Understanding the effect of refractory metal chemistry on the stacking fault energy and mechanical property of Cantor-based multi-principal element alloys

Prashant Singh, William Trehern, Brent Vela, Prince Sharma, Tanner Kirk, Zongrui Pei, Raymundo Arróyave, Michael C. Gao, D. D. JohnsonInternational Journal of Plasticity 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how adding refractory metals (like Nb, Ta, Mo, W) to Cantor-based multi-principal element alloys (MPEAs) affects their stacking fault energy (SFE) and mechanical properties. The findings reveal that even small amounts of these refractory elements can significantly tune SFE, offering a pathway to design MPEAs with enhanced plasticity and strength for demanding applications.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Multi-principal element alloys (MPEAs), often referred to as high-entropy alloys (HEAs), are a class of materials gaining significant attention for their exceptional mechanical properties, including high strength and temperature stability. A critical factor governing the mechanical behavior of face-centered cubic (fcc) MPEAs is the stacking fault energy (SFE). SFE dictates the dominant deformation mechanisms, such as twinning-induced plasticity (TWIP) or transformation-induced plasticity (TRIP), which are crucial for achieving both high strength and ductility. While the influence of some alloying elements on SFE is understood, the systematic effect of refractory metals—known for their ability to enhance high-temperature properties—on the SFE and overall mechanical performance of complex MPEAs remains largely unexplored. This paper aims to fill this knowledge gap by comprehensively studying how refractory metal chemistry influences SFE and related mechanical properties in Cantor-based MPEAs.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged computational approach:

  • CALPHAD (Calculation of Phase Diagrams): This thermodynamic modeling tool was used to screen a vast compositional space (over 1 million potential alloys) to identify candidate MPEAs that are single-phase fcc, possess high solidus temperatures (indicating good high-temperature stability), and have a narrow solidification range (important for manufacturing processes like additive manufacturing).
  • DFT (Density-Functional Theory): First-principles DFT calculations, specifically using the Korringa-Kohn-Rostoker (KKR) method combined with the Coherent Potential Approximation (CPA), were utilized to accurately calculate the stacking fault energy (SFE) for the selected candidate alloys. The KKR-CPA method is advantageous as it can handle arbitrary chemical compositions and model the disordered nature of MPEAs effectively. They also used an ANNNI (Axial Next-Nearest-Neighbor Ising) model for SFE calculations, comparing results from higher-order and lower-order models.
  • Solute-Solution-Strengthening Model: A reduced model based on Curtin's work was employed to predict the temperature-dependent yield strength of the alloys, incorporating DFT-calculated elastic constants and alloy volumes.

Datasets

The study did not explicitly use pre-existing datasets for training. Instead, it generated its own data through extensive computational simulations. The initial screening involved CALPHAD calculations on approximately 1,000,000 single-phase fcc MPEAs. This was followed by DFT calculations on down-selected candidate alloys, leading to the analysis of SFEs and mechanical properties for numerous compositions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Refractory Metals are Potent SFE Modifiers: Even small additions (around 5 at.%) of refractory elements like Nb, Ta, Mo, and W can dramatically alter the SFE of fcc MPEAs, often in ways that differ from their effects in simpler alloy systems.
  • Beyond Simple Correlations: The influence of alloying elements on SFE in complex MPEAs is not always straightforward. For instance, Mn's effect on SFE in these MPEAs differs from its behavior in simpler steels, highlighting the importance of considering the overall chemical complexity.
  • Electronegativity and Electron Affinity Drive SFE: The study identified a positive correlation between SFE and the variance in electron affinity (ΔEAvariance), suggesting that maximizing bonding strength through chemical tuning, particularly related to electron affinity and electronegativity, is key to controlling SFE.
  • Strength-Ductility Trade-off Management: By tuning SFE, researchers can potentially achieve a better balance between strength and ductility, moving away from the typical trade-off observed in many materials.
  • Ni-Rich Alloys Show Pronounced SFE Trends: Ni-rich MPEAs, even without refractory metals, exhibit significant and increasing trends in SFE, suggesting their potential for plasticity enhancement.

Key Results

  • The study identified specific compositions of refractory-reinforced Cantor-based MPEAs that exhibit optimal SFE values (15-30 mJ/m²) conducive to TRIP and TWIP mechanisms, crucial for enhanced ductility.
  • For example, MPEA8 (Ni60Fe5Cr5C05Nb25) showed a favorable combination of high yield strength (1069 MPa at 900 K) and good ductility (PR=2.33) with an SFE of 18.3 mJ/m².
  • The introduction of Nb in place of Mo in certain alloys led to augmented bonding and increased strength, attributed to enhanced charge sharing and hybridization.
  • The research provides a design guide for experimentalists, highlighting specific alloy compositions and elemental concentrations that can lead to improved plasticity and strength in fcc MPEAs.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Experimental Validation: While the study validates its DFT predictions against some experimental data for elemental solids and simpler alloys, direct experimental validation of the predicted SFEs and mechanical properties for the complex MPEAs studied is still needed.
  • Temperature Dependence of Elastic Properties: The solute-solution-strengthening model, while useful for comparative analysis, ignores the temperature dependence of elastic properties due to a lack of data and reliable predictive models.
  • Focus on Specific Refractories: The study primarily focused on Nb, Ta, Mo, and W. Future work could explore the effects of other refractory elements.
  • Manufacturing Considerations: While the CALPHAD screening considered solidification range for additive manufacturing, further detailed studies on the processability of the identified optimal alloys would be beneficial.
  • Broader Alloy Spaces: The study focused on specific Cantor-based MPEA systems. Expanding the investigation to other MPEA families could reveal broader design principles.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{singh2024understanding,
  author = {Prashant Singh and William Trehern and Brent Vela and Prince Sharma and Tanner Kirk and Zongrui Pei and Raymundo Arróyave and Michael C. Gao and D. D. Johnson},
  title = {{Understanding the effect of refractory metal chemistry on the stacking fault energy and mechanical property of Cantor-based multi-principal element alloys}},
  journal = {International Journal of Plasticity},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1016/j.ijplas.2024.104020},
}
Figure