Understanding the spatial distribution and hot spots of collared Bornean elephants in a multi-use landscape

Nicola K. Abram, B. Skara, Nurzhafarina Othman, M. Ancrenaz, Kerrie Mengersen, Benoît GoossensScientific 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

Bornean elephants in Sabah, Malaysia, are increasingly using oil palm plantations, a significant shift from their historical forest reliance. This study maps their movements and identifies "hot spots" of high usage, revealing that while females prefer forests, males and some females heavily utilize oil palm for foraging and potentially due to fragmented landscapes. Understanding these patterns is crucial for developing effective conservation strategies in this human-dominated landscape.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Kinabatangan floodplain in Sabah, Malaysian Borneo, is a critical habitat for the endangered Bornean elephant. However, this region has experienced extensive deforestation and fragmentation, primarily due to the expansion of oil palm plantations and human settlements. This habitat loss has confined elephants to a landscape that is increasingly a mosaic of forests, oil palm estates, and community areas. A key challenge for conservationists is understanding how elephants are utilizing these diverse, human-modified landscapes, particularly the extent to which they are using oil palm areas and whether this indicates a problem or an adaptation. Without this knowledge, it's difficult to design effective conservation plans, identify crucial corridors, and mitigate human-elephant conflict.

Methods

The researchers employed GPS telemetry data from 14 collared Bornean elephants (11 females, 3 males) collected between 2010 and 2020.

  1. Range Mapping: They first mapped the "entire known range" for each elephant by creating Minimum Convex Polygons around all their GPS points. These individual ranges were then pooled to represent the collective range of the study population.
  2. Hot Spot Identification: To pinpoint areas of high usage within these ranges, they used a two-step statistical approach:
  3. Moran's I: This test was used to determine if there was significant spatial autocorrelation (clustering) in the elephant's GPS points, a prerequisite for hot spot analysis.
  4. Getis-Ord Gi* (Hot Spot Analysis): This analysis identifies statistically significant spatial clusters of high (hot spots) or low (cold spots) values. A high z-score indicates a tendency towards intense clustering of high usage.
  5. Land Use/Land Cover Analysis: They developed spatial data for land use and land cover for 2010 and 2015, classifying areas into protected forests, unprotected forests, oil palm estates, and oil palm smallholdings/villages. This data was overlaid with the elephant's range and hot spot data to quantify the proportion of time spent in each land use type.
  6. Statistical Analyses: Various statistical tests were used, including Pearson correlations to examine relationships between range size, hot spot size, and time spent; ANOVA to compare land use proportions; and k-means clustering to group elephants based on their land use preferences.

Datasets

  • GPS Telemetry Data: Collected from 14 collared Bornean elephants (11 females, 3 males) between 2010 and 2020. Data points were recorded at two-hour intervals.
  • Land Use/Land Cover Data: Developed for 2010 and 2015, based on modified data from Abram et al. (2014) and high-resolution satellite imagery (SPOT 5). This data was classified into:
  • Protected areas (Wildlife Sanctuary, Virgin Forest Reserves)
    • Unprotected forest
    • Oil palm estates (differentiated into large industrial estates and smallholdings)
    • Community areas (village areas and dwellings)
  • Cadastral Data: Obtained from the Land and Survey Department's online platform and the GeoRSPO platform to identify land ownership of oil palm estates.
  • Road Network Data: Digitized from SPOT 5 imagery and relevant maps from the Sabah Structure Plan 2033, including existing main roads and planned new roads/highways.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Oil Palm as a Significant Habitat: The study reveals that oil palm estates are not just incidental areas but are heavily utilized by a substantial portion of the elephant population, particularly males and some females. This challenges the notion that elephants strictly avoid human-modified landscapes.
  • Sex-Specific Habitat Use: A clear difference emerges between sexes. Females show a stronger preference for forests, while males, and some females, are more inclined to use oil palm estates. This could be linked to foraging opportunities, reduced landscape permeability for females, or "high-risk, high-gain" strategies by males.
  • Hot Spots vs. Entire Range: While hot spots constitute a relatively small percentage of an elephant's entire range (averaging 12%), a disproportionately large amount of time is spent within these hot spots (averaging 34%). This highlights the critical importance of these concentrated areas.
  • Impact of Infrastructure: The planned Pan Borneo Highway poses a significant threat, with nine elephants having hot spots that intersect with existing or planned road alignments. This infrastructure could fragment elephant ranges and increase human-elephant conflict.
  • Forest Fragmentation is Critical: Even unprotected forest fragments are vital, with elephants using them extensively. The loss and fragmentation of these areas, even outside formal protected zones, are major concerns.

