Unexpected Oversolubility of CO 2 Measured at Electrode–Electrolyte Interfaces

Zeke Coady, Samuel G. H. Brookes, Zhaohan Shen, Benjamin J. Rhodes, Grace Mapstone, Zhen Xu, Wei Yu, Hirotomo Nishihara, Christoph Schran, Angelos Michaelides, Alexander C. ForseJournal of the American Chemical Society 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals a surprising 30-fold "oversolubility" of CO₂ in microporous activated carbons saturated with electrolyte, a phenomenon previously thought to be limited to larger pores and incomplete saturation. This enhanced CO₂ uptake, driven by favorable CO₂-pore wall interactions, has significant implications for improving the efficiency of electrochemical CO₂ capture and conversion technologies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Electrochemical CO₂ capture and reduction technologies hold immense promise for mitigating climate change and enabling sustainable chemical synthesis. A key challenge in these systems is efficiently delivering CO₂ to the electrode-electrolyte interface where reactions occur. "Oversolubility," the phenomenon where gases dissolve to a much higher extent in confined liquids within porous materials than in bulk liquids, has been proposed as a way to boost CO₂ concentration at these interfaces. However, previous research primarily focused on mesoporous materials and incomplete solvent saturation. This paper addresses the critical gap in understanding oversolubility in microporous, solvent-saturated materials, which are precisely the conditions found in many electrochemical CO₂ capture and reduction electrodes. The authors aim to quantify this effect, explore its underlying mechanisms, and assess its relevance for practical applications.

Methods

The researchers employed a powerful combination of experimental and computational techniques:

  • Solid-State ¹³C Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) Spectroscopy: This was the primary experimental tool. By using ¹³C-labeled CO₂, they could precisely quantify the amount of CO₂ and its reaction product, bicarbonate (HCO₃⁻), both inside the pores ("in-pore") and outside the pores ("ex-pore"). This allowed for the direct measurement of CO₂ solubility enhancement (SE) and, crucially, an "in-pore" solubility enhancement (SEin-pore) that is independent of the total solvent volume.
  • Atomistic Modeling (Machine-Learning Potentials): To understand the microscopic origins of the observed oversolubility, the team used advanced computational simulations. These simulations employed machine-learning potentials trained on first-principles calculations, enabling them to model complex systems with high accuracy and at a reasonable computational cost. They simulated idealized pore environments to investigate the interactions between CO₂, water, and the pore walls.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on experimental measurements using activated carbon samples and electrolyte, and computational simulations of idealized pore environments.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Oversolubility in Micropores is Real and Significant: The most striking finding is the demonstration of substantial CO₂ oversolubility (up to 30-fold) in microporous activated carbons that are fully saturated with electrolyte. This challenges previous assumptions and opens new avenues for material design.
  • Adsorption, Not Absorption, is the Dominant Mechanism: Atomistic modeling strongly suggests that the oversolubility is driven by an "adsorption-like" mechanism. CO₂ molecules preferentially interact with and adsorb onto the pore walls, rather than being simply dissolved within the bulk liquid phase in the pores.
  • Pore Size Matters: Smaller pore sizes (less than 1 nm) were found to enhance the oversolubility effect. This is attributed to the increased surface-to-volume ratio and the confinement effects that favor CO₂ adsorption at the pore-water interface.
  • Functional Groups Are Less Important Than Pore Structure: The oversolubility effect persisted even in highly ordered, annealed activated carbons with reduced functional groups. This indicates that the intrinsic graphene-like structure of the carbon material plays a more significant role than specific surface chemistry.
  • CO₂ Adsorbs Parallel to Pore Walls: Molecular simulations revealed that CO₂ molecules tend to orient themselves parallel to the pore walls, which likely facilitates their diffusion and accumulation within these confined spaces.

Key Results

  • Up to 30-fold CO₂ Oversolubility: Quantitative ¹³C NMR measurements showed a solubility enhancement (SE) of up to 30 times the bulk solubility of CO₂ in 1 M Na₂SO₄(aq).
  • Significant In-Pore Enhancement: The in-pore solubility enhancement (SEin-pore), which is a more direct measure of the phenomenon within the confined space, was also substantial and showed a clear dependence on pore size.
  • Pore Size Dependence: ACC-10, with smaller average pore sizes, exhibited a higher SE (30.9×) compared to ACC-20 (26.2×).
  • HCO₃⁻ Formation: The study also quantified the formation of bicarbonate, a key reaction product, and showed how its presence contributes to the overall dissolved gas molality.
  • Computational Validation: Atomistic simulations confirmed the preferential adsorption of CO₂ over water at the pore-water interface, with CO₂ adsorption being energetically more favorable.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Idealized Pore Models: The atomistic simulations used idealized slit pores. The authors acknowledge that real activated carbons have more complex pore structures and suggest that future work should incorporate these complexities.
  • Disordered Carbon Structures: Extending the modeling approach to more realistic, disordered carbon structures is crucial for validating the hypothesis and refining the understanding of oversolubility.
  • Functional Groups and Defect Sites: Further investigation into the role of functional groups and defect sites in more complex carbon structures is needed.
  • Chemical and Physical Exchange: Future research should examine the balance between CO₂ stabilization and reactivity at the interface, as well as diffusion behavior and chemical/physical exchange.
  • Broader Applications: The concept of confinement-driven oversolubility should be considered for other gas-liquid-solid electrochemical systems, such as Li-CO₂, Zn-CO₂, Li-air, and Zn-air batteries.

Summary updated

Abstract

Enhancements in gas solubility in pore-confined liquids─termed oversolubility─can drastically influence gas separation and catalytic efficiency in confined environments; however, they remain poorly understood in electrochemical CO<sub>2</sub> capture and reduction systems. While previous investigations of oversolubility have emphasized the importance of mesoporosity and incomplete pore saturation by the solvent, in this work, we report an unprecedented 30-fold oversolubility effect for CO<sub>2</sub> in solely microporous activated carbons saturated with 1 M Na<sub>2</sub>SO<sub>4(aq)</sub>. The oversolubility effect occurs regardless of the activated carbon's functional groups and level of disorder and is enhanced for smaller pore sizes. Oversolubility is quantified using solid-state <sup>13</sup>C nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy (NMR), enabling differentiation between in-pore and ex-pore CO<sub>2</sub> and HCO<sub>3</sub><sup>-</sup>. Atomistic modeling of the system, based on a machine-learning model delivering first-principles accuracy, suggests that the effect is driven by an adsorption-like mechanism underpinned by favorable interactions between CO<sub>2</sub> and the pore walls. Our findings demonstrate the unexpected importance of oversolubility for gas uptake in microporous, solvent-saturated carbon electrodes, an effect with direct relevance for improving electrochemical CO<sub>2</sub> capture and conversion technologies.
BibTeX
@article{coady2025unexpected,
  author = {Zeke Coady and Samuel G. H. Brookes and Zhaohan Shen and Benjamin J. Rhodes and Grace Mapstone and Zhen Xu and Wei Yu and Hirotomo Nishihara and Christoph Schran and Angelos Michaelides and Alexander C. Forse},
  title = {{Unexpected Oversolubility of CO <sub>2</sub> Measured at Electrode–Electrolyte Interfaces}},
  journal = {Journal of the American Chemical Society},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1021/jacs.5c09712},
}
Figure