Understanding the relationship between surfing performance and fin design

James R. Forsyth, Grant Barnsley, Mehrdad Amirghasemi, Johan Barthélemy, Alhoush Elshahomi, Buyung Kosasih, Pascal Perez, Stephen Beirne, Julie R. Steele, Marc in het PanhuisScientific 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates whether expert surfers can accurately perceive performance changes due to surfboard fin design modifications. By combining objective performance data from instrumented surfboards with subjective surfer feedback, the research demonstrates a strong correlation between perceived and actual performance, suggesting that fin design significantly impacts how surfers experience their ride.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The surfing equipment market, valued at billions of dollars, heavily relies on subjective assessments for product development, particularly for surfboard fins. While fluid dynamics simulations suggest that fin design (shape, surface features) can influence water flow and thus performance, there's a significant gap in understanding whether experienced surfers can actually perceive these subtle changes. This research aims to bridge this gap by quantifying surfing performance and correlating it with subjective feedback, addressing the question: "Can accomplished surfers accurately sense how changes to surfboard fin design affect their performance?"

Methods

The study employed a multi-faceted approach:

  • Fin Design and Fabrication: Four distinct fin designs were created: a commercial standard (COM), a 3D-printed replica (3DCOM), and two 3D-printed designs with grooved surfaces (G1 and G2). These were manufactured using computer-aided design (CAD) and additive manufacturing (3D printing) with continuous fiber reinforcement. Mechanical properties (stiffness and flex) were characterized to ensure comparability.
  • Instrumented Surfboards: The 3D-printed fins were installed into instrumented surfboards equipped with a sport-specific tracking device. This device combined GPS (10 Hz) and inertial measurement units (200 Hz) to capture detailed wave-riding performance data.
  • Surfing Trials: Six accomplished surfers (surf coaches, shapers, judges, researchers) with extensive experience participated in six sessions over six days at a consistent surf location. They surfed with each fin condition in a randomized, blinded order.
  • Data Collection:
    • Objective Performance Data: The tracking device recorded metrics such as total distance, ride time, number of turns, top speed, average speed, turn durations, turn magnitudes (yaw, pitch, roll), angular velocity, and turn flow.
  • Subjective Perceptions: After each fin condition, surfers completed a visual analogue scale (VAS) to rate their perception of "Drive," "Feel," "Hold," "Speed," "Stiffness," and "Turnability."
  • Statistical Analysis: Linear mixed models were used to analyze performance data and perceptions, accounting for individual surfer variability. Pearson product-moment correlations were employed to identify associations between subjective perceptions and objective performance metrics. Variance inflation factor (VIF) analysis was used to select relevant independent variables for predictive models.

Datasets

The study did not introduce new benchmark datasets. Instead, it generated novel data through:

  • Objective Surfing Performance Data: Collected from 214 waves and 835 turns using the sport-specific tracking device. This dataset captures detailed kinematic and dynamic aspects of surfing maneuvers across different fin conditions.
  • Subjective Surfer Perception Data: Collected via visual analogue scales (VAS) for six qualitative descriptors of fin performance, providing a subjective rating for each fin condition.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Perception Matches Performance: The most significant finding is that accomplished surfers' subjective perceptions of fin performance largely aligned with the objective data collected by the tracking device. This validates the idea that expert surfers can indeed "feel" the impact of fin design.
  • Grooved Fins Show Promise: The single-grooved fin (G1) was perceived by surfers as offering better "Speed" and "Feel" compared to other conditions. Objectively, G1 fins also showed improvements in bottom turn and cutback magnitudes, suggesting a tangible performance benefit.
  • 3D Printing as a Viable Alternative: The study demonstrated that 3D-printed fins, including those with novel grooved designs, exhibit comparable structural and functional qualities to commercially available fins. This highlights the potential of additive manufacturing for rapid prototyping and innovation in surfboard fin design.
  • "Feel" is Complex and Correlated: The perception of "Feel" was found to be negatively correlated with cutback pitch and rail angles in the G1 condition. This suggests that how a surfer experiences "feel" is intricately linked to the specific mechanics of their turns, particularly how they engage the rail.
  • Drive is Linked to Speed: Perceived "Drive" (the ability to maintain speed through turns) was positively correlated with objective top speed, indicating that a surfer's awareness of their speed directly influences their perception of how well the fin carries them through maneuvers.

Key Results

  • Preference for Grooved Fins: Surfers preferred the single-grooved fins (G1) for "Speed" and "Feel," followed by double-grooved (G2) and then commercial fins (COM).
  • Objective Performance Gains: The G1 fin condition showed statistically significant improvements in bottom turn magnitude and cutback turn magnitude compared to the 3DCOM fin.
  • Speed Perception Accuracy: For the G1 fin, there was a significant positive correlation between surfers' perception of speed and their measured top speed, indicating they could detect speed differences.
  • Predictive Models: Linear mixed models, while having moderate explanatory power (R² values between 0.06-0.26), identified bottom turn rail angle as a significant predictor for perceived drive, stiffness, and hold, underscoring its importance in subjective assessments.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Small Sample Size: The study involved only six participants, all of whom were male. While they were highly experienced, a larger and more diverse sample would enhance generalizability.
  • Single Direction Surfing: Participants only surfed left-hand waves. Future research should investigate performance and perception across different wave types and directions.
  • Environmental Variability: Surfing in an uncontrolled ocean environment introduces variability. The authors suggest future studies in controlled environments like wave pools to reduce variability and isolate the effects of fin design more precisely.
  • GPS Accuracy: While the tracking device is considered reliable, GPS technology can have limitations in accurately measuring distance and velocity in dynamic environments.
  • Future Research Directions: The authors recommend further studies that systematically manipulate fin characteristics and assess their influence on discrete surfing maneuvers. They also suggest exploring the relationship between fin design and objective performance in various wave shapes and conditions, and replicating the study in a wave pool to control environmental factors. The potential for 3D printing to accelerate innovation in the surfing equipment market is also highlighted.

Summary updated

Abstract

This research aimed to determine whether accomplished surfers could accurately perceive how changes to surfboard fin design affected their surfing performance. Four different surfboard fins, including conventional, single-grooved, and double-grooved fins, were developed using computer-aided design combined with additive manufacturing (3D printing). We systematically installed these 3D-printed fins into instrumented surfboards, which six accomplished surfers rode on waves in the ocean in a random order while blinded to the fin condition. We quantified the surfers' wave-riding performance during each surfing bout using a sport-specific tracking device embedded in each instrumented surfboard. After each fin condition, the surfers rated their perceptions of the Drive, Feel, Hold, Speed, Stiffness, and Turnability they experienced while performing turns using a visual analogue scale. Relationships between the surfer's perceptions of the fins and their surfing performance data collected from the tracking devices were then examined. The results revealed that participants preferred the single-grooved fins for Speed and Feel, followed by double-grooved fins, commercially available fins, and conventional fins without grooves. Crucially, the surfers' perceptions of their performance matched the objective data from the embedded sensors. Our findings demonstrate that accomplished surfers can perceive how changes to surfboard fins influence their surfing performance.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{forsyth2024understanding,
  author = {James R. Forsyth and Grant Barnsley and Mehrdad Amirghasemi and Johan Barthélemy and Alhoush Elshahomi and Buyung Kosasih and Pascal Perez and Stephen Beirne and Julie R. Steele and Marc in het Panhuis},
  title = {{Understanding the relationship between surfing performance and fin design}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-024-58387-y},
}
Figure