Universal dynamics of spontaneous Lorentz violation and a new spin-dependent inverse-square law force

Nima Arkani–Hamed, Hsin-Chia Cheng, Markus A. Luty, Jesse ThalerJournal of High Energy Physics 2005 · DOI

Introduction

Lorentz invariance—the principle that the laws of physics remain unchanged for all inertial observers—is a cornerstone of modern physical theory. However, many candidate theories for quantum gravity suggest that this symmetry might be violated at extremely high energy scales. While much of the existing literature focuses on "explicit" violations—where symmetry-breaking terms are added directly to the equations of motion—this paper explores the consequences of spontaneous Lorentz violation.

In this framework, the underlying physical laws remain symmetric, but the vacuum state itself selects a preferred direction, effectively creating a modern "ether." Just as breaking rotational symmetry in a solid produces phonons or magnons, breaking Lorentz symmetry must produce a new dynamical particle: a Goldstone boson. This research identifies the universal low-energy properties of this particle and its potential interactions with the Standard Model.

The Goldstone Field and the Ether

The authors employ Effective Field Theory (EFT) techniques, specifically focusing on the non-linear realization of broken time diffeomorphism symmetry. They assume a scenario where time-translation symmetry is broken while spatial rotations remain intact, defining a preferred rest frame for the ether.

Deriving the Lagrangian for the resulting Goldstone field ($\pi$) reveals a significant departure from standard physics. Because spatial diffeomorphism invariance forbids a standard $k^2$ kinetic term, the leading term is $(\nabla^2 \pi)^2$. This results in a highly unusual non-relativistic dispersion relation:

$$\omega \propto \frac{k^2}{M}$$

where $M$ is the characteristic mass scale of the symmetry breaking. This relationship implies that the phase velocity of the waves vanishes at long wavelengths, a property that leads to several exotic physical effects.

A New Long-Range Force

Typically, massless bosons like the photon mediate $1/r$ potentials between charges, while spin-spin interactions (such as magnetism) fall off rapidly as $1/r^3$. However, due to the unique $\omega \propto k^2$ dispersion of the ether's Goldstone boson, it mediates a spin-dependent inverse-square ($1/r$) potential.

This makes the resulting force much longer-ranged than standard magnetic interactions. Depending on the mass scale $M$ (estimated between $10^{-3}$ eV and 10 eV), this new force could reach "gravitational strength," meaning it would be comparable to the gravitational attraction between two spins but with a distinct spin-dependent signature.

Ether Čerenkov Radiation and Parabolic Wakes

Because the phase velocity of the $\pi$ waves ($v = k/M$) goes to zero as the wavelength increases, any object moving relative to the ether frame—regardless of its speed—will eventually exceed the speed of some modes in the field. This triggers the emission of "Goldstone shockwaves," a phenomenon the authors term Ether Čerenkov radiation.

This radiation has a profound effect on the potential surrounding a moving spin source. Rather than a spherical field, the potential forms a parabolic wake or shadow. A test spin located behind the moving source would feel the full force of the potential, while a spin located in front would experience a suppressed, oscillating force. This asymmetry provides a unique experimental signature for spontaneous Lorentz violation.

Experimental Detection and Constraints

The authors argue that the unique angular dependence and $1/r$ nature of this force make it a prime target for precision tabletop experiments. Even if the force is significantly weaker than magnetism, its long-range nature and specific geometric properties could allow it to be isolated using torsion balances or other high-precision instruments.

While the energy loss for a single particle due to Ether Čerenkov radiation is extremely small (approximately $10^{-37}$ GeV/s for an electron), the cumulative effects in high-density environments or over cosmological timescales provide important bounds. The authors utilize parameters from neutron stars, laboratory magnets, and the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMBR) to constrain the theory, noting that if the scale $M$ is near $10^{-3}$ eV, this sector might even be linked to the physics of Dark Energy.

Conclusion

By investigating the universal dynamics of spontaneous Lorentz violation, this paper predicts a novel, long-range spin-dependent force and a unique form of radiation. These phenomena offer a potential "smoking gun" for physics beyond the Standard Model, providing concrete targets for next-generation experimental tests of our universe's fundamental symmetries.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{arkanihamed2005universal,
  author = {Nima Arkani–Hamed and Hsin-Chia Cheng and Markus A. Luty and Jesse Thaler},
  title = {{Universal dynamics of spontaneous Lorentz violation and a new spin-dependent inverse-square law force}},
  journal = {Journal of High Energy Physics},
  year = {2005},
  doi = {10.1088/1126-6708/2005/07/029},
}
Figure