Unintended Side Effects of Digital Transition: Perspectives of Japanese Experts

Masahiro Sugiyama, Hiroshi Deguchi, Arisa Ema, Atsuo Kishimoto, Junichiro Mori, Hideaki Shiroyama, Roland W. ScholzSustainability 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores the "unintended side effects" of the digital transition, moving beyond the hype to understand potential societal disruptions. It highlights the unique perspective of Japanese experts, who tend to focus on human-AI coexistence rather than existential risks, and calls for broader, culturally sensitive dialogues to navigate this complex future.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The digital transition, characterized by the pervasive integration of digital information and algorithms into all aspects of life, promises immense benefits for sustainability. However, this rapid shift also brings a multitude of potential "unintended side effects" – unforeseen negative consequences that could disrupt societal structures and human well-being. While discussions on these effects have begun, they are often limited in scope and regional coverage, predominantly driven by Western perspectives. This paper addresses the need for a more inclusive and nuanced understanding of these side effects, particularly by incorporating the perspectives of experts from non-Western contexts like Japan, and by advocating for transdisciplinary approaches to address these challenges.

Methods

The primary method employed in this paper is an expert roundtable discussion. In February 2017, a group of Japanese experts from various disciplinary backgrounds convened at the University of Tokyo to discuss the unintended side effects of the digital transition. Participants were asked to present their ideas and propositions, which were then transcribed, analyzed, and structured. Following the roundtable, a Delphi-like procedure was used to refine these propositions. The paper also draws on existing literature and policy documents related to digital transition, AI, and sustainability.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Cultural Context Matters: The paper emphasizes that expert perspectives on digital transition are shaped by cultural contexts. Japanese experts, for instance, tend to focus on the practicalities of AI and robot coexistence with humans, rather than the more existential "technological singularity" concerns prevalent in Western discourse.
  • Bridging Local and Global Conversations: There's a recognized need to connect Japan's domestic discussions on digital transition with the broader global dialogue, ensuring that diverse viewpoints are heard and considered.
  • Beyond "Have-Nots" to "Want-Nots": The digital divide is not just about access (have-nots) but also about choice (want-nots) – individuals who consciously opt out of digital technologies. This distinction is crucial for inclusive societal planning.
  • AI Bias and Global Risk: The dominance of a few US-based tech giants in AI development raises concerns about inherent biases in technology that could disproportionately affect global populations.
  • Redefining Humanity and Human-Machine Interaction: The digital transition necessitates a re-evaluation of what it means to be human, including concepts of dignity, autonomy, and privacy, as well as the evolving nature of human-machine relationships.
  • The Interconnectedness of Risks: Digital technologies amplify the interconnectedness of risks across various sectors (security, finance, infrastructure), making resilience and robust governance frameworks essential.
  • Biotechnology and Digital Ethics: The convergence of digital technology with biotechnology, particularly genetic engineering, raises profound ethical questions about human identity, evolution, and the definition of life.
  • The Need for Transdisciplinary Approaches: Addressing the complex, multifaceted side effects of digital transition requires collaboration across disciplines and between science and practice.

Key Results

The paper doesn't present quantitative results in the traditional sense. Instead, it offers a qualitative synthesis of expert opinions and identifies key areas of concern and potential research agendas. The main "results" are the insights derived from the expert roundtable, which highlight:

  • A distinct Japanese perspective on AI and robotics, focusing on coexistence.
  • The identified unintended side effects, categorized under themes like "Humanity," "Technology perspective," and "Socioeconomic structures."
  • A call for broadening societal discourse beyond expert circles to include the public and stakeholders.
  • The identification of several propositions for future research and policy, presented in Appendix B.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Limited Scope of the Roundtable: The roundtable itself was limited to a small number of experts from a limited number of disciplines.
  • Indicative Nature of Findings: The results should be interpreted as indicative, serving as a starting point for further discussion and research.

Future work suggested by the paper includes:

  • Fostering Broader Domestic Conversations: Expanding the societal debate on digital transition within Japan, involving a more diverse range of experts and the lay public.
  • Bridging Domestic and Global Dialogues: Connecting Japan's unique perspectives with the global conversation on digital transition.
  • Developing Methodological Tools: Creating new methods for fast, yet meaningful, societal dialogues to keep pace with rapid technological advancements.
  • Pursuing Responsible Innovation: Revisiting the research agenda for AI and other digital technologies, in collaboration with stakeholders.
  • Further Expert Roundtables: The paper mentions plans for subsequent roundtables in Europe and North America to gather broader perspectives.

Summary updated

Abstract

The core of the digital transition is the representation of all kinds of real-world entities and processes and an increasing number of cognitive processes by digital information and algorithms on computers. These allow for seemingly unlimited storage, operation, retrieval, and transmission capacities that make digital tools economically available for all domains of society and empower human action, particularly combined with real-world interfaces such as displays, robots, sensors, 3D printers, etc. Digital technologies are general-purpose technologies providing unprecedented potential benefits for sustainability. However, they will bring about a multitude of potential unintended side effects, and this demands a transdisciplinary discussion on unwanted societal changes as well as a shift in science from analog to digital modeling and structure. Although social discourse has begun, the topical scope and regional coverage have been limited. Here, we report on an expert roundtable on digital transition held in February 2017 in Tokyo, Japan. Drawing on a variety of disciplinary backgrounds, our discussions highlight the importance of cultural contexts and the need to bridge local and global conversations. Although Japanese experts did mention side effects, their focus was on how to ensure that AI and robots could coexist with humans. Such a perspective is not well appreciated everywhere outside Japan. Stakeholder dialogues have already begun in Japan, but greater efforts are needed to engage a broader collection of experts in addition to stakeholders to broaden the social debate.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sugiyama2017unintended,
  author = {Masahiro Sugiyama and Hiroshi Deguchi and Arisa Ema and Atsuo Kishimoto and Junichiro Mori and Hideaki Shiroyama and Roland W. Scholz},
  title = {{Unintended Side Effects of Digital Transition: Perspectives of Japanese Experts}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3390/su9122193},
}
Figure