Unheeded SARS-CoV-2 proteins? A deep look into negative-sense RNA

Martin Bartas, Adriana Volná, Christopher A. Beaudoin, Ebbe Toftgaard Poulsen, Jiří Červeň, Václav Brázda, Vladimı́r Špunda, Tom L. Blundell, Petr PečínkabioRxiv 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores the underappreciated potential for SARS-CoV-2's negative-sense RNA intermediates to encode proteins. Using advanced bioinformatics, the researchers identified nine novel "negative-sense ORFs" (nsORFs) with characteristics suggesting they can be translated, potentially revealing a hidden layer of SARS-CoV-2's molecular machinery and its role in infection.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

For a long time, it was assumed that positive-sense RNA viruses, like SARS-CoV-2, only used their positive-sense RNA strand for protein production. However, recent research has shown that the negative-sense RNA intermediates, which are crucial for viral replication, can also harbor protein-coding regions. Despite this emerging understanding, the potential for SARS-CoV-2's negative-sense RNA to encode proteins remained largely unexplored. This paper aims to fill that gap by systematically investigating the SARS-CoV-2 negative-sense RNA for the presence and validity of these "negative-sense ORFs" (nsORFs). Understanding these potential nsORFs is important because they could represent undiscovered viral proteins that play a significant role in the virus's life cycle and the pathogenesis of COVID-19.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged bioinformatics approach to identify and characterize potential nsORFs.

  • ORF and Translation Initiation Site (TIS) Detection: They used four distinct computational tools (TISrover, ATGpr, NCBI ORFfinder, and StarORF) to identify potential open reading frames (ORFs) and eukaryotic translation initiation sites (TIS), specifically looking for the "Kozak sequence" which is known to enhance translation efficiency.
  • Codon Bias Analysis: They analyzed the codon usage of the identified nsORFs and compared it to the human genome using the Codon Adaptability Index (CAI). A higher CAI suggests better adaptation to the host's translational machinery.
  • RNA Interaction Motif Analysis: They used the Beam RNA Interaction motif search tool to predict potential binding motifs for human proteins, suggesting how these nsORFs might interact with host cellular components.
  • Homology Searches: Standard tools like Pfam and SMART were used to search for homologous genes in known protein databases, though many nsORFs lacked clear matches.
  • Proteomics and Ribo-Seq Meta-searches: They re-analyzed existing mass spectrometry (proteomics) and ribosome profiling data from SARS-CoV-2 infected cells to see if these nsORFs were actually translated.
  • 3D Structure Prediction and Modeling: For the identified nsORFs, they predicted three-dimensional protein structures using ab initio modeling (trRosetta) and refined them with other tools. They also performed structural similarity comparisons with known proteins.
  • Evolutionary Conservation Analysis: They used tools like SimpleSynteny to examine if these nsORFs were conserved across related coronaviruses, indicating their potential importance.

Datasets

The primary dataset used was the SARS-CoV-2 reference genome (NC_045512.2). Additionally, the study re-analyzed publicly available proteomics and ribosome profiling data from previous SARS-CoV-2 infection studies involving human primary alveolar macrophages and Vero E6 cells. For evolutionary conservation analysis, the genomes of several related coronaviruses were used, including Bat coronavirus RaTG13, Bat SARS-like coronavirus isolate bat-SL-CoVZC45, SARS coronavirus Tor2, Coronavirus BtRs-BetaCoV/YN2018A, MERS-CoV isolate HCoVEMC2012, and Human-CoV-OC43.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • A Hidden Proteome: The most significant insight is the identification of nine novel nsORFs on the negative-sense RNA strand of SARS-CoV-2 that possess characteristics suggesting they can be translated into proteins. This hints at a previously unrecognized layer of viral protein production.
  • Functional Potential: Several nsORFs showed strong eukaryotic translation initiation signals and high codon adaptability, suggesting efficient translation in human cells.
  • Host Interaction Potential: Many nsORFs were predicted to interact with RNA-binding proteins and other human cellular factors, hinting at their involvement in modulating host responses or viral replication.
  • Evolutionary Significance: The conservation of some nsORFs across related coronaviruses suggests they are not mere transcriptional noise but have likely evolved to serve important functions.
  • Structural Intrigue: The predicted 3D structures of these nsORFs revealed higher-order folding and similarities to known proteins involved in crucial cellular processes like DNA/RNA binding and immune signaling.

