Universal hidden monotonic trend estimation with contrastive learning

Edouard Pineau, Sébastien Razakarivony, Mauricio Gonzalez, Anthony SchrapfferarXiv 2022 · arXiv · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces Contrastive Trend Estimation (CTE), a novel method for universally detecting hidden monotonic trends in time series data, regardless of data type. By adapting contrastive learning with a loss inspired by the Mann-Kendall test, CTE bypasses traditional assumptions and demonstrates strong performance across diverse applications, including health monitoring and survival analysis.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Many real-world systems, from mechanical equipment to biological processes, exhibit gradual, monotonic changes over time. Identifying these "trends" is crucial for monitoring, prediction, and understanding system behavior. However, existing methods often rely on strong assumptions about data distribution or require expert knowledge to select relevant features. Furthermore, trends can be deeply hidden within complex, high-dimensional data (like sensor readings or images) and are difficult to extract without prior knowledge of the system's underlying mechanics. This paper aims to provide a universal, assumption-free method for extracting these hidden monotonic trends from any temporal data.

Methods

The core of the proposed method is Contrastive Trend Estimation (CTE). It leverages Contrastive Learning (CL), a powerful self-supervised learning paradigm, to learn representations that capture the underlying trend. Specifically, CTE adapts the Mann-Kendall test, a non-parametric statistical test for monotonic trends, to create a contrastive loss function.

Here's a breakdown of the approach:

  • Data Representation: CTE uses a neural network (NN) to embed each data point $X_t$ into a lower-dimensional space. This allows the method to handle diverse data types beyond simple numerical time series.
  • Contrastive Loss: For any two time points $t_u$ and $t_v$ within a sequence, where $t_u < t_v$, the method learns to predict whether the hidden trend at $t_u$ is less than or equal to the trend at $t_v$. This is framed as a binary classification problem. The loss function is derived from the logistic regression output and is inspired by the Mann-Kendall statistic, which essentially counts concordant and discordant pairs of observations.
  • Universal Applicability: By using NNs for embedding and a contrastive approach, CTE is designed to work with various data modalities (vectors, images, graphs, time series) without requiring specific assumptions about their structure or the nature of the trend's influence on the observed data.

Datasets

The paper evaluates CTE on several datasets:

  • Ball-springs systems: A simulated dataset for health monitoring, involving 10-ball-spring systems with simulated degradation.
  • Survival Analysis Datasets: Four public datasets are used:
  • Churn: Customer churn prediction.
  • Credit: Credit risk assessment.
  • GBCSG2: German Breast Cancer Study Group data for treatment effects.
  • Maintenance: Predictive maintenance of mechanical equipment.
  • CMAPSS dataset: A NASA dataset for turbine engine degradation simulation, used to evaluate CTE's performance under noisy trend conditions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Contrastive Learning for Trends: The paper demonstrates that contrastive learning, typically used for representation learning, can be effectively adapted to the specific task of monotonic trend detection.
  • Mann-Kendall Inspiration: Adapting a well-established statistical trend test (Mann-Kendall) into a contrastive loss function is a clever way to imbue the learning process with prior knowledge about monotonicity.
  • Universality Across Data Types: The use of neural network embeddings is key to CTE's ability to handle diverse data types, moving beyond traditional time-series-specific methods.
  • Strong Performance in Survival Analysis: CTE shows competitive or superior performance in survival analysis tasks, highlighting the deep connection between monotonic trend estimation and predicting event times.
  • Robustness to Noise: The method shows resilience to noisy trends, a common challenge in real-world applications.

Key Results

  • Ball-springs System: CTE achieved an absolute correlation of 0.97 with the true trend, matching or exceeding other methods like NFSA and TCL-ICA, especially when using a more generic embedding function.
  • Survival Analysis: CTE consistently achieved high concordance indices (CI) across four different survival analysis datasets, often outperforming standard models like Linear Cox, Neural Cox, Extra Tree, Random Forest, and Multitask Logistic Regression. For instance, on the "Credit" dataset, CTE achieved 77.2 ± 1.8, compared to the next best 77.0 ± 1.9 from Linear Cox. On the "Maintenance" dataset, CTE achieved 99.6 ± 0.4, while others were in the low 90s.
  • Noisy Trend: Experiments on the CMAPSS dataset showed that CTE, when combined with robust classification losses, can effectively handle noisy trends, maintaining good classification accuracy.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Identifiability: While the paper provides theoretical guarantees for identifiability up to a monotonic transformation, the exact nature of this transformation is not always known.
  • Interpretability: The authors suggest adding interpretability layers to CTE, such as attention mechanisms within the embedding functions, to better understand why the model makes certain predictions, which is important for industrial applications.
  • Multiple Trends: The current CTE focuses on a single monotonic trend. Future work aims to extend the model to handle scenarios with multiple independent underlying trends.
  • Restoration Events: The current framework assumes a single monotonic trend phase. Handling systems with multiple trend phases separated by restoration events is a potential area for future research.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, we describe a universal method for extracting the underlying monotonic trend factor from time series data. We propose an approach related to the Mann-Kendall test, a standard monotonic trend detection method and call it contrastive trend estimation (CTE). We show that the CTE method identifies any hidden trend underlying temporal data while avoiding the standard assumptions used for monotonic trend identification. In particular, CTE can take any type of temporal data (vector, images, graphs, time series, etc.) as input. We finally illustrate the interest of our CTE method through several experiments on different types of data and problems.
BibTeX
@misc{pineau2022universal,
  author = {Edouard Pineau and Sébastien Razakarivony and Mauricio Gonzalez and Anthony Schrapffer},
  title = {{Universal hidden monotonic trend estimation with contrastive learning}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2210.09817},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2210.09817},
}
Figure