Understanding the spatial–temporal variation of human footprint in Jiangsu Province, China, its anthropogenic and natural drivers and potential implications

Feixue Shen, Lin Yang, Xianglin He, Chenghu Zhou, Jonathan M. AdamsScientific 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Understanding the spatial and temporal patterns of human pressures provides a foundation for understanding interactions between human and environment and managing human activities for a sustainable development. This study is the first attempt focused within China at calculating the spatial-temporal human footprint and its driving forces in a highly urbanized area with intensive human activities. Population, land use, night-time lights, and road impacts were used to generate human footprint maps of Jiangsu Province for 2000, 2010 and 2015 with a resolution of 1 km * 1 km. Five natural drivers and four anthropogenic drivers were employed to construct generalized additive models for explaining the spatial variation of human footprint and its change. It shows that a large difference is between the human footprint in northern and southern Jiangsu, and the pattern of human pressures conforms to the "Matthew effect", with spatial aggregation of high human footprint areas accelerating. Slope, industrialization level are significant in explaining the spatial variation of human footprint in 2000, 2010 and 2015. The effect of natural drivers decreases for explaining the human footprint over time. Furthermore, annual precipitation, mean annual temperature and urban per capita disposable income are also significant drivers for human footprint in 2010 and 2015. And the increasing of human footprint slows with increasing of industrialization level. The difference of industrialization level and urban income between northern and southern Jiangsu mainly caused different driving pattern for human footprint and its change. Our study has generated new insights on the interaction pattern between human and nature in highly developed regions based on the human footprint concept, and can provide references for managing human activities in similar regions rapid socioeconomic development.

Introduction

Jiangsu Province, China, represents one of the most densely populated and economically developed regions globally. A study published in Scientific Reports provides a high-resolution analysis of how human activity has reshaped this landscape over a 15-year period. By mapping the "human footprint" (HF), researchers have uncovered a fundamental shift: a landscape once governed by natural geography is now increasingly dominated by industrialization and urban wealth.

Methodology

The "human footprint" is a composite index measuring cumulative human impact. While often applied to wilderness areas, this study applies it to a "hyper-developed" context at a 1 km² resolution for 2000, 2010, and 2015. The HF was calculated by integrating four key pressure layers:

  • Population Density: Utilizing gridded population data (GPWv4).
  • Land Use: Categorizing impacts from "constructive" (urban), agricultural, and natural lands.
  • Night-time Lights: Capturing the intensity of activity via satellite data (DMSP-OLS).
  • Road Impacts: Weighting the influence of expressways, railways, and local roads by distance.

To disentangle drivers, the researchers employed Generalized Additive Models (GAMs), which are capable of modeling non-linear relationships, such as the plateauing effect of industrialization in mature regions.

Spatial-Temporal Patterns

The study reveals a distinct "North-South Divide" at approximately 32.5°N. Southern Jiangsu exhibits a continuous web of high human pressure, whereas northern Jiangsu’s impact is more fragmented, centering around specific urban hubs.

Spatial distribution of human footprint in Jiangsu Province for 2000, 2010, and 2015, showing a clear north-south divide and increasing intensity over time.

A key finding is the "Matthew Effect": human pressure follows the principle of "the rich get richer." Areas with an already high HF saw the most rapid increases, leading to an accelerating spatial aggregation of pressure in the south.

Driving Forces and Key Results

The research highlights a significant transition in environmental drivers. In 2000, natural factors like slope were the primary determinants of human impact. By 2015, anthropogenic factors—specifically industrialization levels and urban income—became the dominant explanatory variables.

Analysis of human footprint change (2000-2015) and the mean change across cities, categorized by contributing anthropogenic drivers.

Key findings include:

  • Widespread Increase: 79% of the province experienced an increase in human pressure between 2000 and 2015.
  • Model Robustness: The combined natural and anthropogenic GAMs explained 97.2% of the deviance in HF changes.
  • Industrialization's "S-Curve": While HF increases with industrialization, the rate of increase slows at very high levels, suggesting a "diminishing marginal utility" of expansion or the success of environmental policies in highly developed zones.
  • Ecological Success Stories: Despite the general trend, small areas in Nanjing and the Yancheng Nature Reserve showed decreased human footprints, demonstrating that targeted restoration policies can be effective.

Limitations and Future Outlook

The study notes that the "industrial structure" variable is broad and does not distinguish between different types of tertiary industries (e.g., eco-tourism vs. heavy industry). Future research should utilize even higher-resolution data and investigate the granular impact of specific policies. Furthermore, the emerging correlation between climate variables (precipitation and temperature) and HF in later years suggests a complex, evolving interaction between human activity and local climate that warrants deeper study.

Summary updated

Abstract

Understanding the spatial and temporal patterns of human pressures provides a foundation for understanding interactions between human and environment and managing human activities for a sustainable development. This study is the first attempt focused within China at calculating the spatial-temporal human footprint and its driving forces in a highly urbanized area with intensive human activities. Population, land use, night-time lights, and road impacts were used to generate human footprint maps of Jiangsu Province for 2000, 2010 and 2015 with a resolution of 1 km * 1 km. Five natural drivers and four anthropogenic drivers were employed to construct generalized additive models for explaining the spatial variation of human footprint and its change. It shows that a large difference is between the human footprint in northern and southern Jiangsu, and the pattern of human pressures conforms to the "Matthew effect", with spatial aggregation of high human footprint areas accelerating. Slope, industrialization level are significant in explaining the spatial variation of human footprint in 2000, 2010 and 2015. The effect of natural drivers decreases for explaining the human footprint over time. Furthermore, annual precipitation, mean annual temperature and urban per capita disposable income are also significant drivers for human footprint in 2010 and 2015. And the increasing of human footprint slows with increasing of industrialization level. The difference of industrialization level and urban income between northern and southern Jiangsu mainly caused different driving pattern for human footprint and its change. Our study has generated new insights on the interaction pattern between human and nature in highly developed regions based on the human footprint concept, and can provide references for managing human activities in similar regions rapid socioeconomic development.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{shen2020understanding,
  author = {Feixue Shen and Lin Yang and Xianglin He and Chenghu Zhou and Jonathan M. Adams},
  title = {{Understanding the spatial–temporal variation of human footprint in Jiangsu Province, China, its anthropogenic and natural drivers and potential implications}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-020-70088-w},
}
Figure