Key Results

  • Nine Putative nsORFs Identified: The study identified nine nsORFs that met stringent criteria for potential protein-coding regions, including strong Kozak signals and stop codons. These ORFs ranged from 132-300 nucleotides in length.
  • High Codon Adaptability: The average Codon Adaptability Index (CAI) for the nsORFs was 0.72, which is slightly higher than the average CAI for the positive-sense SARS-CoV-2 genes (0.68). Notably, nsORF4, nsORF6, and nsORF9 had CAI values higher than even the N protein of SARS-CoV-2.
  • Predicted Host Interactions: Several nsORFs were predicted to bind to human proteins such as PUM1, UPF1, MOV10, hnRNP L, U2AF5, and NCBP3, suggesting potential roles in host-virus interactions.
  • Structural Similarities: Structural comparisons revealed that some nsORFs are similar to known proteins involved in RNA/DNA binding, cell signaling, and protein degradation. For instance, nsORF9 showed similarity to interferon alpha/beta receptor 2, suggesting a role in inflammatory signaling.
  • Evolutionary Conservation: In the closest relative, RaTG13 coronavirus, nearly all nsORFs were conserved. In more distant coronaviruses, 3-4 nsORFs were still conserved, with nsORF2 and nsORF9 being the most consistently found across SARS-related coronaviruses.
  • Limited Experimental Confirmation: Despite the bioinformatics predictions, proteomics and ribosome profiling analyses were unable to confirm the translation of these nsORFs, likely due to their low abundance.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Low Abundance: The primary limitation acknowledged is the inability to detect the nsORFs through existing proteomics and ribosome profiling datasets. This is attributed to their potentially low abundance, which might be a compensatory mechanism for the lower levels of negative-sense RNA.
  • Experimental Validation Needed: While the bioinformatics evidence is strong, direct experimental validation is crucial to confirm the translation and function of these nsORFs.
  • Future Research Directions: The authors suggest that more focused and high-depth ribosome profiling or proteomics studies are needed to detect these low-abundance proteins in vivo. Further research could also explore the specific functional roles of these nsORFs in the viral lifecycle and COVID-19 pathogenesis, potentially leading to new therapeutic targets. The study hopes to stimulate further research in developing more specific and sensitive approaches to detect the complete SARS-CoV-2 proteome.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract SARS-CoV-2 is a novel positive-sense single-stranded RNA virus from the Coronaviridae family (genus Betacoronavirus ), which has been established as causing the COVID-19 pandemic. The genome of SARS-CoV-2 is one of the largest among known RNA viruses, comprising of at least 26 known protein-coding loci. Studies thus far have outlined the coding capacity of the positive-sense strand of the SARS-CoV-2 genome, which can be used directly for protein translation. However, it has been recently shown that transcribed negative-sense viral RNA intermediates that arise during viral genome replication from positive-sense viruses can also code for proteins. No studies have yet explored the potential for negative-sense SARS-CoV-2 RNA intermediates to contain protein coding-loci. Thus, using sequence and structure-based bioinformatics methodologies, we have investigated the presence and validity of putative negative-sense ORFs (nsORFs) in the SARS-CoV-2 genome. Nine nsORFs were discovered to contain strong eukaryotic translation initiation signals and high codon adaptability scores, and several of the nsORFs were predicted to interact with RNA-binding proteins. Evolutionary conservation analyses indicated that some of the nsORFs are deeply conserved among related coronaviruses. Three-dimensional protein modelling revealed the presence of higher order folding among all putative SARS-CoV-2 nsORFs, and subsequent structural mimicry analyses suggest similarity of the nsORFs to DNA/RNA-binding proteins and proteins involved in immune signaling pathways. Altogether, these results suggest the potential existence of still undescribed SARS-CoV-2 proteins, which may play an important role in the viral lifecycle and COVID-19 pathogenesis. Contact [email protected] ; [email protected]
BibTeX
@misc{bartas2020unheeded,
  author = {Martin Bartas and Adriana Volná and Christopher A. Beaudoin and Ebbe Toftgaard Poulsen and Jiří Červeň and Václav Brázda and Vladimı́r Špunda and Tom L. Blundell and Petr Pečínka},
  title = {{Unheeded SARS-CoV-2 proteins? A deep look into negative-sense RNA}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1101/2020.11.27.400788},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure