Unified Solar Modulation Potential for Same-Charge Cosmic Rays and Implications for Local Interstellar Spectra

Mengjie Zhao, Xing-Jian Lv, Xiao-Jun Bi, Kun Fang, Peng-Fei YinarXiv 2025 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

By analyzing 11 years of AMS-02 data, researchers have demonstrated that cosmic rays with the same charge sign share a unified solar modulation potential during periods of low solar activity. This finding allowed them to derive the "true" Local Interstellar Spectrum (LIS) for positrons without making prior assumptions about its shape, confirming a significant positron excess that points toward exotic primary sources like pulsars or dark matter.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cosmic rays (CRs) arriving at Earth are not the same as those traveling through interstellar space. As they enter our solar system, they encounter the "heliosphere"—a bubble created by the solar wind and its magnetic field. This environment slows down and deflects low-energy particles, a process called solar modulation.

To understand the origins of cosmic rays (the Local Interstellar Spectrum or LIS), scientists must "demodulate" the data collected by detectors like AMS-02 on the International Space Station. However, there is a classic "chicken-and-egg" problem: to calculate the modulation effect, you usually need to know the LIS, but to find the LIS, you need to know the modulation. While the Voyager spacecraft provided a rare glimpse of the unmodulated proton LIS by traveling outside the heliosphere, the LIS for other particles like positrons remains shrouded in uncertainty.

Methods

The authors employ the Force-Field Approximation (FFA), a widely used but simplified model that characterizes solar modulation using a single parameter: the modulation potential ($\phi$).

Their novel approach involves a "Non-LIS method." Instead of guessing the LIS shape, they look at how the measured flux of a particle species changes relative to a reference time (solar minimum). This allows them to calculate the temporal variation of the modulation potential ($\Delta\phi$) independently for different particles.

They then use the GALPROP framework—a numerical code for CR propagation—to fit the proton LIS using both AMS-02 and Voyager 1 data. Once the proton modulation is well-constrained, they apply that same potential to positrons, assuming that particles with the same charge sign experience the same heliospheric conditions.

Datasets

  • AMS-02 (Alpha Magnetic Spectrometer): High-precision temporal flux measurements for protons ($p$), antiprotons ($\bar{p}$), electrons ($e^-$), and positrons ($e^+$) spanning May 2011 to June 2022.
  • Voyager 1: Direct measurements of the proton spectrum outside the heliosphere (3 MeV to 300 MeV).
  • AMS-02 Heavy Nuclei: Data for Helium through Oxygen were used to validate that all positively charged nuclei share a consistent modulation potential.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Charge-Sign Symmetry: The study confirms that solar modulation is highly dependent on the sign of the particle's charge. Protons and positrons (both positive) show nearly identical temporal variations ($\Delta\phi$), as do electrons and antiprotons (both negative).
  • FFA Validity: The simple Force-Field Approximation is remarkably accurate during Low Solar Activity (LSA). However, it struggles during High Solar Activity (HSA), likely because the model ignores complex "drift effects" and the rigidity-dependent nature of diffusion when the solar magnetic field is turbulent.
  • Unified Potential: Because $p$ and $e^+$ share a modulation potential, we can use the well-known proton LIS to "unlock" the positron LIS. This removes the need for theoretical models of positron production during the demodulation process.

Key Results

  • Reference Potential: The best-fit modulation potential during the solar minimum was determined to be $\phi_0 = 0.32$ GV.
  • Positron LIS Discovery: The derived positron LIS (the spectrum outside our solar system) shows a clear and significant excess at energies above 3 GV compared to standard "secondary" production models (where positrons are just byproducts of CR collisions with interstellar gas).
  • Primary Sources Required: This discrepancy confirms that "secondary-only" models cannot explain the positron flux. There must be primary sources of positrons in our galaxy, such as Pulsar Wind Nebulae or potentially dark matter annihilation.

Limitations and Future Work

The primary limitation is the FFA model itself during periods of high solar activity. The authors noted that during the solar maximum, the modulation becomes "rigidity-dependent," meaning the single-parameter $\phi$ is no longer sufficient to describe the physics.

Future work will likely focus on:

  1. Developing more realistic drift models to explain the "hysteresis" (time lags) observed between positively and negatively charged particles.
  2. Breaking the degeneracy for electrons and antiprotons. Unlike protons, we don't have a "Voyager" measurement for these particles outside the heliosphere, making it harder to pin down their absolute LIS.
  3. Refining primary positron source models now that a more reliable LIS is available for quantitative testing.

Summary updated

Abstract

The energy spectra of cosmic rays (CRs) below tens of GeV are significantly modulated by solar activity within the heliosphere. To investigate the properties of Galactic CRs, it is important to determine the unmodulated local interstellar spectrum (LIS). Recent high-precision temporal measurements of CR energy spectra, released by the AMS-02 collaboration, provide a crucial observational foundation for this endeavor. In this study, we employ the widely used force-field approximation (FFA) model to analyze the AMS-02 data, and attempt to derive the LIS for CR protons and positrons. By applying a non-LIS method, we derive temporal variations of the relative solar modulation potential, $Δϕ$, for individual particle species. Our analysis demonstrates that the FFA provides sufficient accuracy in explaining the AMS-02 spectral measurements of all particles during the low solar activity period. Notably, the derived $Δϕ(t)$ for protons and positrons, as well as for electrons and antiprotons, exhibit excellent consistency, indicating that particles with the same charge sign can be effectively described within a unified FFA framework during the low solar activity period. Having established a well-constrained proton LIS and its associated modulation potential, we apply the common modulation behavior between positrons and protons to demodulate the AMS-02 positron measurements, and derive the positron LIS without necessitating prior knowledge of its characteristics. This LIS is useful for quantitative investigations into potential exotic origins of CR positrons.
BibTeX
@misc{zhao2025unified,
  author = {Mengjie Zhao and Xing-Jian Lv and Xiao-Jun Bi and Kun Fang and Peng-Fei Yin},
  title = {{Unified Solar Modulation Potential for Same-Charge Cosmic Rays and Implications for Local Interstellar Spectra}},
  year = {2025},
  eprint = {2504.10742},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2504.10742},
  howpublished = {arXiv},
}
Figure