TL;DR
This paper presents the analysis of a collective burial site in Mougins, France, dating to the late 6th and early 5th millennia BCE. It reveals one of the oldest collective burials in the Western Mediterranean Neolithic, offering crucial insights into early European societal structures, symbolic practices, and dietary habits.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The study addresses the challenge of understanding early Neolithic societies in the Western Mediterranean, particularly during a period of significant symbolic and social change. Specifically, it investigates the Les Bréguières site at Mougins, which, despite its exceptional preservation of human remains and unique context, had limited documentation from its initial excavation in the 1960s. The paper aims to precisely date the site, characterize its funerary practices, and analyze the demographic and dietary patterns of the individuals interred, thereby contributing to a more nuanced understanding of this transitional period.
Methods
The research employed a multi-disciplinary approach:
- Radiocarbon Dating (AMS): Direct dating of bone collagen was used to establish a precise chronological framework for the site's use as a burial.
- Anthropological Analysis: Detailed study of the human skeletal remains to determine the number of individuals, their age and sex distribution, and to characterize the funerary assemblage as a collective burial.
- Isotopic Analysis (δ¹³C and δ¹⁵N): Analysis of bone and dental collagen to reconstruct the dietary habits of the individuals and animals, providing insights into their food sources and trophic levels.
- Lithic and Ceramic Analysis: Examination of associated artifacts to understand cultural affiliations and chronological context.
- Faunal Analysis: Identification and analysis of animal remains to understand their role in the burial context (consumption, offerings, or natural deposition).
- Geological Context Analysis: Understanding the site's geological setting (a fault) to interpret its use as a burial.
Datasets
- Human Remains: Skeletal remains of at least 61 individuals from the Les Bréguières site.
- Animal Remains: Faunal remains from the Les Bréguières site.
- Artifacts: Ceramic and lithic artifacts recovered from the site.
- Comparative Datasets: Isotopic data from other Neolithic sites in the Ligurian-Provençal region and Western Mediterranean were used for comparison.
Key Insights and Ideas
- One of the Oldest Collective Burials: The site represents one of the earliest known collective burials in the Western Mediterranean Neolithic, providing a rare window into this period.
- Significant Social and Symbolic Transition: The burial occurs during a time of profound societal and symbolic shifts across Western Europe, making its analysis crucial for understanding these changes.
- Dietary Diversity and Marine Resource Use: Isotopic analysis revealed a significant reliance on animal protein, but also, for the first time in this region and period, evidence of marine resource consumption by at least one individual. This challenges previous assumptions about Neolithic diets in the area.
- Complex Funerary Practices: The site suggests a complex funerary process, potentially involving secondary deposition or delayed burial, indicated by the modification of some human bones and the differential representation of skeletal parts.
- Potential for Further Research: The exceptional preservation and the large number of individuals offer significant potential for future research, including molecular and advanced isotopic analyses.
Key Results
- Dating: Eleven out of twelve AMS dates place the site's use as a burial between the late 6th and early 5th millennia BCE.
- Demographics: The assemblage includes at least 61 individuals, representing all age classes except perinatal individuals.
- Diet: Isotopic analysis indicates a predominantly terrestrial animal protein-based diet, with evidence of marine resource consumption in at least one individual.
- Artifacts: Ceramic analysis suggests a link to the Impresso-cardial to early Chassean phases, while lithic analysis points to connections with the VBQ sphere.
- Faunal Assemblage: The faunal assemblage is dominated by suids, caprids, and leporids, with evidence of both anthropogenic modification (consumption) and potential natural deposition.
Limitations and Future Work
- Limited Excavation Documentation: The original excavation by M. Sechter lacked detailed spatial recording, making precise reconstruction of depositional events challenging.
- Site Destruction: A portion of the fault cavity was destroyed by quarrying, limiting the understanding of the original burial context and the full extent of the site.
- Small Sample Size for Some Analyses: While the overall number of individuals is high, specific analyses (e.g., detailed demographic breakdown for adults, isotopic analysis for all individuals) are limited by sample size or preservation.
- Future Work: The authors emphasize the need for further isotopic analysis on a larger number of individuals to better understand dietary variability and potential marine resource use. They also suggest a revision of other karstic burial collections in the region, given the new chronological data from Les Bréguières. Further research into the mobility patterns of individuals and the socio-economic implications of the site's use is also recommended.
Summary updated