Key Results

  • Pooled Range: The collective known range of the 14 elephants spanned 627.95 km².
  • Pooled Hot Spots: Nine hot spots covered 266.89 km² (43% of the pooled range).
  • Land Use in Pooled Range: 37% protected areas, 8% unprotected forests, 53% oil palm estates, 2% community areas.
  • Land Use in Pooled Hot Spots: 34% protected areas, 11% unprotected forests, 51% oil palm estates, 2% community areas.
  • Time Spent in Hot Spots: Averaged 34% of an elephant's time, with individual elephants spending between 10% and 60% of their time in hot spots.
  • Oil Palm Usage: Six elephants spent the majority of their time in oil palm estates. Males were consistently among the highest users of oil palm.
  • Road Intersection: Nine elephants had hot spots intersecting with roads, with time spent in these areas ranging from 2% to 44% (average 14%).
  • Land Use Classification Accuracy: High accuracy (97.3% with Kappa 0.96) for the developed land use/land cover maps.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Availability: The GPS data is not publicly available due to the risk of poaching endangered elephants.
  • Sample Size: While 14 collared elephants provide valuable insights, a larger sample size could offer more robust statistical power for certain analyses.
  • Future Work: The authors emphasize the urgent need for:
  • Protecting all forested habitats: This includes both protected and unprotected forest fragments, as they are crucial for elephant survival.
  • Improving oil palm estate management: This involves removing unnecessary barriers, cautiously using temporary electric fences, and developing comprehensive guidelines for managing human-elephant interactions within these estates.
  • Addressing infrastructure threats: The planned Sukau bridge and highway pose a significant risk of range fragmentation and increased conflict, requiring careful consideration and mitigation.
  • Integrated Landscape Management: Utilizing platforms like the RSPO Jurisdictional Certification approach to build an integrated landscape-level strategy for managing elephant ranges.
  • Long-term Coexistence: The ultimate goal is to foster long-term coexistence between humans and elephants in this multi-use landscape.

Summary updated

Abstract

In the Kinabatangan floodplain, Sabah, Malaysian Borneo, oil palm and settlements have reduced and fragmented lowland tropical forests, home to around 200 endangered Bornean elephants (Elephas maximus borneensis). In this region, elephants range within forests, oil palm and community areas. The degree to which elephants are using these areas remains unclear. We used GPS telemetry data from 2010 to 2020 for 14 collared elephants to map their entire known ranges and highly used areas (hot spots) across four land use categories and estimate time spent within these. The use of land use types across elephants varied significantly. Typically, females had strong fidelity to forests, yet many of these forests are threatened with conversion. For the three males, and several females, they heavily used oil palm estates, and this may be due to decreased landscape permeability or foraging opportunities. At the pooled level, the entire range and hot spot extents, constituted 37% and 34% for protected areas, respectively, 8% and 11% for unprotected forests, 53% and 51% for oil palm estates, and 2% for community areas. Protecting all forested habitats and effectively managing areas outside of protected areas is necessary for the long-term survival of this population.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{abram2022understanding,
  author = {Nicola K. Abram and B. Skara and Nurzhafarina Othman and M. Ancrenaz and Kerrie Mengersen and Benoît Goossens},
  title = {{Understanding the spatial distribution and hot spots of collared Bornean elephants in a multi-use landscape}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-022-16630-4},
}
Figure