of the D2D users is derived. Simulation and analytical results show that, depending on the density of D2D users, optimal values for the UAV altitude exist for which the system sum-rate and the coverage probability are maximized. Moreover, our results also show that, by enabling the UAV to intelligently move over the target area, the total required transmit power of UAV while covering the entire area, is minimized. Finally, in order to provide a full coverage for the area of interest, the tradeoff between the coverage and delay, in terms of the number of stop points, is discussed.

Introduction

Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs) are increasingly being deployed as agile, flying base stations to boost cellular capacity in hotspots, support IoT networks, or provide emergency coverage during disasters. Simultaneously, Device-to-Device (D2D) communication—where devices communicate directly without routing data through a central tower—is used to improve network capacity by reusing existing licensed spectrum.

Prior research has studied D2D networks under fixed terrestrial base stations or UAV base stations in isolation. However, combining the two introduces unique interference challenges. Unlike fixed towers, a UAV's channel to the ground is highly dependent on its altitude (which dictates the probability of a clear Line-of-Sight) and its ability to move. This paper addresses how the presence of an underlaid D2D network impacts the optimal altitude, coverage performance, and mobility strategy of a UAV base station.

System Model and Methodology

The authors build a tractable analytical framework using several key techniques:

  • Stochastic Geometry: The spatial distribution of D2D transmitters is modeled using a homogeneous Poisson Point Process (PPP) to mathematically derive average interference.
  • Air-to-Ground Channel Modeling: UAV-to-user links are modeled with probabilistic Line-of-Sight (LoS) and Non-Line-of-Sight (NLoS) components, varying based on the UAV's elevation angle.
  • Mobility Analysis: For a moving UAV, path planning is mapped to the mathematical "disk covering problem" to calculate the minimum number of stop points required to fully cover a target area.
System model illustrating a mobile UAV serving downlink users (DU) while co-existing with underlaid D2D pairs.

Key Insights and Performance Tradeoffs

The study reveals a critical tradeoff: while moving the UAV to multiple locations improves coverage for ground users, it significantly increases both service delay and interference outages for the underlying D2D network.

  • Altitude as a Double-Edged Sword: Increasing UAV altitude improves the chance of a clear LoS connection but also increases path loss due to distance. A mathematical "sweet spot" for altitude exists, typically between 300m and 400m in dense urban environments.
  • D2D Density Impacts Altitude: As the density of interfering D2D users increases, the UAV must lower its optimal altitude to get closer to its target downlink users and overpower local D2D interference.
  • The Coverage-Delay Tradeoff: Providing highly reliable coverage requires stopping at more locations. For instance, increasing the coverage requirement from 40% to 70% requires increasing stop points from 5 to 23, resulting in higher service delays.
  • Mobility Penalties: As the UAV moves and transmits from multiple stop points, it acts as a roaming source of interference. Increasing stop points from 3 to 7 can increase D2D outage probability by nearly 0.20.

Conclusion

This research demonstrates that while UAV mobility and altitude optimization can significantly enhance downlink coverage, they impose severe outage penalties on underlaid D2D users. Future extensions could explore multi-UAV deployments and dynamic power control for D2D users to mitigate the interference caused by UAV mobility.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, the deployment of an unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) as a flying base station used to provide the fly wireless communications to a given geographical area is analyzed. In particular, the coexistence between the UAV, that is transmitting data in the downlink, and an underlaid device-to-device (D2D) communication network is considered. For this model, a tractable analytical framework for the coverage and rate analysis is derived. Two scenarios are considered: a static UAV and a mobile UAV. In the first scenario, the average coverage probability and the system sum-rate for the users in the area are derived as a function of the UAV altitude and the number of D2D users. In the second scenario, using the disk covering problem, the minimum number of stop points that the UAV needs to visit in order to completely cover the area is computed. Furthermore, considering multiple retransmissions for the UAV and D2D users, the overall outage probability of the D2D users is derived. Simulation and analytical results show that, depending on the density of D2D users, the optimal values for the UAV altitude, which lead to the maximum system sum-rate and coverage probability, exist. Moreover, our results also show that, by enabling the UAV to intelligently move over the target area, the total required transmit power of UAV while covering the entire area, can be minimized. Finally, in order to provide full coverage for the area of interest, the tradeoff between the coverage and delay, in terms of the number of stop points, is discussed.
BibTeX
@article{mozaffari2015unmanned,
  author = {Mohammad Mozaffari and Walid Saad and Mehdi Bennis and Mérouane Debbah},
  title = {{Unmanned Aerial Vehicle With Underlaid Device-to-Device Communications: Performance and Tradeoffs}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Wireless Communications},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1109/twc.2016.2531652},
}
Figure