Understanding the Mechanism of Electrochemical CO 2 Capture by Supercapacitive Swing Adsorption

Grace Mapstone, T. M. Kamsma, Zhen Xu, Penelope Jones, Alpha A. Lee, Israel Temprano, James Lee, Michael F. L. De Volder, Alexander C. ForseACS 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper delves into the mechanism behind supercapacitive swing adsorption (SSA) for CO2 capture, a promising electrochemical method. By combining finite-element modeling with experimental data, the researchers reveal that CO2 capture is driven by the dynamic depletion and accumulation of bicarbonate ions within the supercapacitor electrodes, particularly at the gas-exposed electrode. This work highlights SSA as a kinetic phenomenon and suggests that optimizing operating conditions is crucial for improving its efficiency.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The urgent need to mitigate climate change has spurred the development of advanced carbon dioxide (CO2) capture technologies. While traditional methods like amine scrubbing are established, they often suffer from high energy demands and the use of toxic materials. Electrochemical approaches, such as supercapacitive swing adsorption (SSA), offer a more sustainable alternative, leveraging lower energy consumption and potentially non-toxic components. SSA utilizes supercapacitors to reversibly capture and release CO2. However, a significant hurdle in optimizing SSA has been the lack of a clear understanding of its underlying capture mechanism. This ambiguity makes it difficult to design more efficient and effective SSA systems. This paper aims to bridge this knowledge gap by investigating the detailed mechanism of CO2 capture in SSA devices.

Methods

The researchers employed a two-pronged approach:

  • Finite-Element Modeling (FEM) with COMSOL: A simplified computational model was developed using COMSOL to simulate the transport of CO2 and bicarbonate ions within the aqueous electrolyte of a supercapacitor. This model incorporated continuum transport equations, including Fickian diffusion and Ohmic conduction, coupled with the CO2-to-bicarbonate chemical reaction. The model aimed to capture the essential features of the experimental system, including the porous structure of the electrodes and the interaction of species with charged surfaces.
  • Experimental Electrochemical Measurements: SSA experiments were conducted using a custom-built gas cell. Various charging protocols (negative charging, positive charging, and switching) were applied to a supercapacitor device. The pressure changes within the gas cell were monitored to quantify CO2 capture and release. The study also investigated the impact of different charging current densities and prolonged voltage holds on the system's performance.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on experimental data generated by the authors and computational simulations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bicarbonate Dynamics Drive Capture: The core insight is that CO2 capture and release in SSA are not simply due to physical adsorption but are driven by the electrochemical manipulation of bicarbonate ion concentrations within the electrodes. Charging leads to either depletion or accumulation of bicarbonate, which in turn influences CO2 speciation and drives its movement.
  • Asymmetric Electrode Behavior is Key: The asymmetry in the supercapacitor design, where one electrode is preferentially exposed to the gas reservoir, is crucial. This asymmetry, coupled with the charging protocol, dictates whether CO2 is captured or released.
  • SSA is Inherently Kinetic: The experiments and modeling suggest that SSA is a kinetic phenomenon. At longer timescales or with prolonged voltage holds, the system tends towards equilibrium, leading to reversible capture and release, and thus diminishing net capture. This implies that efficient capture relies on operating within specific, shorter timeframes.
  • Low Current Density is Detrimental: Counterintuitively, very low charging current densities lead to reduced CO2 capture. This is attributed to competing processes at the two electrodes and the system having too much time to re-equilibrate towards a thermodynamic state, negating the capture effect.
  • Mass Transport Limitations Emerge at High Currents: Conversely, very high charging current densities also reduce capture. In this regime, the system becomes mass transport limited, meaning the rate of electrochemical charging outpaces the diffusion of CO2 and bicarbonate ions, hindering efficient capture.

Key Results

  • The computational model successfully reproduced key experimental observations, including CO2 capture during negative charging and release during positive charging.
  • The switching protocol, which alternates between negative and positive charging, demonstrated improved adsorption capacity compared to single-polarity charging.
  • Experiments with long voltage holds (6 hours) showed that CO2 capture becomes reversible, indicating that SSA is a kinetic, not a thermodynamic, process.
  • A peak in adsorption capacity was observed at an intermediate current density (around 30 mA g⁻¹), with reduced capacity at both lower and higher current densities. For example, a maximum CO2 adsorption capacity of 57 ± 4 mmol kg⁻¹ was reported at 30 mA g⁻¹.
  • The model predicted a maximal change in CO2 concentration (δρ) of 0.065, 0.10, and 0.15 for negative, positive, and switching charging, respectively, which, while lower than experimental values, were within an order of magnitude, validating the model's approach.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Simplifications: The authors acknowledge that their computational model is a simplified representation of the experimental device. It does not account for all potential physical mechanisms, such as the complex behavior of H+ ions near electrodes or other reaction pathways.
  • Experimental Challenges: The study mentions the need to reduce corrosion from chloride ions, leading to a change in electrolyte. The precise behavior of H+ ions in the system remains an area for future investigation.
  • Future Directions: The paper suggests that further investigation into kinetic and thermodynamic effects is crucial. Optimizing device and material design to facilitate faster mass transport of CO2 and bicarbonate ions is highlighted as a key strategy to improve SSA performance by favoring faster current densities. Understanding and exploiting these kinetic and thermodynamic trade-offs is presented as an important direction for future research.

Summary updated

Abstract

Carbon dioxide capture underpins an important range of technologies that can help to mitigate climate change. Improved carbon capture technologies that are driven by electrochemistry are under active development, and it was recently found that supercapacitor energy storage devices can reversibly capture and release carbon dioxide. So-called supercapacitive swing adsorption (SSA) has several advantages over traditional carbon dioxide capture technologies such as lower energy consumption and the use of nontoxic materials. However, the mechanism for the capture of CO<sub>2</sub> in these devices is poorly understood, making it challenging to design improved systems. Here, the mechanism of SSA is investigated via finite-element modeling with COMSOL of aqueous continuum transport equations, coupled to the CO<sub>2</sub> to bicarbonate reaction. This simple computational model reproduces the key experimental observations and shows that charging leads to bicarbonate depletion (or accumulation) in the electrodes, driving CO<sub>2</sub> capture (or release) at the gas-exposed electrode. This suggests that relevant aspects of the mechanism are captured without excluding other mechanisms that might be at play in parallel as well. At very low charging currents, both experiments and modeling reveal a decrease in the amount of carbon dioxide captured, suggesting the presence of competing processes at the two electrodes, and that SSA is an inherently kinetic phenomenon. This study highlights the importance of the operating conditions of these devices and may aid their development in the future.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{mapstone2025understanding,
  author = {Grace Mapstone and T. M. Kamsma and Zhen Xu and Penelope Jones and Alpha A. Lee and Israel Temprano and James Lee and Michael F. L. De Volder and Alexander C. Forse},
  title = {{Understanding the Mechanism of Electrochemical CO <sub>2</sub> Capture by Supercapacitive Swing Adsorption}},
  booktitle = {ACS},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1021/acsnano.4c10931},
}
Figure